Can LLMs Prove Robotic Path Planning Optimality? A Benchmark for Research-Level Algorithm Verification
Zhengbang Yang, Md. Tasin Tazwar, Minghan Wei, Zhuangdi Zhu · 2026
Read Can LLMs Prove Robotic Path Planning Optimality? A Benchmark for Research-Level Algorithm Verification by Zhengbang Yang, Md. Tasin Tazwar, Minghan Wei, Zhuangdi Zhu (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2603-19464.txt.
Introduction
Yang and co-authors test whether language models can prove robot path planners optimal. Such proofs need geometric insight and strict multi-step math. Their benchmark holds 34 research-grade proof tasks across planner types. Each task gives the algorithm, its constraints, and the claimed bound. Even top models fail to write fully valid proofs alone. Adding task-specific lemmas in context lifts proof quality a lot. That help beats plain chain-of-thought and giving the true ratio. A fine error study sorts where proofs break.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Zhengbang Yang, Md. Tasin Tazwar, Minghan Wei, Zhuangdi Zhu |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 36736 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2603.19464
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Can LLMs Prove Robotic Path Planning Optimality? A Benchmark for Research-Level Algorithm Verification Zhengbang Yang, Md. Tasin Tazwar, Minghan Wei, Zhuangdi Zhu Abstract Robotic path planning problems are often NP-hard, and practical solutions typically rely on approximation algorithms with provable performance guarantees for general cases. While designing such algorithms is challenging, formally proving their approximation optimality is even more demanding, which requires domain-specific geometric insights and multi-step mathematical reasoning over complex operational constraints. Recent Large Language Models (LLMs) have demonstrated strong performance on mathematical reasoning benchmarks, yet their ability to assist with research-level optimality proofs in robotic path planning remains under-explored. In this work, we introduce the first benchmark for evaluating LLMs on approximation-ratio proofs of robotic path planning algorithms. The benchmark consists of 34 research-grade proof tasks spanning diverse planning problem types and complexity levels, each requiring structured reasoning over algorithm descriptions, problem constraints, and theoretical guarantees. Our evaluation of state-of-the-art proprietary and open-source LLMs reveals that even the strongest models struggle to produce fully valid proofs without external domain knowledge. However, providing LLMs with task-specific in-context lemmas substantially improves reasoning quality, a factor that is more effective than generic chain-of-thought prompting or supplying the ground-truth approximation ratio as posterior knowledge. We further provide fine-grained error analysis to characterize common logical failures and hallucinations, and demonstrate how each error type can be mitigated through targeted context augmentation. I Introduction Robotic path planning problems are usually NP-hard [ 8 , 3 ] , and this field has long relied on approximation algorithms as practical solutions. Even marginal improvements in approximation ratios can yield substantial real-world benefits in deployment time, energy consumption, and mission reliability in varying high-stake domains [ 8 , 3 ] . Therefore, the quality of proposed algorithms plays significant role. Yet while proposing a new planning algorithm is relatively tractable, formally proving its approximation optimality is far more demanding, often requiring human experts days or weeks of careful mathematical and geometric reasoning. The recent emergence of large language models (LLMs) with strong performance in mathematical reasoning [ 22 , 10 , 13 , 2 ] raises a natural question: can LLMs expedite the formal verification of approximation optimality for robotic path planning algorithms? Such a capability would lay the groundwork for automated algorithm validation, and ultimately for the cost-effective discovery of new planning algorithms with stronger optimality guarantees. One might expect LLMs to transfer their mathematical competency to this domain, particularly given their advanced performance on math reasoning benchmarks such as GMS8K [ 6 ] and MATH [ 14 ] . However, the task we investigate is fundamentally distinct, where the planning optimality proofs operate at a research level, involving complex optimization constraints arising from operational requirements, such as cost budgets and terrain or operational restrictions [ 28 , 15 ] . They demand task-specific knowledge of domain lemmas and theorems, and reasoning over long problem formulations that jointly describe the algorithm, the environment, and the optimality objective. Furthermore, a valid proof typically requires multi-step deduction to connect concrete task descriptions to abstract mathematical conditions. For instance, proving the 3/2-approximation guarantee for the metric Traveling Salesman Problem (TSP) requires mapping the tour-planning objective to combinatorial structures (minimum spanning trees (MST), odd-degree vertex sets, and minimum-weight perfect matchings) and then chaining multiple lemmas, e.g. , \mathrm{MST}\leq\mathrm{OPT} , \mathrm{MWPM}\leq\mathrm{OPT}/2 , and triangle-inequality shortcutting to convert an Eulerian walk into a Hamiltonian tour without increasing cost. These characteristics place our investigation well beyond the scope of standard math reasoning. To systematically study this challenge, we introduce a benchmark comprising 34 robotic constrained planning problems from 11 peer-reviewed, published robotic papers. Each instance includes the original problem formulation, algorithm description, and formal performance guarantee as presented in the source work. The tasks are curated from representative constrained path-planning formulations motivated by real robotic deployment settings, including energy-aware navigation, perception-constrained routing, time-critical missions, and multi-robot workload balancing. Each selected paper establishes formal approximation guarantees, enabling us to assess whether LLMs can reason about algorithmic performance bounds rather than merely solving isolated planning instances. Our evaluation reveals several key findings: (1) Current LLMs differ substantially in performance, yet even the strongest models struggle to produce valid optimality proofs without given expert domain knowledge (setting 1, Sec IV-C ). (2) Augmenting prompts with task-relevant in-context knowledge, specifically, lemmas and prior knowledge tailored to the target problem, leads to notable improvements in proof accuracy. (3) Providing the ground-truth approximation ratio as posterior knowledge also improves reasoning quality, though it contributes less than in-context lemmas. (4) Generic chain-of-thought (CoT) [ 27 ] or deduction-inducing prompting alone does not meaningfully reduce task difficulty, though it provides complementary benefit when combined with posterior knowledge. (5) Notably, we find that open-source models such as Qwen 3.5 respond strongly to in-context augmentation, with performance gains that can surpass those achieved by counterpart LLMs. We further provide a fine-grained error analysis (Sec IV-D ) to characterize where LLMs typically fail and how each error type can be mitigated. Our benchmark also introduces a granular evaluation metric that jointly assesses the correctness of the final proof, the quality of the reasoning chain, and the alignment with ground-truth proofs from the original research papers. We will release an automated pipeline for extracting and formalizing path planning algorithms from research papers to facilitate future work in this domain 1 1 1 Our prompts and additional experiment results will be released anonymously to https://anonymous.4open.science/r/RoboticBench-4F48/README.md. . II Related Work LLM assisted path planning: Work along this line explores using LLMs directly as planning agents or algorithm executors. NLGraph benchmark [ 26 ] demonstrated that LLMs possess preliminary abilities to trace shortest paths on simple classic topologies. LLM+P [ 17 ] integrated language models with classical planners, utilizing the LLM to translate natural language problem descriptions into formal specifications that symbolic solvers can process. LLM-A* [ 18 ] integrated language models into the A* search procedure to heuristically navigate planning spaces. Similarly, GraphArena [ 25 ] benchmarked LLMs on their ability to act as algorithmic executors for graph computation tasks, testing their step-by-step traversal on complex routing challenges like the Traveling Salesman Problem. In practical domains, frameworks like TravelPlanner [ 30 ] and Personal Travel Solver [ 23 ] deployed LLMs as autonomous solvers for real-world routing and planning instances, assessing their ability to satisfy multifaceted constraints. They evaluate LLMs as solvers of planning instances rather than investigating whether LLMs can reason about the optimality of proposed algorithms. LLM on scientific or mathematical reasoning: A parallel thread evaluates LLMs on scientific and mathematical reasoning more broadly. Datasets such as GMS8K [ 6 ] , MATH [ 14 ] , PRM800K [ 16 ] provided mathematical problems ranging from elementary to undergraduate-level difficulty. State-of-the-art LLMs tend to saturate on these math benchmarks with (near-) expert performance. More advanced benchmarks include ARB [ 21 ] , OmniMATH [ 10 ] , Olympiadbench [ 13 ] , Matharena [ 2 ] . They target general mathematical competitions where problems are mostly self-contained and drawn from established Olympiad corpora. While FrontierMath [ 11 ] remains a formidable challenge for state-of-the-art models, it merely evaluates final answers rather than demanding complete proofs or granular reasoning steps. Furthermore, its closed-source nature limits community-driven