The impact of prescriptions in phenomenological extractions of Transverse Momentum Dependent distributions
Matteo Cerutti, Andrea Simonelli · 2026
Read The impact of prescriptions in phenomenological extractions of Transverse Momentum Dependent distributions by Matteo Cerutti, Andrea Simonelli (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2603-19088.txt.
Introduction
Cerutti and Simonelli probe a hidden source of doubt in fits of parton momentum spreads. Such spreads describe how quarks move sideways inside fast protons. Fits at low energy agree well under varied choices for a key cutoff rule. The extracted spreads also match at small sideways motion. At mid-range motion, though, the choices pull apart in a clear way. That split feeds into forecasts for high-energy Drell-Yan events. The team calls the cutoff rule an intrinsic theory doubt in this fit frame.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Matteo Cerutti, Andrea Simonelli |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 73009 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2603.19088
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
The impact of prescriptions in phenomenological extractions of Transverse Momentum Dependent distributions Matteo Cerutti, Andrea Simonelli Abstract We investigate the impact of phenomenological prescriptions in the Collins–Soper–Sterman (CSS) approach for global extractions of Transverse Momentum Distributions (TMDs). We show that fits to low-energy Drell-Yan data with different choices of b ∗ b_{*} prescription yield equally good agreement with data and similar TMDs at small partonic transverse momentum. In contrast, sizable differences emerge at intermediate transverse momentum region, significantly affecting the predictions for high-energy Drell-Yan processes. Our results demonstrate that the b ∗ b_{*} prescription represents an intrinsic source of theoretical uncertainty in the CSS approach, introducing systematic effects that influence TMD extractions and their interpretation. At the same time, our analysis emphasizes the interplay between data at different energy scales in assessing the effect of phenomenological prescriptions in TMD fits adopting the CSS framework. I Introduction The three-dimensional structure of hadrons, the bound states of Quantum Chromodynamics (QCD), provides essential insight into color confinement and hadronization. A powerful tool to explore it is given by transverse-momentum-dependent (TMD) parton densities, which describe how the spin and three-dimensional motion of partons correlate with the spin–momentum properties of the hadron that confines them Rogers 2016 ; Diehl 2016 ; Angeles-Martinez et al. 2015 ; Bacchetta 2016 ; Scimemi 2019 ; Boussarie et al. 2023 ; Lorcé et al. 2025 . These densities F_{j/h} extend the concept of standard parton distribution functions (PDFs), and are often given an intuitive interpretation as describing the distribution of a parton of species j with light-cone momentum fraction x and transverse momentum \bm{k}_{\perp} inside a hadron h . They arise in factorization theorems of processes sensitive to the transverse momentum \bm{q}_{T} of a final state relative to a specified axis, in the kinematic limit where |\bm{q}_{T}| is much smaller than the hard scale Q characterizing the observable Ji et al. 2005 ; Collins 2011 ; Echevarria et al. 2012 . A notable example is Drell-Yan (DY) lepton-pair production from hadron-hadron collisions, in which the hard scale is given by the invariant mass squared Q^{2} of the lepton pair and \bm{q}_{T} is the transverse momentum of the pair measured with respect to the beam axis. In the kinematic domain of TMD factorization, where |\bm{q}_{T}|\ll Q , the differential DY cross section can be written as 1 1 1 Note that we neglected kinematic power corrections Vladimirov 2023 ; Piloneta and Vladimirov 2024 . \begin{split}&\frac{d\sigma^{\text{DY}}}{d|\bm{q}_{T}|\,dy\,dQ}=\frac{16\pi^{2}\alpha^{2}|\bm{q}_{T}|}{9Q^{3}}\,x_{1}\,x_{2}\,{\cal H}^{\text{DY}}\big(a_{S}(\mu);{Q}/{\mu}\big)\,\sum_{q}c_{q}(Q^{2})\\ &\qquad\times\int d^{2}{\bm{k}_{\perp}}_{1}\,d^{2}{\bm{k}_{\perp}}_{2}\,F_{q/h_{1}}(x_{1},{\bm{k}_{\perp}^{2}}_{1};\mu,\zeta_{1})\,F_{\bar{q}/h_{2}}(x_{2},{\bm{k}_{\perp}^{2}}_{2};\mu,\zeta_{2})\,\delta^{(2)}({\bm{k}_{\perp}}_{1}+{\bm{k}_{\perp}}_{2}-\bm{q}_{T})\;+(1\leftrightarrow 2)\;,\end{split} (1) where \alpha denotes the electromagnetic coupling and x_{1}=Qe^{y}/\sqrt{s} , x_{2}=Qe^{-y}/\sqrt{s} are the longitudinal momentum fractions carried by the incoming partons, with y the pseudorapidity of the lepton pair. For simplicity, we restrict to unpolarized quarks inside unpolarized hadrons h_{1} and h_{2} . The hard function {\cal H}^{\text{DY}} encodes the virtual part of the scattering and depends on Q and on the renormalization scale \mu . It is fully under perturbative control and can be expanded in powers of a_{s}=\alpha_{s}/(4\pi) Collins and Rogers 2017 . The sum runs over all active quark flavors, and c_{q} are the standard electroweak charges (see, e.g. , Ref. Bacchetta et al. 2020 for their specific expressions). The second line of Eq. ( 1 ) contains the convolution of the unpolarized TMD PDFs F_{q/h_{1}} and F_{\bar{q}/h_{2}} . They depend on the longitudinal x_{1,2} and transverse {\bm{k}_{\perp}}_{1,2} momenta of the incoming parton, as well as on the renormalization ( \mu ) and rapidity ( \zeta ) scales, here set as \mu^{2}=\zeta_{1}=\zeta_{2}=Q^{2} . Most importantly, they contain an intrinsic non-perturbative core that becomes increasingly relevant as |\bm{k}_{\perp}| decreases. This is reflected in the DY spectrum at small |\bm{q}_{T}| , which requires the introduction of non - perturbative physics, in contrast with the regime |\bm{q}_{T}|\sim Q where the transverse-momentum dependence is generated perturbatively Collins et al. 1985 ; Bozzi et al. 2006 ; Collins 2011 ; Aybat and Rogers 2011 . Such scenario poses the difficult challenge of separating genuine non-perturbative contributions from those parts that can still be treated using perturbative techniques. This is a central objective in TMD phenomenology. In fact, most efforts are dedicated to disentangle the non-perturbative core of TMD parton densities, extract it from data, and interpret it in terms of physically meaningful functions encoding the intrinsic three-dimensional motion of partons in hadrons. Ideally, the methodology should remain independent of arbitrary assumptions, with different parameterizations eventually converging to the same physical description. However, modeling non-perturbative physics inevitably builds on choices, assumptions and prescriptions whose effects are difficult to control, leading to extracted quantities that represent a combination of different intertwined effects. This can potentially obscure the interpretation of the outcome of the phenomenological analysis, although still providing an excellent agreement with experimental data. Reducing the phenomenological bias is therefore an important concern, particularly in view of the tensions currently reported among TMD extractions by different groups (see Ref. Moos et al. 2025 ). The foundations of TMD phenomenology traces back to the Collins–Soper–Sterman (CSS) formalism Collins and Soper 1982 ; Collins et al. 1985 , which will be reviewed in Section II.1 . This approach has been extensively developed and refined, reaching very high perturbative accuracy, up to next-to-next-to-next-to-leading log N 3 LL (and approximate N 4 LL for Drell–Yan processes) in the most recent studies Moos et al. 2025 ; Bacchetta et al. 2025a ; Bacchetta et al. 2024 ; Moos et al. 2024 ; Bacchetta et al. 2022 ; Rossi et al. 2025 ; Barry et al. 2025 . In these studies, the parameterization of the non-perturbative core of TMDs has reached high level of complexity, and only in some cases it is possible to extract physically interpretable quantities like the average partonic transverse momentum, which often depend on procedures based on specific assumptions (see, e.g. , Sec. IV B.4 of Ref. Bacchetta et al. 2024 ). More recently, in order to reduce the potential bias associated with model choices, neural networks have been successfully tested to parametrize the non-perturbative components of TMDs Bacchetta et al. 2025a ; Avkhadiev et al. 2025 . This strategy is shown to improve the description of the data and provide more reliable error bands, increasing the confidence that the underlying physics is contained within the extracted uncertainties. The limitation of this approach is the loss of direct interpretability of the results in terms of QCD mechanisms, which remains one of the strengths of more traditional parameterizations. Alternative approaches Gonzalez-Hernandez et al. 2023 ; Aslan et al. 2024 ; Simonelli 2025 , which aim to maximize the interpretability of the results, have been proposed only recently and are therefore still at an early stage of phenomenological development. At present, the original CSS approach remains the most widely used and extensively adopted framework for TMD extractions. The purpose of this work is to assess the impact of potential biases inherent in the phenomenological implementation of the CSS approach. We provide explicit examples by performing fits to a selection of Drell–Yan experimental data and discuss the practical advantages and intrinsic limitations of this standard approach. Specifically, we present a detailed analysis of the effects of the phenomenological assumptions introduced by the so-called “ b_{*} prescription” to avoid hitting the Landau pole. We emphasize that increasing awareness of the potential