An analytical criterion for significant runaway electron generation in activated tokamaks

B. Zaar \aff 1 \corresp, I. Pusztai \aff 1, I. Ekmark \aff 1, T. Fülöp \aff 1 · 2026

Read An analytical criterion for significant runaway electron generation in activated tokamaks by B. Zaar \aff 1 \corresp, I. Pusztai \aff 1, I. Ekmark \aff 1, T. Fülöp \aff 1 (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2603-20485.txt.

Introduction

Zaar and co-authors derive a simple test for when a disrupted tokamak makes large runaway electron currents. Such currents can hit the wall and cause grave damage in ITER or SPARC. In deuterium-tritium plasmas, seed runaways can come from tritium beta decay. Compton scattering can add more seeds. Their criterion counts both sources in the avalanche gain factor. It also counts partial screening by injected noble gases. Fluid simulations with the DREAM code support the model. The aim is a fast map of safe operation zones.

Catalog record

CREATORB. Zaar \aff 1 \corresp, I. Pusztai \aff 1, I. Ekmark \aff 1, T. Fülöp \aff 1
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE59713
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2603.20485

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

An analytical criterion for significant runaway electron generation in activated tokamaks B. Zaar \aff 1 \corresp, I. Pusztai \aff 1, I. Ekmark \aff 1, T. Fülöp \aff 1 Abstract A disrupting plasma in a high-performance tokamak such as ITER or SPARC may generate large runaway electron currents that, upon impact with the tokamak wall, can cause serious damage to the device. To quickly identify regions of safe operation in parameter space, it is useful to develop reduced models and analytical criteria that predict when a significant fraction of the Ohmic current is converted into a current of runaway electrons. In deuterium-tritium plasmas, the seed runaway current may have a significant contribution from — or may even be dominated by — tritium beta decay and Compton scattering. In this work, a criterion for significant runaway electron generation that includes tritium beta decay and Compton scattering sources is developed. The avalanche gain factor includes the effects of partial screening of injected noble gases. The result is an analytical model that can predict significant runaway electron generation in the next generation of activated tokamak devices. The model is validated by fluid simulations using Dream ( 17 ) and is shown to delineate regions in parameter space where significant runaway electron generation may occur. 1 Introduction Plasma-terminating disruptions are one of the crucial problems facing magnetic fusion devices with large plasma currents, such as ITER ( 12 ; 2 ) . Such events lead to a sudden cooling of the plasma — a thermal quench. The thermal quench is associated with a substantial increase in the plasma resistivity, causing the current to decay, which induces a strong toroidal electric field. If the electric field exceeds a critical value, above which the friction force from collisions and radiation becomes smaller than the accelerating force from the electric field for electrons in the tail of the bulk Maxwellian distribution, these electrons may run away. In such cases, a large part of the initial plasma current can be converted into a beam of relativistic runaway electrons ( 3 ) . Runaway electrons can be produced by a range of mechanisms. First, electrons can enter the runaway region in momentum space through the diffusive leak from the thermal population at a rate that is exponentially sensitive to the electric field (so-called Dreicer generation) ( 4 ) . Second, in the case of sudden cooling, when the collision frequency is lower than the cooling rate, fast electrons do not have time to thermalize, and a hot tail forms in the electron distribution ( 11 ) . If the hot tail electrons have energies above the critical energy, they may run away. Finally, during deuterium-tritium (DT) operation, fast electrons can be produced by nuclear reactions. Tritium ions undergoing beta decay produce electrons in the keV range, and Compton scattering of gamma rays from the activated wall can knock both free and bound electrons into the runaway regime ( 23 ) . Collectively, these four mechanisms are referred to as primary generation mechanisms. Furthermore, and perhaps most importantly for reactor-scale fusion devices, runaway electrons already present in the plasma can create new ones through close collisions with thermal electrons. This leads to an exponential growth in the number of runaway electrons — an avalanche ( 19 ) . This secondary generation is proportional to the density of existing runaway electrons, and the dynamics become highly nonlinear. Therefore, small variations in the balance between runaway electron generation and transport lead to large differences in the maximum runaway electron current. In addition, the avalanche gain is exponentially sensitive to the initial plasma current and is therefore expected to be significantly larger in future devices with larger plasma currents ( 34 ) . Currently envisaged disruption mitigation methods are based on the injection of massive amounts of material ( 16 ) , resulting in a cold and partially ionized plasma. In partially ionized plasmas, the nucleus is only partially screened by the bound electron cloud; an energetic electron can penetrate the electron cloud and experience a portion of the normally screened nuclear charge. The effect of this partial screening is expected to be substantial in impurity rich plasmas ( 14 ) . In addition, the injection of highly radiating impurities such as neon or argon may lead to even higher avalanche growth rates due to the large number of available target electrons. Therefore, energetic electrons resulting from disruptions can pose a severe risk to future fusion devices. In order to design operating scenarios for next-generation fusion devices, advanced first-principles simulations are needed. Self-consistent simulations that take into account the evolution of plasma parameters across the entire plasma are computationally expensive, and optimization of operating scenarios based on such simulations is a monumental task. Although simplified fluid models of runaway electron generation will not provide a quantitative prediction of the expected electron energy spectrum, they can be useful in indicating whether large runaway currents are to be expected. Based on the approximate solution of two coupled differential equations for the runaway electron density and the inductive electric field, an analytical criterion for significant runaway electron generation was first derived by 10 and later refined by 8 by including the hot-tail runaway seed. Such criteria are useful complements to more comprehensive disruption or runaway electron models, as they can be used to quickly estimate where in parameter space large runaway currents can be expected before committing computational resources to a detailed parameter scan. They can also be used as a "trigger" in integrated modelling code suites to determine whether to execute a more sophisticated model. However, in previous criteria, energetic electrons from nuclear sources (tritium decay and Compton scattering) and the effect of partial screening were not included; hence, they were not applicable for disruptions in activated scenarios mitigated with material injection. The focus of this paper is to derive an analytical criterion for significant runaway electron generation in activated scenarios. In § 2 , the zero-dimensional fluid model for runaway electron generation, on which the criterion is based, is presented. § 3 and § 4 describe the avalanche gain and nuclear runaway electron sources, respectively. The criterion is validated by comparisons with fluid simulations using the Dream code in § 5 , and the conclusions are summarized in § 6 . 2 Zero-dimensional fluid model for runaway electron generation The density of the runaway electron population n_{\mathrm{r}} is determined by the sum of the primary (seed) and secondary (avalanche) generation mechanisms as \frac{\mathrm{d}n_{\mathrm{r}}}{\mathrm{d}t}=\sum_{\mathrm{seeds}}\gamma_{\mathrm{seed}}+\Gamma_{\mathrm{ava}}n_{\mathrm{r}}, (1) with the total seed generation rate (in principle consisting of Dreicer, hot-tail, tritium decay, and Compton scattering sources) \sum_{\mathrm{seeds}}\gamma_{\mathrm{seed}} and the avalanche growth rate \Gamma_{\mathrm{ava}} . Here, it is assumed that no runaway electrons are present in the plasma at the time of the disruption onset (at t=0 ). All runaway electron generation mechanisms depend on the parallel electric field E_{\parallel} , which is inductive and is given by E_{\parallel}=E_{\parallel 0}-\frac{L}{2\upi R_{0}}\frac{\mathrm{d}I_{\mathrm{p}}}{\mathrm{d}t}, (2) where L\approx\mu_{0}R_{0}\left[\ln{\left(\frac{8R_{0}}{a}\right)}-2\right] (3) is the self-inductance of the plasma in the large aspect ratio limit, with the vacuum permeability \mu_{0} , the plasma major radius R_{0} , and the plasma minor radius a . E_{\parallel 0} is the contribution to the electric field due to the external transformer.

Read the complete text