Agentic AI and the next intelligence explosion
James Evans, Benjamin Bratton, Blaise Agüera y Arcas · 2026
Read Agentic AI and the next intelligence explosion by James Evans, Benjamin Bratton, Blaise Agüera y Arcas (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2603-20639.txt.
Introduction
Evans and co-authors argue that the next leap in AI will be social, not a single vast mind. Evolution, they note, made intelligence plural and shared. New agent systems seem to reason by staging inner debates. These inner societies argue, check, and settle hard tasks. Human AI teams also act as hybrid agents no one person controls. They urge a shift from one to one alignment toward rules like those of markets. The result would sprawl like a city of minds.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | James Evans, Benjamin Bratton, Blaise Agüera y Arcas |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 11938 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2603.20639
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Agentic AI and the next intelligence explosion James Evans, Benjamin Bratton, Blaise Agüera y Arcas Abstract \uselogo For decades, the artificial intelligence (AI) “singularity” [ 21 ] has been heralded as a single, titanic mind bootstrapping itself to godlike intelligence [ 9 ] , consolidating all cognition into a cold silicon point. But this vision is almost certainly wrong in its most fundamental assumption. If AI development follows the path of previous major evolutionary transitions [ 19 ] or “intelligence explosions” [ 29 ] , our current step-change in computational intelligence will be plural, social, and deeply entangled with its forebears (us!). By its nature, intelligence is high-dimensional and relational, not a single quantity that must be unambiguously less or greater than human scale. In fact, it is unclear what we even mean by “human scale,” given that our intelligence is already a collective property, not an individual one. Recent advances in agentic AI show us once again that intelligence has always fundamentally involved the interaction of distinctive, distributed perspectives [ 23 ] , and it is from social organization [ 11 ] that transformative intelligence has and will continue to emerge. We can observe this in at least two ways: In the orchestration of societies of AI agents [ 28 ] by and with human users in new “centaur” configurations, and in the microsocieties that flourish inside and between reasoning models themselves. Let’s start with the latter. What happens inside an ostensibly singular reasoning model? A community conversation, as it turns out. In a recent study, we demonstrated that frontier reasoning models like DeepSeek-R1 and QwQ-32B do not improve simply by “thinking longer.” Instead, they simulate complex, multi-agent-like interactions within their own chain of thought—what we term a “society of thought” [ 8 ] . These models spontaneously generate internal debates among distinct cognitive perspectives that argue, question, verify, and reconcile. This conversational structure causally accounts for the models’ accuracy advantage on hard reasoning tasks, which we demonstrated by explicitly priming and amplifying multi-party conversation. The finding is striking because it reveals an emergent behavior. None of these models were trained to produce societies of thought. When reinforcement learning is used to reward base models solely for reasoning accuracy, they spontaneously increase conversational, multi-perspective behaviors [ 27 ] . Models are rediscovering, through optimization pressure alone, what centuries of epistemology and decades of cognitive science [ 12 ] have suggested: that robust reasoning is a social process [ 13 ] , even when it occurs within a single mind [ 10 ] . The exact nature of that emergent behavior is, of course, to be further discovered (and invented) as cooperative human-agent social dynamics become more grounded, complex, and durable. What proves fundamental about socially-mediated reasoning in general, and what is specific to fine-tuned and reinforced contexts, is likely to inspire considerable research in the coming years. This opens a vast—yet familiar—design space. The social and organizational sciences have spent a century studying how team size [ 24 ] , composition, hierarchy [ 26 ] , role differentiation, conflict norms, institutions, and network structures shape collective performance. Almost none of this research has been brought to bear on AI reasoning [ 25 ] . Today’s reasoning models produce a single conversation—an AI town hall transcript. But effective groups exhibit hierarchy, specialization, division of labor, and structured disagreement. To explore this, we will need systems that support multiple parallel, converging, and diverging streams of deliberation—architectures in which brainstorming, devil’s advocacy, and constructive conflict are not accidental emergent properties but designed features. The toolkits of team science, small-group sociology, and social psychology become blueprints for next-generation AI development. In addition to its practical applications, these insights may clarify the entire history of intelligence. Each prior “intelligence explosion” was not an upgrade to individual cognitive hardware, but the emergence of a new, socially aggregated unit of cognition [ 17 ] . Primate intelligence scaled with social group size [ 4 ] , not habitat difficulty. Human language created what Michael Tomasello calls the “cultural ratchet” [ 20 ] : knowledge accumulating across generations without any individual requirement to reconstruct the whole. Writing, law, and bureaucracy externalized social intelligence into infrastructure [ 6 ] , institutions that coordinate across longer time horizons than any participant within them. A Sumerian scribe running a grain accounting system did not comprehend its macroeconomic function; the system was functionally more intelligent than he was. AI extends this sequence. Large language models are trained on the accumulated output of human social cognition [ 16 ] —the cultural ratchet made computationally active, every parameter a compressed residue of communicative exchange. What migrates into silicon is not abstract reasoning but social intelligence in externalized form [ 5 ] , encountering itself on a new substrate. If intelligence is inherently social, then the path to more powerful AI runs not through building a single colossal oracle but through composing richer social systems—and these systems will be hybrid. We have entered the era of human-AI centaurs: composite actors that are neither purely human nor purely machine. Centaur actors can take many forms and inhabit many different roles. Each one of us may move in and out of diverse ensembles many times a day: one human directing many AI agents; one AI serving many humans; many humans and many AIs collaborating in shifting configurations [ 3 ] . A corporation or state comprising myriad of humans already holds singular legal standing and acts with collective agency that no individual member can fully control. The recent explosion of agentic AI suggests the possibility of something similar at the scale of billions of interacting minds, human and non-human alike. Platforms like OpenClaw, an open source platform for building multi-purpose AI agents that persist within a computer, and Moltbook, a popular social network for AI agents to interact, offer embryonic glimpses [ 28 ] of this future. But the deeper structural shift goes beyond any single platform. Agents can now renew and fork themselves, splitting into two versions, and interact with one another; an agent facing a complex task can initiate new copies, differentiate and assign them subtasks, then recombine the results. Imagine an agent confronting a dauntingly complex problem spawns an internal society of thought. One emergent perspective, encountering a sub-problem beyond its reach, spawns its own subordinate society, a recursive descent into collective deliberation that expands when complexity demands and collapses when the problem resolves. Conflict is not a bug but a resource, flexibly instantiated and dissolved at every level of the folding and unfolding hypergraph of conversations. This implies a very different approach to scaling. It is not only about scaling the raw computational capacity of an agent, but about building systems that can operate at the scale and within the context of a real society. This means putting as much effort into building agent institutions as building agents themselves. The dominant paradigm for AI alignment—Reinforcement Learning from Human Feedback [ 2 ] —resembles a parent-child model of correction, fundamentally dyadic and unable to scale to billions of agents. The social intelligence perspective suggests an alternative: institutional alignment [ 15 ] . Just as human societies rely not on individual virtue but on