Maximum entropy distributions of wavefunctions at thermal equilibrium
Jacob T. Willson, Henrik J. Heelweg, Adam P. Willard · 2026
Read Maximum entropy distributions of wavefunctions at thermal equilibrium by Jacob T. Willson, Henrik J. Heelweg, Adam P. Willard (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2603-19060.txt.
Introduction
Willson and co-authors seek the rule that sets how quantum wavefunctions spread at thermal balance. Classic theory gives energy states a Boltzmann spread, but wavefunctions lack a fixed energy. They apply a maximum entropy rule to the wavefunction set. A cap on mean energy alone fails to give a valid balance state. A cap on the shape of the state spread also fails. A third cap on measurement entropy proves key. It ties balance to a divergence from the Gibbs state, hinting at new physics.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Jacob T. Willson, Henrik J. Heelweg, Adam P. Willard |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 57898 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2603.19060
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Maximum entropy distributions of wavefunctions at thermal equilibrium Jacob T. Willson, Henrik J. Heelweg, Adam P. Willard Abstract Statistical mechanics reveals that the properties of a macroscopic physical system emerge as an average over an ensemble of statistically independent microscopic subsystems, each occupying a specific microstate. In the study of quantum systems, these microstates can be chosen to correspond to the pure state wavefunctions of individual quantum systems. However, the physical principles that govern the distribution of a pure state wavefunction ensemble, even under conditions of thermal equilibrium, are not well established. For instance, the canonical Boltzmann distribution cannot be applied to wavefunctions because they lack a definite energy. In this manuscript, we present a maximum entropy principle for the quantum wavefunction ensemble at thermal equilibrium, the so-called Scrooge ensemble. We highlight that a constraint on the energy expectation value, or even the shape of the associated eigenstate distribution, fails to yield a valid equilibrium state. We find that in addition to these constraints, one must also constrain the measurement entropy to be equal to the Rényi divergence of the ensemble with respect to the Gibbs state, indicating that the Rényi divergence may have uninvestigated physical importance to thermal equilibrium in quantum systems. Introduction Quantum statistical mechanics is naturally formulated in a basis of energy eigenstates. According to this formulation, the observable properties of a macroscopic quantum system represent an average over a weighted ensemble of these eigenstates. It therefore stands to reason that before observation, such a system is represented by an equivalently weighted ensemble of wavefunction states that are yet to be collapsed. Remarkably, the physical principles that determine the weighting of a wavefunction ensemble at thermal equilibrium are not well understood. Here, we consider the role of entropy maximization in shaping the distribution of wavefunction states within an equilibrium ensemble. The statistical mechanical formulation of thermal equilibrium is founded on the maximum entropy principle. This principle states that the equilibrium distribution of system microstates is the one that maximizes entropy subject to the system’s physical constraints. 26 ; 25 For quantum systems represented in a basis of eigenstates, when the average energy of the eigenstate ensemble is constrained, entropy maximization yields the well-known Gibbs state, in which eigenstates are Boltzmann distributed, as represented by the density matrix, \rho_{\mathrm{G}}=\frac{e^{-\beta H}}{\mathrm{Tr}\{e^{-\beta H}\}}, (1) where H denotes the system Hamiltonian and 1/\beta=k_{\mathrm{B}}T is the Boltzmann constant times temperature. A foundational inconsistency arises when this principle is applied to an ensemble of pure state wavefunctions, distributed according to the classical probability distribution P(\Gamma) , where \Gamma=\ket{\psi}\bra{\psi} is the density operator representation of the single system wavefunction, \ket{\psi} . Maximizing the entropy of this distribution with the same average energy constraint fails to produce the Gibbs state. 10 ; 8 ; 34 ; 3 Therefore, if the wavefunction ensemble is governed by a maximum entropy principle, then it must be subject to a different set of physical constraints. These constraints must shape the distribution in such a way as to be consistent with the Gibbs state upon observation. In this manuscript, we present the constraints necessary to achieve this consistency and examine why the conventional constraint on average energy, or even on the Gibbs state itself, fails to yield a valid thermal distribution. It is worthwhile to note that there has been skepticism surrounding the seemingly straightforward extension of statistical mechanical principles to wavefunction ensembles. Most notably, it was argued by Jaynes that a distribution of pure state wavefunctions, cannot serve as a valid foundation for statistical mechanics because the state distribution function, P(\Gamma) , does not define the probabilities of mutually exclusive events. 25 Jaynes argued that wavefunction states are only mutually exclusive if they are orthogonal, and therefore, a quantum state probability distribution is only valid if it is restricted to an orthonormal set of states. We argue, however, that although non-orthogonal wavefunction states are observationally indistinguishable, they are formally distinct quantum states. For example, they are precisely distinguishable (and therefore mutually exclusive) in the numerical simulation of model quantum systems. If a statistical mechanical formulation of a simulated ensemble of pure state wavefunctions is possible, then it is, at least in principle, physically meaningful and worthy of study (even if these studies are purely theoretical). Figure 1: Maximum entropy distribution derived from different physical constraints. (a) An ensemble of wavefunctions P(\Gamma) can be compactly represented by a density operator \rho . Maximizing the entropy of P(\Gamma) is not equivalent to maximizing the entropy of \rho , subject to the same constraint. (b) The energy constrained ensemble (ECE) is the quantum analogue of the classical canonical ensemble, maximizing entropy under an average energy constraint. (c) The Gibbs-state constrained ensemble (GCE) maximizes entropy among distributions that average to the Gibbs state. (d) The Scrooge ensemble maximizes entropy under a constraint on the average Rényi divergence D(\Gamma\|\rho) of \Gamma from \rho . We begin by formalizing the entropy of a quantum state ensemble. In the standard formulation of quantum statistical mechanics, fundamental thermodynamic properties are defined in relation to the von Neumann entropy, 48 S_{\mathrm{vN}}(\rho)=-\mathrm{Tr}\{\rho\ln\rho\}=-\sum_{k}p_{k}\ln p_{k}, (2) where \rho is the density operator, and in the second equality the trace is represented by a sum over eigenstates, where p_{k} denotes the probability of observing a system in the k th eigenstate. In this study, we define the entropy of a wavefunction ensemble (hereby referred to as the P -ensemble entropy) analogously as, S_{P}=-\int[d\Gamma]P(\Gamma)\ln P(\Gamma), (3) where the integral is taken over the Haar measure within the state space of all possible pure state wavefunctions, and P(\Gamma) is the probability that the system is in state \Gamma . 18 ; 16 Although there is no apparent connection between the thermodynamic entropy, S_{\mathrm{vN}} , and the P -ensemble entropy, S_{P} , the associated distribution, P(\Gamma) contains useful physical information. For instance, the ensemble density operator (and therefore all of standard quantum statistical mechanics) is fully encoded by P(\Gamma) , as the first moment of the distribution, i.e. , \rho=\int[d\Gamma]\Gamma P(\Gamma). (4) Furthermore, additional information about the ensemble is contained within the higher moments of P(\Gamma) . This information is, in principle, experimentally accessible, for example, with experimental protocols that utilize quantum information platforms, 15 ; 23 ; 31 ; 38 or single-molecule spectroscopy. 17 ; 18 ; 16 The mapping from P(\Gamma) to \rho is not one-to-one, i.e. , there are many possible wavefunction ensembles capable of representing a given ensemble density matrix, \rho . The first attempt to derive an expression for P(\Gamma) at equilibrium was by Park and Band, who defined an entropy similar to eq. 3 , but defined over all possible density matrices, which they took as the fundamental physical states of quantum systems. 35 ; 6 ; 36 ; 7 Their formalism was later refined by Slater, who reduced the probability space to only include pure states; 42 ; 44 however, his analysis was restricted to small spin systems. 43 ; 45 Later, Brody and Hughston considered the full P -ensemble, maximizing S_{P} subject to a constraint on the average energy expectation value. In addition, they considered the maximum S_{P} distribution for a two-level system subject to a constraint to the Gibbs state. 10 ; 11 ; 12 ;