No evidence of polarization in the 11.3 μ 11.3\,\mu m PAH emission line by independent analyses Facilities: GTC(CanariCam) astropy ( Astropy Collaboration et al. 2013 ; Astropy Collaboration et al. 2018 ; Astropy Collaboration et al. 2022 )
Enrique Lopez-Rodriguez · 2026
Read No evidence of polarization in the 11.3 μ 11.3\,\mu m PAH emission line by independent analyses Facilities: GTC(CanariCam) astropy ( Astropy Collaboration et al. 2013 ; Astropy Collaboration et al. 2018 ; Astropy Collaboration et al. 2022 ) by Enrique Lopez-Rodriguez (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2603-21205.txt.
Introduction
Lopez-Rodriguez re-analyzes a claim that a PAH emission line in a nebula is polarized. These hydrocarbons trace star formation and gas content, and their polarization could probe magnetic fields. An earlier study reported about two percent polarization in the 11.3 micrometer line of the MWC 1080 nebula. Using the same CanariCam data, he measures a value consistent with zero. He shows the earlier result follows from oversubtracting a constant instrumental term. Current dust models agree with the null result.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Enrique Lopez-Rodriguez |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 30621 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2603.21205
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
No evidence of polarization in the 11.3 μ 11.3\,\mu m PAH emission line by independent analyses Facilities: GTC(CanariCam) astropy ( Astropy Collaboration et al. 2013 ; Astropy Collaboration et al. 2018 ; Astropy Collaboration et al. 2022 ) Enrique Lopez-Rodriguez Abstract Polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs) are commonly used as proxies for star formation, molecular gas content, and other interstellar medium (ISM) properties in our Galaxy and other galaxies. Given their abundance and brightness, polarization measurements of PAH features could, in principle, provide a probe of the ISM magnetic field and intrinsic PAH properties; however, the diagnostic power of PAH polarization remains to be established. Previous studies reported that the 11.3 μ 11.3\,\mu m PAH emission line in the northwestern nebula of the Herbig Be star MWC 1080 was polarized at 1.9 ± 0.2 1.9\pm 0.2 %. This level of polarization was explained via the paramagnetic relaxation process, which may allow the characterization of magnetic fields in the ISM. Using the same observations, here, we re-analyzed the 8 − 13 μ 8-13\,\mu m spectro-polarimetric observations taken with CanariCam on the 10.4-m Gran Telescopio CANARIAS (GTC), and we measure a polarization of 0.5 ± 0.6 0.5\pm 0.6 % within 11.3 ± 0.2 μ 11.3\pm 0.2\,\mu m, consistent with an unpolarized source, 0.6 ± 0.2 0.6\pm 0.2 % (instrumental polarization). We reproduce the previously reported polarized PAH emission line if the polarization fraction spectrum is oversubtracted by a constant instrumental polarization and the polarization uncertainties, which is inconsistent with the fundamentals of polarimetric data analysis. Thus, the published 8 − 13 μ 8-13\,\mu m spectro-polarimetric data taken with CanariCam/GTC provide no statistical evidence for a polarized 11.3 μ 11.3\,\mu m PAH emission line, in agreement with current dust models. I Introduction Polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs) are carbon-based nano-sized molecules highly abundant in the interstellar medium ( B. T. Draine et al. 2021 , ISM; e.g.,) . These PAHs absorb ultraviolet (UV) and optical radiation and re-emmit it at infrared (IR) wavelengths, producing strong emission lines at 3.3 , 6.2 , 7.7 , 8.6 , 11.3 , and 12.7\,\mu m via their stretching and bending modes ( A. G. G. M. Tielens 2008 ) . Specifically for our study here, the 11.3\,\mu m band is attributed to C-H out of plane bending modes, whose strength depends on the size, structure, charging of the PAH, and the physical conditions of the environment ( L. J. Allamandola et al. 1989 ; B. T. Draine & A. Li 2001 ) . Although PAH formation and evolution mechanisms are still not fully understood, PAHs account for \sim 15 % of the interstellar carbon and \sim 20 % of the IR power of our Galaxy and star-forming galaxies ( A. Li 2020 ; L. J. Allamandola et al. 2021 ) . Thus, PAHs are typically used as proxies for star formation activity in galaxies and for the formation of molecular clouds. The brightness of PAH emission lines makes them ideal candidates for polarimetric observations, a technique that is typically photon-starved. If these PAHs are polarized, this may open a new window for studying their intrinsic atomic properties, magnetic fields in the ISM, the 10-60 GHz Galactic foreground in the cosmic microwave background that is thought to arise from rapidly spinning small dust grains ( L. Sironi & B. T. Draine 2009 ; B. T. Draine et al. 2021 ) , and the question of the carrier of the 2175 Å UV extinction feature. PAH polarization has been proved for since the late 80’s ( K. Sellgren et al. 1988 ) . Both in Davis-Greenstein ( L. Davis & J. L. Greenstein 1951 ) and modern radiative alignment torques (RAT) theory ( B.-G. Andersson et al. 2015 , e.g.,) , the internal alignment of the grains (aligning the spin axis with a symmetry axis of the grain) depends on paramagnetic relaxation ( E. M. Purcell 1979 ) . Paramagnetism arises when there are unpaired quantum spins in the solid, as in silicates. Carbon solids are diamagnetic and should therefore not show efficient internal alignment, nor couple to magnetic fields. Observationally, this is supported by the sensitive upper limits of polarization in the 3.4 \mu m line of aliphatic CH ( J. E. Chiar et al. 2006 ) and the centro-symmetric, radial polarization geometry of the carbon-rich envelope of the asymptotic giant branch star IRC+10216 ( B.-G. Andersson et al. 2022 ) . Another possibility, as originally proposed by A. Lazarian & B. T. Draine 2000 , and elaborated on by T. Hoang et al. 2014 , is that very small grains, including PAHs, may be aligned via resonance paramagnetic alignment. Recent modeling of far-UV (FUV) spectro-polarimetry (Tram et al. 2026, submitted) indicates that if active, this mechanism is sub-dominant to RAT alignment induced by sub-Lyman limit radiation in fully ionized gas. A long-standing problem in interstellar astronomy is the carrier of the 2175 Å extinction feature ( D. C. B. Whittet 2003 , e.g.,) . Since the IR emission of PAHs are thought to require excitations by UV photons ( D. Massa et al. 2022 , e.g.,) , and the characteristics of the 2175 Å feature, in terms of elemental abundances and grain size requirements imply small, likely carbonaceous grains (cf D. C. B. Whittet 2003 , p. 97-102) . Thus, an association between these two phenomena have been widely assumed. Observational support for this association has recently been presented by D. Massa et al. 2022 ; K. D. Gordon et al. 2024 . The recent detection of the 2175 Å feature at high redshift ( K. Ormerod et al. 2025 ; R. Fisher et al. 2025 ; V. Markov et al. 2025 , z \sim 2-12 ; e.g.) challenges the elemental enrichment in galaxies, requiring a rapid production of carbon to account for the feature as caused by such dust. However, in the final sample of interstellar UV polarimetry ( P. G. Martin et al. 1999 ) from the two flights of the Wisconsin Ultraviolet Photo-Polarimetry Experiment (WUPPE; K. H. Nordsieck et al. 1994 ; C. M. Anderson et al. 1996 ) and HST/FOS ( R. G. Allen et al. 1993 ; G. C. Clayton et al. 1995 ) , only two lines of sight, out of 30, show detectable polarization in the 2175 Å feature. Hence, a better understanding of the polarization properties of the PAH features is of central importance also to the interpretation of the UV feature. The 11.3\,\mu m PAH emission was reported to be polarized, 1.9\pm 0.2 %, in the northwestern (NW) nebula of the Herbig Be star MWC 1080 ( H. Zhang et al. 2017 ) . These observations used 8-13\,\mu m spectro-polarimetric observations taken with CanariCam ( C. M. Telesco et al. 2003 ) on the 10.4-m Gran Telescopio CANARIAS (GTC). This high polarization was attributed to PAH alignment with a local magnetic field via a resonance paramagnetic relaxation process. However, this polarization measurement presents several challenges. From an observational point of view, a) the measured polarized 11.3\,\mu m PAH emission is unexpectedly wider than the total-intensity emission line, which indicates some issues with the analysis of the polarized spectrum, b) the polarization fraction spectrum exhibits