Generalized JMN Naked Singularity Models
Jay Verma Trivedi, Pankaj S. Joshi · 2026
Read Generalized JMN Naked Singularity Models by Jay Verma Trivedi, Pankaj S. Joshi (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2603-20676.txt.
Introduction
Trivedi and Joshi build a wider class of naked singularity spacetimes. The models extend the JMN family, which arise from gravitational collapse. Their version adds uneven density through a radial mass function. Tangential pressure does not vanish in these end states. Each model joins smoothly to a Schwarzschild exterior. When the photon sphere sits outside, the shadow matches a Schwarzschild black hole. Disk spectra show more high frequency light than Schwarzschild. Shifts from the base JMN model stay small.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Jay Verma Trivedi, Pankaj S. Joshi |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 46546 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2603.20676
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Generalized JMN Naked Singularity Models Jay Verma Trivedi, Pankaj S. Joshi Abstract We construct a generalized class of Joshi–Malafarina–Narayan (JMN) naked singularity spacetimes that arise as equilibrium end states of gravitational collapse with non-vanishing tangential pressure. The generalization introduces density inhomogeneity through a radially dependent mass function F ( r ) = ( M 0 + M n r n ) r 3 F(r)=(M_{0}+M_{n}r^{n})r^{3} , leading to a two–parameter family of solutions matched smoothly to an exterior Schwarzschild spacetime. The observational properties of the spacetime are then examined through shadow formation and thin accretion disk emission. We find that when the photon sphere lies in the exterior Schwarzschild region, the shadow is identical to that of a Schwarzschild black hole. Accretion disk spectra show enhanced high–frequency emission compared to Schwarzschild, while deviations from the original JMN model remain small due to strong constraints on the inhomogeneity parameter. These results indicate that the generalized model effectively serves as a small perturbation of the JMN spacetime, demonstrating the robustness of JMN-type naked-singularity geometries. keywords : JMN, naked singularity, gravitational collapse, generalization, shadow, accretion disk. I Introduction The Cosmic Censorship Conjecture (CCC), originally proposed by Penrose in 1969 Penrose:1969pc ; Hawking:1979ig , remains one of the central unresolved problems in classical general relativity. Although it plays a fundamental role in our understanding of black hole physics, neither a precise mathematical formulation nor a general proof of the conjecture has been established to date. The singularity theorems of Hawking and Penrose guarantee the formation of spacetime singularities under broad, physically reasonable conditions HawkingEllis1973 ; however, they remain silent on the crucial question of whether such singularities are necessarily hidden behind event horizons or can be visible to distant observers. Models of gravitational collapse have provided significant insight into this problem. A large body of work over the past several decades has demonstrated that the end state of collapse may be either a black hole or a naked singularity, depending sensitively on the initial conditions of the collapsing matter Dwivedi:1992fh ; Joshi:1993zg ; Joshi:1994br ; Joshi:2001xi ; Hellaby:1985zz ; Goncalves:2001pf ; Giambo:2002xc ; Harada:2001nj ; Ori:1989ps ; Gundlach:1999cu ; Nolan:2002zd ; Giacomazzo:2011cv ; Ortiz:2011jw ; Banerjee:2002sy ; Barausse:2010ka ; Mosani:2023vtr . These results indicate that naked singularities arise naturally in classical general relativity and that the formation of an event horizon is not enforced solely by the Einstein field equations. As a consequence, CCC remains unproven and, within certain collapse scenarios, appears to be theoretically violated. Naked singularities are indeed a generic outcome of gravitational collapse; hence, CCC ultimately becomes an observational question. In this context, recent studies have focused on identifying potential astrophysical signatures that can distinguish naked singularities from black holes. Notably, analyses of the first image of Sagittarius A* (Sgr A*) have highlighted the JMN-1 naked singularity spacetime Joshi:2011zm , which arises as an equilibrium configuration of anisotropic fluid collapse with vanishing radial and non-zero tangential pressure, as a viable black hole mimicker EventHorizonTelescope:2022xqj . It is well known that a spherically symmetric distribution of non-interacting particles, in the absence of pressure, cannot remain in equilibrium against its own gravitational attraction and must undergo complete gravitational collapse. The final outcome of such a dust collapse is either a black hole or a naked singularity, depending on the initial density and velocity profiles of the collapsing matter Joshi:1993zg ; WaughLake1988 ; Newman1986 ; Christodoulou1984 ; EardleySmarr1979 . Over the past decades, extensive investigations of gravitational collapse in a wide range of physical settings—such as self-similar models OriPiran1987 ; Ori:1989ps ; FoglizzoHenriksen1993 , scalar fields Christodoulou1994 ; Giambo2005 ; BhattacharyaGoswamiJoshi2011 , perfect fluids Harada1998 ; HaradaMaeda2001 ; GoswamiJoshi2002 ; GiamboGiannoniMagliPiccione2004 ; VillasdaRochaWang2000 , and more general matter configurations—have shown that both black holes and naked singularities naturally arise as possible end states within general relativity ShapiroTeukolsky1991 ; ShapiroTeukolsky1992 ; Lake1991 ; JoshiKrolak1996 ; Joshi:2001xi ; GoswamiJoshi2007 . When pressures are present within the collapsing matter cloud, a scenario that is physically more realistic than dust, complete gravitational collapse is no longer the only possible outcome. An important question then arises: whether and under what conditions equilibrium configurations can emerge dynamically from gravitational collapse. This issue is directly physical, as numerous astrophysical objects, including stars, planets, and galaxies, form through collapse and subsequently settle into long-lived equilibrium states. In Joshi:2011zm , it was demonstrated that the gravitational collapse of a matter cloud with non-vanishing tangential pressure and vanishing radial pressure, starting from regular initial data, can asymptotically approach a variety of equilibrium configurations. While this choice represents a simplified matter model, it allows for a transparent analysis due to the conservation of the mass function, and it captures a rich set of physical possibilities. Collapse models with vanishing radial pressure were originally studied by Datta in the context of the Einstein cluster, describing counter-rotating particles Datta1970 ; Bondi1971 ; JhinganMagli2000 ; HaradaIguchiNakao1998 . These models have since been explored extensively to characterize collapse end states in terms of black holes and naked singularities Magli1997 ; Magli1998 ; HaradaNakaoIguchi1999 ; JoshiGoswami2002 . In Joshi:2011zm , the general formalism developed in MalafarinaJoshi2011a ; JoshiMalafarina2011 was employed to analyze the dynamical evolution of such systems and to determine the conditions under which collapse may halt and lead to static configurations. It was shown that both regular and centrally singular equilibrium spacetimes can arise from this process. As a specific application, they examined a toy model called JMN-1, which exhibits a central naked singularity, and studied the properties of an accretion disk in the resulting spacetime. A notable feature of the solutions presented there is that naked singularities emerge from a fully dynamical collapse process starting from regular initial conditions. This distinguishes these models from many other naked singular geometries studied in general relativity, which are not obtained through regular gravitational collapse (see, however, discussions on overspinning Kerr black holes in deFeliceYunqiang2001 ; SaaSantarelli2011 ). Although their analysis is based on an idealized model in which the singular configuration is approached asymptotically, it can be physically interpreted as a slowly evolving collapse where the central density grows without horizon formation and remains visible to distant observers. At sufficiently late times, the collapse effectively “freezes,” allowing spacetime to be well approximated by a static configuration, enabling a meaningful study of its physical properties. The primary objective of this work is to check the robustness of the JMN-1 spacetime. We generalize the toy model’s assumption to incorporate density inhomogeneities at the initial stage of collapse. We briefly illustrate that observational features, such as those associated with accretion disks, can differ slightly from those of JMN-1. This paper is organized as follows. In Section II , we review the general formalism describing the dynamical evolution of matter clouds supported by tangential pressure and the conditions under which collapse asymptotes to equilibrium. Section III examines a representative generalized toy model and its physical properties. In Section IV , we analyze shadow properties of this new model. In Section V , we analyze the accretion disk properties in order to distinguish the new model from the old toy model JMN-1. Finally, Section VI summarizes the main results and outlines directions for future work. II Equilibrium configuration The spacetime geometry of a