Radiating Bondi Flows II: Giant Planet Accretion Models Journal: MNRAS This work made extensive use of the SciPy ( 45 ) , Matplotlib ( 21 ) , and NumPy ( 20 ) packages. Radiation-hydrodynamics simulations were performed with the publicly available version of the Athena++ code ( 41 ; 23 ) . Claude Sonnet 4.6 ( 1 ) was used to perform minor optimizations and improve readability for bonditools.py
Avery P. Bailey, Kaitlin M. Kratter, Andrew N. Youdin · 2026
Read Radiating Bondi Flows II: Giant Planet Accretion Models Journal: MNRAS This work made extensive use of the SciPy ( 45 ) , Matplotlib ( 21 ) , and NumPy ( 20 ) packages. Radiation-hydrodynamics simulations were performed with the publicly available version of the Athena++ code ( 41 ; 23 ) . Claude Sonnet 4.6 ( 1 ) was used to perform minor optimizations and improve readability for bonditools.py by Avery P. Bailey, Kaitlin M. Kratter, Andrew N. Youdin (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2603-20377.txt.
Introduction
Bailey and co-authors apply their radiating Bondi flow theory to forming giant planets. In core accretion, late growth depends on gas falling in from the disk. Older models treat this inflow as adiabatic, ignoring the planet's own glow. Paper I showed such feedback can suppress accretion by orders of magnitude. Here, planets in smooth disks see accretion cut by ten to a hundred times. The cut applies inside about 10 AU and weakens for gap-opening planets. Time-dependent simulations confirm the effect is stable and robust.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Avery P. Bailey, Kaitlin M. Kratter, Andrew N. Youdin |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 53041 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2603.20377
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Radiating Bondi Flows II: Giant Planet Accretion Models Journal: MNRAS This work made extensive use of the SciPy ( 45 ) , Matplotlib ( 21 ) , and NumPy ( 20 ) packages. Radiation-hydrodynamics simulations were performed with the publicly available version of the Athena++ code ( 41 ; 23 ) . Claude Sonnet 4.6 ( 1 ) was used to perform minor optimizations and improve readability for bonditools.py Avery P. Bailey, Kaitlin M. Kratter, Andrew N. Youdin Abstract In the core accretion model of giant planet formation, the late stages of runaway growth are regulated by the hydrodynamic infall of gas from the protoplanetary disk. For a subset of planet-disk pairings, this scenario is analogous to the classical Bondi problem, which has motivated a Bondi-like parameterization of accretion in some population synthesis models. Existing models and the associated classical Bondi rate however, are predicated upon an adiabatic equation of state. In reality, the planet and its associated accretion shock supply a luminosity that substantially heats the accretion flow. In Paper I of this series, we demonstrate that such radiative feedback can dramatically suppress accretion by orders of magnitude. Here we quantify this effect under realistic planet-forming conditions. We find that for planets forming in an unperturbed disk, accretion is suppressed by 1-2 orders of magnitude interior to ∼ 10 \sim 10 AU. For planets that open a gap, this feedback is less dramatic and the effect is ∼ \sim 1 order in magnitude. We investigate the effect of various assumptions regarding dust opacities, shock efficiency, and planet radius and find this radiative suppression mechanism to be fairly insensitive to these effects. We also perform full time-dependent simulations demonstrating that the associated adverse entropy profiles are accurate and stable to convection. A simple and flexible set of open-source tools are provided to incorporate this radiative feedback into existing accretion models and population synthesis frameworks. show][email protected] I Introduction In the core accretion paradigm, the later stages of giant planet formation are marked by a period of rapid runaway accretion. When a planet’s gaseous envelope becomes approximately equal in mass to its solid core, adding mass to the envelope also has the effect of shortening the envelope cooling time, accelerating the addition of further mass in a compounding process and marking the start of the runaway phase ( 4 ; 38 ) . The accretion rate continues to increase until reaching a magnitude the protoplanetary disk cannot sustain, at which point the planetary envelope contracts ( 18 ) . The accretion rate in this runaway regime and afterwards is limited in combination by viscous transport in the protoplanetary disk, multi-dimensional effects ( 42 ; 28 ) , and a maximal planetary accretion rate. This maximal planetary accretion rate is either estimated from fits to multi-dimensional numerical simulations ( 42 ; 29 ) e.g. 3 ; 6 ; 26 , or modeled as a Bondi-like accretion rate. While application of Bondi accretion is most appropriate for lower mass (sub-thermal) planets or polar flows, where infall is expected to be more radial in nature, similar parameterizations have been invoked for higher masses, where rotational effects and vertical stratification become non-negligible ( 9 ) . As such, Bondi accretion often finds its way into models of these later stages of giant planet formation. Planetary population synthesis models, used to produce artificial populations for comparison to the observed exoplanet sample, will sometimes employ a Bondi parameterization e.g. the Bern models ( 36 ; 13 ) . Spectral energy distribution calculations ( 10 ) of protoplanets invoke Bondi envelope profiles for optically thicker regimes where planet envelopes are found to be more spherical ( 16 ; 27 ) . Evolutionary models of planets at large orbital separations are also based upon Bondi prescriptions and extended to include other processes like gap opening ( 17 ) or make inferences about the properties of protoplanet candidates proposed to sculpt observed protoplanetary disk substructures ( 18 ) . All these prescriptions however, are based upon the original and most simple ( 5 ) model, in which a planet’s accretion rate depends only on planet mass, the environmental sound speed, and weakly upon the adiabatic index \gamma . This simplicity is, in part, a result of the simple thermodynamics in which isentropy is assumed. In reality, the accretion flow is subject to heating/cooling via its own radiation and that of the young luminous planet. Heating or cooling can modify the entropy of the flow thereby changing the sound speed, the location of the sonic point, and the overall steady-state accretion rate. Through this mechanism, one expects the steady-state Bondi accretion rate may also depend on properties like the luminosity and optics of the accretion flow, complicating the simple Bondi rate and leading to possibly diverse planet outcomes. Thus, self-consistent treatment of this radiative feedback and its effect on the accretion rate, which is entirely absent from existing studies, is the focus of this work. In the preceding work (Paper I), it was shown that inclusion of this radiative feedback mechanism tends to suppress accretion under conditions of high luminosity, optical depth, and slow cooling. This was demonstrated via an idealized set of 1D steady-state models employing constant opacities. The role of this work is to extend those simple yet informative models to realistic planet-forming conditions and quantify the magnitude and robustness of this suppression mechanism. We therefore focus on the computation of f_{\rm acc}\equiv\dot{M}/\dot{M}_{\rm ad} , which is a correction factor for a planet’s steady-state accretion rate \dot{M} relative to that same planet’s standard adiabatic Bondi rate \dot{M}_{\rm ad} . f_{\rm acc} is primarily a function of protoplanetary disk properties, planet mass, and semi major axis. We choose this parameterization to streamline adoption of these corrections within existing computations that use standard Bondi rates. We develop tools 1 1 1 https://github.com/apbailey/radiative-bondi-products necessary to implement f_{\rm acc} into existing models in a flexible and simple manner (see Section V ). The structure of this paper is as follows. In Section II , we briefly restate the steady-state equations (Paper I) and setup for time-dependent simulations. Section III presents a fiducial set of steady-state solutions for realistic protoplanetary disk conditions and corresponding maps of f_{\rm acc} . In Section IV , we present full time-dependent simulations to confirm the robustness of the solutions presented in III – in particular, their stability to convection. In Section V , we describe our open-source tools 1 for population synthesis codes to incorporate the effects of radiative feedback. Finally, we summarize our findings in Section VI . II Equations and Methods II.1 Steady-State Initial Value Problem To determine the 1D radiative steady-state accretion flow onto a planet in Section III , we solve an initial value problem in radius for five dependent variables: density \rho , Mach number \mathcal{M}\equiv v/c_{s} , entropy 2 2 2 this is technically a dimensionless entropy obtained by dividing the true entropy by the specific heat at constant volume S/c_{V} s , luminosity L , and radiation energy density E_{r} . The equations solved are as follows (see Paper I for details): \displaystyle\partial_{r}\ln\rho=\frac{2}{\gamma+1}\left(-\frac{2}{r}-\partial_{r}\ln\mathcal{M}-\frac{\partial_{r}s}{2}\right) (1a) \displaystyle\begin{aligned} \partial_{r}\ln\mathcal{M}=&\frac{(\gamma+1)(2c_{s}^{2}r-GM-c_{s}^{2}r^{2}\partial_{r}s/\gamma)}{2c_{s}^{2}r^{2}\left(\mathcal{M}^{2}-1\right)}\\ &+\frac{\gamma-1}{r}-\frac{\partial_{r}s}{2}\end{aligned} (1b) \displaystyle\partial_{r}s=\frac{\gamma(\gamma-1)}{\dot{M}c_{s}^{2}}{\partial_{r}L} (1c) \displaystyle\partial_{r}L=4\pi r^{2}\rho\kappa_{P}c(a_{r}T^{4}-E_{r}) (1d) \displaystyle\partial_{r}E_{r}=-\frac{L}{4\pi r^{2}c}\left(\frac{2}{r}+\frac{2\partial_{r}L}{L}+3\rho\kappa_{R}\right). (1e) with \gamma the ratio of specific