Journal Research Data Policies in Materials Science

Lukas Hörmann, Hemanadhan Myneni, Rwayda Kh. S. Al-Hamd, Katarina Batalović, Silvia Bonfanti, Federico Grasselli, Saulius Gražulis, Bahattin Koç, Konstantinos Konstantinou, Ivor Lončarić, Nataliya Lopanitsyna, José Manuel Oliveira, Paolo Pegolo, Patrícia Ramos, Kevin Rossi, Sebastian P. Schwaminger, Edith Simmen, Milica Todorović, Markus Stricker, Jonathan Schmidt · 2026

Read Journal Research Data Policies in Materials Science by Lukas Hörmann, Hemanadhan Myneni, Rwayda Kh. S. Al-Hamd, Katarina Batalović, Silvia Bonfanti, Federico Grasselli, Saulius Gražulis, Bahattin Koç, Konstantinos Konstantinou, Ivor Lončarić, Nataliya Lopanitsyna, José Manuel Oliveira, Paolo Pegolo, Patrícia Ramos, Kevin Rossi, Sebastian P. Schwaminger, Edith Simmen, Milica Todorović, Markus Stricker, Jonathan Schmidt (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2603-19301.txt.

Introduction

Hörmann and co-authors survey data sharing rules at 171 journals in materials science. Nearly all journals now post a data policy, and most ask for a data availability note. But firm demands stay rare, and open deposit of raw data is seldom required. Rules for research software lag far behind those for data. Versioning, identifiers, and run environments get little attention. A shared score shows wide gaps between journals. Neither impact factor nor access type predicts how strict a policy is.

Catalog record

CREATORLukas Hörmann, Hemanadhan Myneni, Rwayda Kh. S. Al-Hamd, Katarina Batalović, Silvia Bonfanti, Federico Grasselli, Saulius Gražulis, Bahattin Koç, Konstantinos Konstantinou, Ivor Lončarić, Nataliya Lopanitsyna, José Manuel Oliveira, Paolo Pegolo, Patrícia Ramos, Kevin Rossi, Sebastian P. Schwaminger, Edith Simmen, Milica Todorović, Markus Stricker, Jonathan Schmidt
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE41249
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2603.19301

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Journal Research Data Policies in Materials Science Lukas Hörmann, Hemanadhan Myneni, Rwayda Kh. S. Al-Hamd, Katarina Batalović, Silvia Bonfanti, Federico Grasselli, Saulius Gražulis, Bahattin Koç, Konstantinos Konstantinou, Ivor Lončarić, Nataliya Lopanitsyna, José Manuel Oliveira, Paolo Pegolo, Patrícia Ramos, Kevin Rossi, Sebastian P. Schwaminger, Edith Simmen, Milica Todorović, Markus Stricker, Jonathan Schmidt Abstract Open and reproducible research in materials science relies on the availability of data, code, and common metadata standards. Journal research data policies (RDPs) remain a primary mechanism by which publication norms are defined and enforced. We survey RDPs for 171 materials science journals spanning 17 publishers, using an expanded coding framework that captures both data-and-code sharing behavior as well as refereeing standards. We find clear signs of progress in comparison to earlier research on RDPs: nearly all journals provide an RDP, and most mention data availability statements. However, enforceable requirements remain uncommon, public deposition of underlying data is rarely mandatory, and FAIR publication is typically encouraged rather than required. Expectations for research software are substantially less developed than those for data, with limited attention to versioning and persistent identifiers, dependency disclosure, reproducible execution environments, or software quality practices. Aggregating the findings on policy features into an open research data score reveals pronounced heterogeneity across journals. Neither impact factor nor access model reliably predicts policy strength. Double-coding further shows that more complex policies and stricter policies can be more challenging to interpret consistently, and we highlight challenges in consistent RDP encoding across studies. Lastly, we conclude with recommended best practice directions for the future. I Introduction The field of materials science has witnessed a transformative acceleration of research driven by the integration of data-driven approaches and machine learning 67 ; 56 ; 57 ; 5 . As researchers strive to develop innovative materials with tailored properties for applications ranging from energy storage and conversion to electronics by relying on data-heavy workflows, the need for data-availability has never been more critical. Achieving verifiable results requires systematic management and sharing of the underlying research artifacts, including all datasets and the software and workflows used to generate and analyze them, beyond what can be reported in the manuscript alone 41 ; 58 ; 80 . An environment of data sharing, code sharing and competitive benchmarks ideally lead to a state of frictionless reproducibility which has been a key driver of progress in machine learning 18 and its application to materials science. A commitment to open research practices fosters collaboration, accelerates discovery, enables validation of results, and facilitates the reuse of tools across disciplines 57 ; 52 . For data-driven methods in particular, the availability of high-quality, machine-readable datasets forms the essential foundation for building robust models 60 . Data sharing practices vary substantially across scientific disciplines. In crystallography and structural biology, data sharing is well established: the Protein Data Bank (PDB) founded in the 1970s 15 evolved into the global archive for macromolecular structures 6 ; 78 . By 2008, deposition of not only structure coordinates but also structure factors and Nuclear Magnetic Resonance restraints became mandatory 68 , enabling validation and, in some cases, improvement of the original findings. This policy, coordinated by the Worldwide PDB consortium 82 and supported by major publishers and funding agencies, substantially improved the availability of structural data and enabled machine learning success stories, such as in protein folding prediction 73 ; 37 ; 72 ; 84 . More recently, advances in computing and storage have enabled repositories for raw diffraction and microscopy data 45 . In the materials science community, data sharing is likewise recognized as essential to advancing the field, as highlighted by the adoption of international frameworks such as the FAIR (Findable, Accessible, Interoperable, Reusable) principles for data 80 and code 3 in materials science 26 . Although no single centralized repository exists for crystal structure data, maintainers of major computational databases 16 ; 34 ; 39 ; 19 ; 11 ; 66 have integrated the OPTIMADE API standard 22 , effectively creating a common data space for basic, simulated crystal structure data. Although crystal structures are only a small subspace of the diverse materials science research data, these successful data-sharing initiatives demonstrate that best practices can be adapted to address gaps in materials-data sharing standards. Various ongoing projects and communities work on the development of data and metadata standards, such as NOMAD 19 , the Battery Data Genome 76 , the Materials Genome Initiative 79 , and the Materials Research Data Alliance 43 , and strategies have been proposed to encourage authors to share data at all levels. This includes initiatives by funding agencies 21 ; 17 ; 65 ; 13 ; 70 ; 71 , universities 55 ; 75 , research communities 42 , and individual research groups. Despite global community efforts, issues such as the lack of standardization of data formats, reluctance to share proprietary or sensitive data, insecurities about sharing data and code, and insufficient infrastructure for storage and access continue to hinder progress 32 ; 27 ; 76 . Furthermore, the complexity, heterogeneity, and sheer volume of materials science data — much of it generated without established curation frameworks — pose persistent obstacles to effective data management 30 . In combination with the rapid expansion of machine-learning–driven research, these limitations raise a second, more systemic risk: low-quality, weakly documented, or insufficiently validated datasets and workflows can be reused at scale, silently propagating errors through follow-on studies and into widely used databases, generating noise and erroneous conclusions. Strengthening data stewardship and reproducibility practices is therefore not only a matter of more efficient data management, but also a prerequisite for maintaining credibility as machine learning (ML) becomes increasingly embedded in materials science. Research across STEM disciplines (science, technology, engineering, mathematics) highlights that journals are the arbiters of community practice and can, even more than funding bodies, incentivize authors to follow community-specific best practices 38 that move the field forward 62 ; 74 ; 44 ; 2 . However, such journal-specific policies have often been found inadequate in their standards, and in some cases, entirely absent 53 ; 54 ; 14 ; 74 ; 10 ; 48 ; 7 ; 31 ; 63 ; 83 ; 46 ; 25 ; 77 ; 51 . For example, Rousi et al. (2020) 54 reported that 35\text{\,}\mathrm{\%} of the highly cited physics journals they examined had no research data policy (RDP), while Resnik et al. (2019) 53 found that 43.6\text{\,}\mathrm{\%} of the examined journals did not address data sharing in their policies at all. There are systemic challenges to adopting more comprehensive and stringent RDPs. First, such policies inevitably impose additional workload on researchers, reviewers, and editors 28 , which can conflict with the incentives of profit-driven journals. Stricter standards may slow publication processes and reduce the number of accepted manuscripts, potentially lowering revenue, particularly in open-access models where income is tied to publication volume. Second, in many materials science domains, companies are significant contributors to research but are often unable to share data 64 . Enforcing strict data publication standards could reduce their scientific contributions to public research. On the other hand, access to results and code is necessary for referees and editors to make informed judgments about reproducibility. Currently, it is largely

Read the complete text