Isolated or Dynamical? Tracing Black Hole Binary Formation through the Population of Gravitational-Wave Sources Preprint: APS/PRD

Manuel Arca Sedda, Lavinia Paiella, Cristiano Ugolini, Filippo Santoliquido, Benedetta Mestichelli, Ilaria Usai, Filippo Simonato, Marica Branchesi · 2026

Read Isolated or Dynamical? Tracing Black Hole Binary Formation through the Population of Gravitational-Wave Sources Preprint: APS/PRD by Manuel Arca Sedda, Lavinia Paiella, Cristiano Ugolini, Filippo Santoliquido, Benedetta Mestichelli, Ilaria Usai, Filippo Simonato, Marica Branchesi (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2603-20430.txt.

Introduction

Arca Sedda and co-authors model how black hole binaries form across cosmic settings. Mergers seen by LIGO-Virgo-KAGRA can arise from isolated pairs or crowded clusters. Their B-POP code follows both channels in young, globular, and nuclear clusters. It folds in star formation history and metallicity change over time. Predicted merger rates, 17.5 to 24.1 per cubic gigaparsec yearly, match observations. Isolated binaries dominate below 20 solar masses in primary mass. Dynamically built mergers take over at higher masses. Their mass and spin patterns also fit current data.

Catalog record

CREATORManuel Arca Sedda, Lavinia Paiella, Cristiano Ugolini, Filippo Santoliquido, Benedetta Mestichelli, Ilaria Usai, Filippo Simonato, Marica Branchesi
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE128234
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2603.20430

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Isolated or Dynamical? Tracing Black Hole Binary Formation through the Population of Gravitational-Wave Sources Preprint: APS/PRD Manuel Arca Sedda, Lavinia Paiella, Cristiano Ugolini, Filippo Santoliquido, Benedetta Mestichelli, Ilaria Usai, Filippo Simonato, Marica Branchesi Abstract The population of binary black hole (BBH) mergers observed by the LIGO–Virgo–KAGRA (LVK) collaboration offers a window into the cosmic evolution of compact binaries and the physical mechanisms that drive their formation. We employ the semi-analytic population-synthesis code B-POP to model BBHs assembled through isolated binary evolution and dynamical interactions in young, globular, and nuclear star clusters. Our framework self-consistently incorporates star formation history, metallicity evolution, and single and binary stellar evolution to quantify their impact on the observable properties of the BBH population and on the relative contribution of distinct formation channels. Our models are characterized by a merger rate, ℛ = 17.5 \mathcal{R}=17.5 – 24.1 ​ Gpc − 3 ​ yr − 1 24.1~\mathrm{Gpc}^{-3}~\mathrm{yr}^{-1} , broadly consistent with LVK constraints. Moreover, the predicted distributions of primary mass, mass ratio, and effective inspiral spin parameter are compatible with those inferred from current LVK observations. Our primary-mass distribution is dominated by isolated binaries at m 1 ≲ 20 ​ M ⊙ m_{1}\lesssim 20\,{\rm M}_{\odot} , while dynamically assembled first- and higher-generation mergers dominate at larger masses. As a consequence, the sub-population of mergers with m 1 ≳ 45 ​ M ⊙ m_{1}\gtrsim 45\,{\rm M}_{\odot} exhibits a nearly flat mass-ratio distribution and distinctive spin properties. We leverage our models to explore how: (i) the fraction of stars in isolated binaries and the fraction of stellar mass bound in clusters regulate the overall merger rate; (ii) common-envelope physics shapes the primary-mass distribution and its redshift evolution; (iii) the inclusion of stellar-collision products enhances the formation of higher-generation mergers; and (iv) the natal spin distribution of stellar-mass black holes influences the effective spin of merging BBHs. Using our models to assess possible origins of selected GW events, we illustrate how the complexity of the underlying astrophysical processes can hinder the possibility to draw definitive conclusions. I Introduction With the conclusion of first part of the fourth observation campaign (O4a) run by the LIGO-Virgo-Kagra (LVK) collaboration ( Harry and LIGO Scientific Collaboration 2010 ; Aso et al. 2013 ; LIGO Scientific Collaboration et al. 2015 ; Acernese et al. 2015 ; Abbott et al. 2018 ; Abbott et al. 2020a ; Akutsu et al. 2021 ) , the gravitational-wave transient catalogue (GWTC-4) counts 165 robust detections 1 1 1 Here, we consider all sources with a parameter p_{\rm astro}>0.5 . Note that the number of detections which also have a false-alarm rate <1 yr -1 is 151. Unless otherwise stated, the LVK data utilised to perform comparisons with our models are publicly available at DOI:~10.5281/zenodo.16911562 . of coalescing black hole binaries (BBHs) ( The LIGO Scientific Collaboration et al. 2025a ) . Despite the ever-growing number of detected BBHs, understanding their origin still remains an unsolved problem of GW astrophysics, primarily due to the many degeneracies and uncertainties affecting the underlying stellar physics of BH formation ( Mandel and Farmer 2022 ; Spera et al. 2022 , e.g.) . From the theoretical viewpoint, the population of detected BBHs likely belongs to a heterogeneous mixture of binaries formed through different formation channels ( Arca Sedda and Benacquista 2019 ; Arca Sedda et al. 2020a ; Bavera et al. 2020 ; Zevin et al. 2021 ; Mapelli et al. 2022 ; Arca Sedda et al. 2023a ) . Broadly speaking, the origin of BBHs can be categorized into two main scenarios: the isolated formation scenario ( Dominik et al. 2012 ; Belczynski 2020 ; Belczynski et al. 2002 ; Iorio et al. 2023 ; Spera et al. 2019 ; Belczynski et al. 2016 ; Stevenson et al. 2019 ; Farmer et al. 2019 ; Godfrey et al. 2023 ) , in which BBH mergers form from the binary stellar evolution of two stars paired at birth, and the dynamical formation scenario ( Lee 1993 ; Downing et al. 2010 ; Banerjee et al. 2010 ; Rodriguez et al. 2015 ; Antonini and Rasio 2016 ; Askar et al. 2017 ; Banerjee 2018 ; Di Carlo et al. 2019 ; Rodriguez et al. 2019 ; Tagawa et al. 2021 ; Banerjee 2022 ; Chattopadhyay et al. 2022 ; Torniamenti et al. 2022 ; Arca sedda et al. 2024 ; Barber and Antonini 2025 ) , in which black holes (BHs) meet and pair up via dynamical interactions in star clusters and galactic nuclei. Several quantities inferred from LVK detections could be used to untangle signatures of different formation scenarios, such as the local merger rate density (MRD), \mathcal{R}_{\rm LVK}=(14–26)~{\rm yr}^{-1}~{\rm Gpc}^{-3} , the mass distribution of binary primaries, the possible evolution of BBH masses and merger rate with redshift, the spin distribution. Additionally, exceptional BBH sources may hint at very specific formation scenarios. Among others, the most massive BBH mergers ever detected, like GW190521 ( Abbott et al. 2020b ) and GW231123 ( The LIGO Scientific Collaboration et al. 2025b ) , hardly reconcile with the expectations of isolated stellar evolution ( Popa and de Mink 2025 ; Tanikawa et al. 2025 , but see) , possibly being byproducts of dynamical processes in dense stellar environments and galactic nuclei ( Kıroğlu et al. 2025 ; Bartos and Haiman 2025 ; Li and Fan 2025 ; Paiella et al. 2025 ) , or deriving from an even more exotic scenario ( Yuan et al. 2025 ; De Luca et al. 2025 , e.g. the merger of primordial BHs,) . In the last few years, several studies utilised phenomenological models to infer properties of BBH mergers at population-level and to assess their statistical significance, either regarding the BBH masses ( Fishbach and Holz 2017 ; Talbot and Thrane 2018 ; Roulet and Zaldarriaga 2019 ; Tiwari and Fairhurst 2021 ) , spins ( Talbot and Thrane 2017 ; Wysocki et al. 2019 ; Miller et al. 2020 ; Roulet et al. 2021 ; Golomb and Talbot 2023 ) , or the possible combination of BBH features ( Roulet et al. 2020 ; Edelman et al. 2023 ; Callister and Farr 2024 ; Afroz and Mukherjee 2025a ; Afroz and Mukherjee 2025b ; Godfrey et al. 2023 ; Ray et al. 2025 ; Kishore Roy et al. 2025 ; Farah et al. 2024 ; Ray et al. 2025 ) . From the numerical point of view, semi-analytical population synthesis codes represent powerful tools to simulate statistically relevant populations of BBH mergers to compare with observations. Generally, these tools are tailored to represent one scenario at a time, either isolated ( Iorio et al. 2023 ; Belczynski et al. 2008 ; Hurley et al. 2002 ) or dynamical ( Antonini and Gieles 2020 ; Kritos et al. 2024 ; Tagawa et al. 2021 ; Mapelli et al. 2021 ) . Among others ( Antonini et al. 2019 ; Mapelli et al. 2021 ; Kritos et al. 2022 ) , B-pop ( Arca Sedda and Benacquista 2019 ; Arca Sedda et al. 2020a ; Arca Sedda et al. 2023a ) is a semi-analytical tool that simultaneously simulates populations of BBH mergers forming via isolated binary (IB) stellar evolution

Read the complete text