Preference-Based Optimisation in Group Decision-Making

A.R.M. Wolfert · 2026

Read Preference-Based Optimisation in Group Decision-Making by A.R.M. Wolfert (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2603-19050.txt.

Introduction

Wolfert argues that group design choices fail when rival goals are merged with no sound base in preference. Such methods yield sets of trade-off options rather than one clear decision. Only people set goals, so preference is the right base. He sets four rules for design-decision systems. All goals and limits are scored in one preference domain. System performance and actor wishes share one space. Actors set their own weights, and the solver returns one best-fit choice. A method and solver put this into practice.

Catalog record

CREATORA.R.M. Wolfert
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE70379
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2603.19050

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Preference-Based Optimisation in Group Decision-Making A.R.M. Wolfert Abstract Conventional multi-objective optimisation approaches (e.g., MOO-CP or MIP) typically fail in group decision-making by aggregating heterogeneous objectives without a valid preference foundation, producing Pareto-dominance sets instead of a unique, actionable decision. Because only humans can define objectives, their preferences constitute the only legitimate basis for decision-making. Accordingly, four essential conditions for complex, multi-level design–decision systems are established: (1) Preference-Key — all objectives, constraints, and trade-offs are evaluated within a unified preference domain using valid preference function modelling (PFM); (2) Integration — feasible system performance (“object-capability”) and acceptable actor preferences (“subject-desirability”) coexist within a single design–decision space; (3) Association — actors can freely specify their individual preferences and weights, enabling consistent aggregation towards group-optimal decision-making; and (4) Uniqueness — the solver identifies a single best-fit solution with maximum aggregated preference. The open design and decision system (ODESYS) methodology, employing the IMAP (Integrative Maximisation of Aggregated Preferences) solver that satisfies these conditions, enables fully integrated multi-objective design optimisation and multi-criteria decision-making (MODO-MCDM). Its extension within the ODESYS/FIVES formulation, introduced here, broadens applicability while excelling in elegant simplicity. It explicitly operationalises affine preference aggregation and preserves equivalence with previously validated ODESYS 1.0 results. By mapping all system behaviour into a unified, goal-oriented preference-performance domain and directly aggregating actor preferences via PFM, ODESYS/FIVES/IMAP confronts system complexity and delivers a single, best-fit solution—even for highly constrained combinatorial group decision problems. In doing so, it guarantees feasible and acceptable outcomes, providing pure group design–decision support that surpasses conventional methods, which may generate numerical results yet lack group decision validity. Two illustrative applications—a marine installation and a multi-constrained vessel allocation problem—demonstrate how ODESYS/FIVES produces a unique, preference-based solution that integrates stakeholder interests across system levels. This approach effectively transforms multi-objective optimisation into pure group decision-making, achieving a best-fit-for-common-purpose within socio-physical reach. Keywords: Integrative maximisation of aggregated preference (IMAP); Multi-objective optimisation (MOO); Multi-actor open design & decision systems (ODESYS); Constrained programming (CP) and Mixed Integer Programming (MIP); Parametric Design; Socio-technical algorithmics Article history: Compiled March 18, 2026 Introduction Across systems engineering, design, and decision science, multi-objective optimisation (MOO) is widely recognised as a core group decision-support activity for confronting complexity. Contemporary problems involve heterogeneous objectives—e.g., availability, affordability, sustainability, and aesthetic value—evaluated by multiple stakeholders under uncertainty and dynamic conditions. Optimisation must therefore move beyond purely physical performance metrics and explicitly incorporate stakeholder preferences (utility or value), as only these provide a valid basis for goal-oriented choice. Separation between optimisation and preference evaluation undermines the design–decision outcome, since only the human-subject is goal-oriented and can set objectives, not the physical-object. Foundational work, such as Decision-Based Design (DBD) ( 55 ) , Value Engineering ( 54 ) , and utility-based design formulations ( 48 ) , highlighted the necessity of preference-aware MCDM. However, these approaches fail to embed preferences as a rigorous basis for group decision-making. Preference measurement was formalised through Barzilai’s Preference Function Modelling (PFM) theory ( 50 ; 29 ) , demonstrating that preferences reside in a one-dimensional affine space and admissible transformations are strictly affine. Despite this, many aggregation practices remain mathematically invalid or decision-ambiguous. Recently, ( 1 ) demonstrated mathematically valid aggregation of preferences in MCDM using PFM. Classical systems engineering design optimisation texts ( 30 ; 31 ) and management science references ( 32 ) provide algorithmic multi-objective solutions (scalarisation, \varepsilon -constraint, Pareto heuristics), but they focus on numerical optima rather than preference‑based MCDM. Consequently, solutions often yield Pareto sets or single optima lacking contextual preference meaning. Contemporary literature ( 6 ; 13 ) highlights the need for a framework that properly integrates preference, acceptability, performance, and feasibility to identify a design–decision vector that maximises aggregated preference. In practice, MOO for multi-constrained problems uses LP/MIP, hybrid MOO-MCDM frameworks, and constraint programming (CP) ( 30 ; 32 ) , often realised via weighted additive rankings, \varepsilon -constraints, lexicographic ordering, Pareto sets, or hierarchical pruning. These methods explore performance spaces but do not deliver a unique, group decision-valid solution; they optimise measures, not human, goal-oriented preferences. Moreover, exploring the full feasible design space is inefficient since only the subset of designs aligned with stakeholder preferences is relevant for effective decision-making. Similarly, advances in parametric and computational design ( 49 ; 47 ) enable systematic exploration of large design spaces through structured parameters and constraint-based modelling. While effective for evaluating technical and performance criteria (structural performance, sustainability, constructability, etc.), these methods remain fundamentally performance-driven, do not internalise stakeholder desirability or acceptability, and cannot produce a unique, decision-valid best-fit solution. They generate candidate designs requiring external interpretation, highlighting the gap between exploration and actual decision-making. To substantiate these findings, the following sections overview contemporary MOO methods for group decision-making, highlight gaps in research and practice, and present a development statement, including four conditions for preference-based optimisation that enable pure group decision-making. Contemporary MOO for group decision-making overview Persistent separation of preferences and system performance remains a key limitation of classical optimisation. Preferences are often applied after technical feasibility is established, rather than embedded within a unified design–decision space, as in systems engineering and performance-driven design frameworks ( 46 ; 31 ) . This persists in Bayesian optimisation ( 15 ) , generative design systems ( 2 ) , and dynamic preference models ( 33 ; 43 ; 22 ; 14 ) , as well as in interactive evolutionary algorithms ( 51 ; 41 ) and Choquet-integral or constraint-reformulation approaches ( 36 ; 35 ) . When feasible performance (“what it can”) and acceptable stakeholder preferences (“what is wanted”) are not integrated, changes in feasibility, acceptability, or project state fail to propagate coherently through the decision-making process. Moreover, exploring the full feasible design space is inefficient, since only the subset of designs aligned with stakeholder preferences is truly relevant, leading to fragmented solution spaces with no convergent best-fit outcome. Stakeholders and actor dynamics have become central in post-2010 research, reflecting the socio-technical nature of design decisions and the importance of stakeholder involvement ( Yang2022PriorGoverned ; 27 ; 40 ) . Participative, negotiation-based, and group decision frameworks improve descriptive realism ( 24 ; 5 ; 34 ; 20 ; 9 ; 21 ; 25 ) , yet preferences are typically episodic inputs rather than dynamic variables integrated throughout optimisation. Optimisation and decision-making therefore remain conceptually and mathematically segregated ( 19 ; 2 ) . While contemporary works ( 27 ; 3 ) provide initial integration steps, a fully unified incorporation of engineering performance, feasibility, stakeholder preferences, and acceptability within a single associative preference-based design–decision space remains largely absent from mainstream MOO practice. Consequently, the a priori identification of a best-fit-for-common-purpose solution remains untapped, stakeholder needs insufficiently integrated, and the notion of a free, best-for-project choice vulnerable to becoming curated and illusory. The absence of a unified preference domain for heterogeneous objectives remains a core limitation in multi-objective optimisation (MOO). Methods either resort to hierarchical or semi-multi-objective formulations, or rely on monetisation as a workaround for commensurability, despite longstanding critiques from decision theory, cost–benefit-focused design, and socio-technical research ( 28 ; 24 ) . Even recent hybrid MOO–MCDM frameworks still layer a posteriori MCDM steps to reconcile fundamentally incomparable objectives ( 13 ; 2 ) . Although explicit preference modelling is increasingly recognised as

Read the complete text