Probing the statistical correlation of optical tidal disruption events with high-energy neutrinos
D.A. Langis, I. Liodakis, K.I.I. Koljonen, P.M. Kouch · 2026
Read Probing the statistical correlation of optical tidal disruption events with high-energy neutrinos by D.A. Langis, I. Liodakis, K.I.I. Koljonen, P.M. Kouch (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2603-20378.txt.
Introduction
Langis and co-authors test whether optical tidal disruption events line up with high-energy neutrinos. IceCube has logged such neutrinos for over a decade, with sources still unclear. Stars torn apart by black holes are one proposed source class. Using the TDECat repository, they run a space-and-time matching algorithm. They also simulate event sets with built-in links to check the method. Despite two notable individual cases, no statistical link emerged. One jetted event matched a neutrino, but a flaring quasar shared its error region.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | D.A. Langis, I. Liodakis, K.I.I. Koljonen, P.M. Kouch |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 42876 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2603.20378
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Probing the statistical correlation of optical tidal disruption events with high-energy neutrinos D.A. Langis, I. Liodakis, K.I.I. Koljonen, P.M. Kouch Abstract High-energy (HE) neutrinos have been observed by the IceCube (IC) Neutrino observatory for over a decade. Nevertheless, the astrophysical origin and the responsible mechanisms producing these HE neutrinos are still a mystery, with many astrophysical phenomena as potential emitters. A plethora of previous studies have attempted to study the correlation between HE neutrinos and active galactic nuclei, finding inconclusive results. Tidal disruption events (TDEs) have been proposed as candidate HE neutrino emitters, yet there is only one prior statistical study for the correlation of the two due to the limited number of observed TDEs. For this reason we used TDECat, an optical TDE repository, to investigate the potential association of TDEs with IceCube HE neutrino events. We implemented a spatio-temporal algorithm, where the temporal constraint is based on the transient nature of TDEs. We also simulated two sets of TDEs, correlated differently with neutrinos, to further study their statistical correlation. Despite the individual cases of TDE AT2019dsg and AT2021lo, we find no statistical association between optical TDEs and HE neutrinos. We find jetted TDE Sw J2058+05 to be spatio-temporally associated with a neutrino event. However, a γ \gamma -ray-flaring, flat-spectrum radio quasar is also within the neutrino’s sky error region. Although our findings indicate no statistical correlation between optical TDEs and HE neutrinos, this correlation should be further studied in the future. Upcoming surveys such as the Legacy Survey of Space and Time, coupled with next-generation neutrino observatories, such as KM3NET and IceCube-Gen2, will expand both TDE and HE neutrino populations, clarifying their potential correlation. 1 Introduction High-energy (HE) neutrinos offer a unique glimpse into cosmic accelerators, with observatories such as the IceCube Neutrino observatory ( 4 ) , Baikal-GVD ( 11 ) , ANTARES ( 24 ; 10 ) and KM3NeT 1 1 1 https://www.km3net.org/ ( 8 ; 34 ) having detected hundreds in the TeV-PeV range. These HE neutrinos have a chance of being of astrophysical origin, although their sources and the mechanisms responsible for particle acceleration remain a mystery. It has been proposed that accreting supermassive black holes ( 52 ; 70 ; 53 , SMBH; e.g.) , microquasars and/or X-ray binaries ( 43 ; 15 ; 19 ; 35 , XRBs; e.g.) , gamma-ray bursts ( 79 ; 61 ; 21 ; 66 , e.g.) , or rapidly spinning neutron stars ( 23 ; 45 , e.g.) could produce these HE neutrinos. However, a definitive association has yet to be established, due to the high atmospheric background and the poor spatial resolution of neutrino events. Blazars, which are active galaxies whose relativistic jets are directed along our line of sight, are among the most promising candidates for neutrino sources. Due to their jet environment and energetics, blazar jets can create HE neutrinos through both hadronic ( 52 ; 53 ; 25 ; 55 , e.g.) and leptonic processes ( 29 ) . Some blazars have been spatio-temporally associated with neutrinos, with the most famous being TXS 0506+056 ( 32 ) . However, past blazar population studies have not convincingly connected blazars with HE neutrinos (e.g. 60 ; 59 ; 58 ; 30 ; 40 ; 73 ; 38 , hereafter 38 ) . For example, 60 used a sample of 3388 jetted active galactic nuclei (AGN) and 56 HE neutrino events (E¿200 TeV), and found strong evidence for an association (0.2% chance probability). In a follow-up study, 59 utilized 7 years of IC track data comprising 712,830 detected events, along with 3411 jetted AGN, and found a 3\sigma association between the two. Combining their results from both studies, they got a significance of 4.1\sigma , which was soon challenged by 84 using the same sample. 30 considered a jetted-AGN dataset observed by the Owens valley radio observatory (OVRO) and Metsähori radio observatory with 1795 blazars, which they cross-correlated with a sample of 56 IC neutrino events. Although not all neutrinos were associated with blazars flaring in the radio, they found a \sim 2\sigma chance probability when the neutrinos coincided with strong radio flares. Lastly, 38 investigated the correlation between one of the blazar sub-datasets from 30 and an updated neutrino sample of 283 events, observing a 2.17\sigma significance only after enlarging the uncertainty areas by 1 ∘ in quadrature to account for systematic errors. Another class of astrophysical phenomena recently proposed as neutrino sources are tidal disruption events ( 77 ; 78 ; 72 ; 63 ; 75 ; 83 , TDEs; e.g.) . Tidal disruption events occur when a star gets too close to a SMBH and is torn apart by its strong tidal forces. The stellar debris then spirals inwards, forming an accretion disc around the SMBH and emitting a burst of electromagnetic radiation characterized by a fast rise and gradual decay over time ( 62 ) . The extreme conditions created during such a process (e.g. intense gravitational and magnetic fields, relativistic jets) provide suitable conditions for the acceleration of particles to very high energies. These accelerated particles are theorized to interact with surrounding matter or radiation, producing HE neutrinos ( 77 ; 51 ; 18 ; 28 ; 57 ; 82 , e.g. ) . This theorized neutrino production from TDEs took the spotlight when TDE AT2019dsg was found to be spatio-temporally associated with the IceCube neutrino event IC191001A ( 72 ) . Subsequently, there have been associations between TDE candidates and neutrino events, namely AT2019aalc - IC191119A ( 75 ) , AT2019fdr - IC200530A ( 63 ) and AT2021lwx - IC220405B ( 83 , even though it was outside the events reported 90% error area;) . Moreover, 44 found TDE ATLAS17jrp (AT2017gge) to be spatio-temporally associated with a potential neutrino flare, with a 0.17% probability of occurring by chance. Furthermore, 50 did a population study on 56 Zwicky Transient Facility (ZTF)-classified TDEs and 143 neutrino events with at least 30\% of being astrophysical after 2019, obtaining \sim 1.3\sigma significance for the full sample and \sim 2.65\sigma for an infrared-selected subsample. While the spatio-temporal method has been applied extensively in blazars ( 60 ; 30 ; 38 ; 37 , e.g.) , this is not the case for TDEs, since there has only been one recent study ( 50 ) . Our goal is to test the association between TDEs and neutrinos. For an in-depth review of optical TDEs, readers can refer to 26 and 74 . Our paper is organized as follows: In Sect. 2 we introduce our neutrino and TDE samples , along with their properties. In Sect. 3 we describe our spatio-temporal method as well as the different simulations we conducted to probe its performance for two distinct cases of associated datasets. Finally, in Sect. 4 we discuss our results, followed by the conclusions in Sect. 5 . 2 Data 2.1 TDE sample As we mention in Sect. 2.2 , IC neutrino alerts contain detections from \sim 55056 MJD to \sim 60232 MJD. We used the optical TDE catalogue (TDECat 2 2 2 https://github.com/dlangis/TDECat ) from 42 and selected events with durations within the aforementioned time window. Our final sample consists of 107 TDEs (108 flares in total;