Extreme points of absolutely PPT states with exactly three distinct eigenvalues

Nalan Wang, Lin Chen, Zhiwei Song · 2026

Read Extreme points of absolutely PPT states with exactly three distinct eigenvalues by Nalan Wang, Lin Chen, Zhiwei Song (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2603-20717.txt.

Introduction

Wang and co-authors study extreme points of absolutely PPT states for two qutrits with three distinct eigenvalues. A long open question asks if two key sets of states coincide. Both sets are convex, so their extreme points matter. The team looks at full rank states on the boundary of the AP set. They show each boundary point is extreme, with just one exception. Each such point holds at most one free parameter. Tables and figures lay out the full forms.

Catalog record

CREATORNalan Wang, Lin Chen, Zhiwei Song
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE108149
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2603.20717

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Extreme points of absolutely PPT states with exactly three distinct eigenvalues Nalan Wang, Lin Chen, Zhiwei Song Abstract Whether the sets of absolutely separable (AS) and absolutely two-qutrit positive-partial-transpose (AP) states are the same has been an open problem in entanglement theory for decades. Since they are both convex sets, we investigate the boundary and extreme points of full-rank two-qutrit AP states with exactly three distinct eigenvalues. We show that every boundary point is an extreme point, with exactly one exception. We explicitly characterize the expressions of such points, each of which turns out to contain at most one parameter in some intervals. When the parameter approaches the ends of intervals, most points become the known extreme points of exactly two distinct eigenvalues. We present our results by tables and figures. pacs 03.65.Ud, 03.67.Mn Keywords: separable state, positive partial transpose (PPT), absolute separability, absolute PPT I Introduction The separability problem is a long-standing open problem arising from quantum information theory, and known as an NP-hard problem in computational complexity. Determining whether a quantum state is separable (equivalently, non-entangled) is a key step to confirm the quantumness of many practically useful protocols such as quantum computing, cryptography and teleportation. From a theoretical perspective, non-separability may demonstrate the non-locality which is one of the fundamental features of quantum mechanics. As a result, much efforts have been devoted into the study of separability problem in the past decades, by developing various tools from linear and operator algebra. The most important tool is the positive partial transpose (PPT) criterion 23 ; 12 . This is a linear positive map under which a separable state on \mathbb{C}^{m}\otimes\mathbb{C}^{n} remains positive. The criterion is also sufficient when mn\leq 6 . However, there exist entangled states which are positive partial transpose (PPT) for mn>6 13 . The construction and detecting of such states have attracted lots of attentions in the quantum-information community. The separability of quantum states of simplest system, namely two-qubit states have been widely studied from more aspects such as volume measure 30 ; 18 ; 31 ; 14 , eigenvalues 25 ; 28 , and operator monotone 26 . Three-qubit separable states have also been investigated 10 . The boundary and length of separable states have also been studied 4 ; 5 ; 9 . Separable and PPT states have also been studied numerically 19 ; 20 . As a proper subset of separable (resp. PPT) states, absolutely separable (resp. PPT) states were firstly proposed as a kind of separable (resp. PPT) states close to the maximally mixed states 7 ; 29 ; 2 . It turns out that the properties of absolute separability (AS) and absolute PPT (AP) are essentially determined by the spectrum of density matrices 17 ; 8 ; 11 ; 15 . AS and PPT states have been studied in terms of maps and channels 6 . The difference has been shown between absolute separability and positive partial transposition in the symmetric subspace 21 ; 24 . There have been lots of efforts for improving the bounds of absolute separability 1 . The connection between resource theory and absolute separability was also constructed 22 . By definition, AS and AP states are respectively separable and PPT up to any global unitary operation. Such states exist, say the maximally mixed states. Further, AS states are a subset of AP states. Whether AS and AP states coincide has been an open problem for decades 3 . The problem has a positive answer for qubit-qudit system 16 . It is known that the sets of AS and AP states are both convex and compact. Hence they are convex hulls of extreme points. The open problem would have a positive answer when they have the same extreme points. Recently, the extreme points of qubit-qudit AP states have been totally characterized 27 . In the same paper, the extreme points of two-qutrit AP states with exactly two distinct eigenvalues have also been analytically constructed. In this paper, we shall continue in this vein to study the extreme points of full-rank two-qutrit AP states with exactly three distinct eigenvalues a,b and c in the decreasing order. We begin by formally introducing the convex sets of separable, PPT, absolutely separable and absolutely PPT states, as well as their extreme points as defined in Definition 1 . We then explore interior points from the perspective of line segments, as revealed by the lemma 2 . It helps readers independently check whether the points constructed in the tables later are boundary or interior points. We also review the necessary and sufficient conditions, by which a two-qutrit state lies in {\cal AP}_{3,3} and becomes a boundary/extreme point in Lemmas 3 and 4 . They actually have been used to generate all extreme points of two-qutrit AP states of exactly two distinct eigenvalues, as we show in Lemma 5 . From Sec. IV , we introduce our findings of characterizing extreme points of {\cal AP}_{3,3} . As the simplest case, we begin by investigating the boundary points of {\cal AP}_{3,3} with exactly one maximal eigenvalue in Lemmas 7 and 8 . They are mostly extreme points of {\cal AP}_{3,3} , with the only exceptional point \nu_{1,5,3}:=\mathop{\rm diag}(3c,b,b,b,b,b,c,c,c) , which turns out to be a non-extreme point in Lemma 9 . We further show that almost all boundary points of {\cal AP}_{3,3} with exactly three distinct eigenvalues are extreme points except \nu_{1,5,3} by Theorem 10 . Then we proceed to characterize the expressions of above-mentioned extreme points in terms of the numbers of largest eigenvalues \mu(a) in Sec. IV - VI . Most extreme points have exactly one parameter in some intervals. When the parameter approach the two ends of interval, the extreme points become the known extreme points of exactly two distinct eigenvalues. For the convenience of readers, we present our findings for \mu(a)=1,2,...,7 in Table 1 - 7 , respectively. We also show the connection of extreme points in Figure 1 - 7 and 8 . The last figure shows the Umbrella Model concluding the main findings of this paper. Some calculations are presented in appendix appendix A . The rest of this paper is organized as follows. In Sec. II we introduce the preliminary facts used in this paper. In Sec. III we study the existence of boundary and extreme points of two-qutrit AP states with various numbers of distinct eigenvalues. They are further characterized in Sec. IV - VI . Finally we conclude in Sec. VII . II Preliminaries In this section we introduce the preliminary knowledge of this paper. A bipartite state \rho is called separable if it is the convex sum of product states. It is known that a separable state is PPT though the converse usually fails. The definitions of absolute separable (AS) and absolute PPT (AP) states are presented as follows. Definition 1 A separable (resp. PPT) state \rho is called absolutely separable (resp. PPT) if it remains separable (PPT) regardless of what global unitary operation is applied. That is, for any unitary matrix U , the state U\rho U^{\dagger} is separable (resp. PPT). We shall respectively refer to {\cal AS}_{m,n} and {\cal AP}_{m,n} as the sets of m\times n AS and AP states. \sqcap

Read the complete text