Faster alone vs. further together: The speed and impact of researchers’ responses to societal crises
2026
Read Faster alone vs. further together: The speed and impact of researchers’ responses to societal crises (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2603-19246.txt.
Introduction
Coles and co-authors ask how solo and team researchers differ when they respond to world crises. They track over 1.5 million papers on 25 crises from more than 3 million authors. Solo authors publish their responses faster than teams. Yet team work draws more notice in journals, news, and policy. Gains from team size fade as teams grow, and the edge varies by crisis. Other traits, like state strength and lead expertise, also shape impact. The old proverb on speed and reach holds up.
Catalog record
| YEAR | 2026 |
|---|---|
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 33467 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2603.19246
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Faster alone vs. further together: The speed and impact of researchers’ responses to societal crises Abstract Article Unpublished manuscript Faster alone vs. further together: The speed and impact of researchers’ responses to societal crises Nicholas A. Coles 1,∗ , Joao Francisco Goes Braga Takayanagi 1 , Stephen M. Fiore 2 , Lingfei Wu 3 1 Department of Psychology, University of Florida, Gainesville, USA. 2 Institute of Simulation and Training, University of Central Florida, Orlando, USA. 3 School of Computing and Information, University of Pittsburgh, Pittsburgh, USA. ∗ Corresponding author: [email protected] Throughout the 21st century, society encountered numerous crises that demanded quick and widespread action. In the present work, we documented researchers’ responses to 25 of these crises, analyzing 1,537,284 published responses from 3,262,152 researchers spanning 225 countries and territories. An analysis of publication speed and citation patterns yielded support for a proverbial claim: “to go fast, go alone; to go far, go together”. Solo authors were quicker to publish responses to societal crises – but their responses received less attention in scholarly, news, and policy venues. Growth towards large-scale collaboration was associated with increased impact; However, this team size advantage was characterized by diminishing returns and significantly varied across sampled crises. Furthermore, pluralistic machine learning modeling highlights the importance of considering additional context, such as government effectiveness and the expertise of team leaders. Taken together, results facilitate evidence-based conversations regarding how researchers optimize speed and impact in the midst of societal crises. Throughout history, human societies have encountered and navigated crises that demanded quick, urgent, and widespread action. For example, in the first quarter of the 21st century, society witnessed some of the deadliest terrorist attacks in modern history, a global pandemic, and the rapid release of AI technologies. For decades, researchers have worked to document how people respond to these societal crises, helping separate proverbial myths from reality. For example, contrary to common belief, research suggests that people tend to respond to crises not with panic – but with order, solidarity, and cooperation 1,2 . Curiously, the actions of researchers themselves are often overlooked in crisis response research – leaving an incomplete narrative. For example, to understand society’s response to the September 11 terrorism attacks, it is important to consider that a leading academic society endorsed psychologists’ participation in detainee interrogation 3 . To understand society’s response to the COVID-19 pandemic 4 , it is important to consider the record-setting speed in which researchers developed mRNA vaccines 5 . Last, to understand how society responds to the shock of AI technologies, we argue it will once again be important to consider the role of researchers – such as the ultra-massive teams that developed GPT-4 6 , DeepSeek V3 7 , and other technologies at the center of an ongoing “AI race” 8 . In the present work, we document researchers’ responses to 25 of these societal crises, analyzing a total of 1,537,284 published responses from 3,262,152 researchers spanning 225 countries and territories (Figure 1). Proverbial claims about collaboration suggests “to go fast, go alone; to go far, go together”. This belief is also often echoed in the scientific community. Proponents of team science often suggest that collaboration is a way to “go further,” as it (a) facilitates role specialization, (b) increases total effort dedicated to a problem, and (c) creates conditions believed to facilitate recombinant growth, wisdom of the crowd, and/or collective intelligence 9–15 . These benefits, however, are often suggested to come at a cost that may be particularly noteworthy during crisis: speed. Indeed, proponents of team science also often emphasize the time needed to (a) assemble teams, (b) negotiate responsibilities, (c) navigate different institutional policies, (d) manage disagreements, and so on 16–19 . Working alone is presumed to be quicker, with simpler coordination, fewer bureaucratic constraints, and greater decision-making agility. In the present work, we test proverbial claims at scale, examining 1,537,284 separate published responses from a total of 3,262,152 researchers. As methodological tests of speed, we borrowed from the sociological notion of focusing events 20 . More specifically, we sampled societal crises that (a) entered mainstream awareness relatively suddenly, and (b) received relatively novel names (e.g., “Hurricane Katrina”; Figure 2, Panel A). This allowed us to estimate response speed by comparing (a) the approximate date that most people became aware of each crisis, to (b) the publication dates of papers explicitly mentioning relevant keywords (retrieved via OpenAlex 21 ). To index the impact of researchers’ published responses, we considered the number of citations their work received in scholarly, news, and policy venues (tracked by OpenAlex 21 and Altmetric 22 ). Last, to establish comparative benchmarks, we compared team size to 12 other predictors often considered at the individual (e.g., leader prestige), group (e.g., number of involved institutions), and societal level (e.g., political stability). Here, we leveraged a pluralistic set of machine learning models to derive robust estimates of the extent to which each variable predicts the speed and impact of researchers’ responses to crises 23 . Expanding upon insights from seminal field studies 1,2 , the present work provides a relatively comprehensive assessment of researchers’ published responses to an extreme phenomenon: societal crises. Theoretically, this tests potentially extreme boundary conditions of a robust finding in research on team science: work from larger teams often achieves more impact (e.g., in scholarly articles, patents, and policy venues), often at the cost of other potentially desirable outcomes (e.g., innovativeness) 24–29 . By sampling a relatively large number of events, we further estimate the reliability of such relationships across a wide variety of crises (e.g., the H1N1 pandemic, Brexit, and the announcement of an impending “metaverse”). Taken together, our work not only lends itself to a more complete narrative of how society responds to crisis, but also to evidence-based conversations regarding how to optimize the speed and impact of researchers’ responses to these crises. Results Similar to what was documented decades ago with the general population, our results illustrate that researchers also often respond to crisis with order, solidarity, and cooperation 1,2 . In total, we uncovered 1,537,284 published responses to 25 societal crises – representing the collective response of 3,262,152 researchers from 225 countries and territories (Figure 1). In many instances, we found that researchers do “go alone”. Averaged across crises, 49.1% of published responses were attributed to a single author ( SD = 22.0% across crises). The other 50.9% of the time, researchers “go together,” with teams ranging from 2 to 100+ co-authors. Next, we describe the implications this decision has for the speed and impact of their published responses. When responding to crises, solo authorship is faster but less impactful Proverbial claims about collaboration suggests “to go fast, go alone; to go far, go together”. Consistent with such notions, researchers were significantly quicker to publish responses as solo authors vs. teams (Δ = 100 days; Mann-Whitney W = 1.88 × 10 11 , p < .001, rank-biserial r = .18). Intriguingly, however, the link between the speed and size of teams was best characterized as weakly quadratic – as opposed to linear (Δ BIC = 4195) or logarithmic (Δ BIC = 1135; Figure 2, Panel B). More specifically, speed most sharply decreased as researchers moved from (a)