GRB 241030A: a bright afterglow challenging forward shock emission

J.-G. Ducoin, C. Pellouin, V. Aivazyan, D. Akl, F. Alvarez, C. Andrade, C. Angulo, S. Antier, J.-L. Atteia, S. Basa, R.L. Becerra, Z. Benkhaldoun, E. Bissaldi, A. Breeveld, E. de. Bruin, E. Burns, N.R. Butler, M.W. Coughlin, F. Daigne, T. Dietrich, D. Dornic, C. Douzet, T. du Laz, P.-A. Duverne, H.B. Eggenstein, E. Elhosseiny, A. Esamdin, P.A. Evans, J. F. Agüí Fernández, M. Ferro, F. Fortin, M. Freeberg, L. García-García, R. Gill, N. Globus, N. Guessoum, G.M. Hamed, P. Hello, A. Holzmann Airasca, D.F. Hu, T. Hussenot-Desenonges, R. Inasaridze, A. Iskandar, S.Q. Jiang, C.C. Jin, A. Kaeouach, S. Karpov, N. J. Klingler, A. Klotz, N. Kochiashvili, H. Koehn, R. Kneip, T. Kvernadze, A. Le Calloch, W.H. Lee, A. Lekic, Y. F. Liang, C. Limonta, J. Liu, K. Ocelotl. C. López, D. López-Cámara, R.H. Mabrouk, F. Magnani, J. Mao, M. Mašek, E. Moreno Méndez, B.M. Mihov, M. Molham, K. Noysena, M. Odeh, N. Omodei, H. Peng, M. Pereyra, M. Pillas, R. Pillera, T. Pradier, Y. Rajabov, N.A. Rakotondrainibe, B. Schneider, M. Serrau, L. Slavcheva-Mihova, O. Sokoliuk, H. Sun, A. Takey, M. Tanasan, K. S. Tinyanont, D. Turpin, A. de Ugarte Postigo, B.T. Wang, L.T. Wang, X.F. Wang, Z.M. Wang, A.M. Watson, H.Z. Wu, Q.Y. Wu, J.J. Xu, Y.S. Yan, H.N. Yang, W. Yuan, H.S. Zhao · 2026

Read GRB 241030A: a bright afterglow challenging forward shock emission by J.-G. Ducoin, C. Pellouin, V. Aivazyan, D. Akl, F. Alvarez, C. Andrade, C. Angulo, S. Antier, J.-L. Atteia, S. Basa, R.L. Becerra, Z. Benkhaldoun, E. Bissaldi, A. Breeveld, E. de. Bruin, E. Burns, N.R. Butler, M.W. Coughlin, F. Daigne, T. Dietrich, D. Dornic, C. Douzet, T. du Laz, P.-A. Duverne, H.B. Eggenstein, E. Elhosseiny, A. Esamdin, P.A. Evans, J. F. Agüí Fernández, M. Ferro, F. Fortin, M. Freeberg, L. García-García, R. Gill, N. Globus, N. Guessoum, G.M. Hamed, P. Hello, A. Holzmann Airasca, D.F. Hu, T. Hussenot-Desenonges, R. Inasaridze, A. Iskandar, S.Q. Jiang, C.C. Jin, A. Kaeouach, S. Karpov, N. J. Klingler, A. Klotz, N. Kochiashvili, H. Koehn, R. Kneip, T. Kvernadze, A. Le Calloch, W.H. Lee, A. Lekic, Y. F. Liang, C. Limonta, J. Liu, K. Ocelotl. C. López, D. López-Cámara, R.H. Mabrouk, F. Magnani, J. Mao, M. Mašek, E. Moreno Méndez, B.M. Mihov, M. Molham, K. Noysena, M. Odeh, N. Omodei, H. Peng, M. Pereyra, M. Pillas, R. Pillera, T. Pradier, Y. Rajabov, N.A. Rakotondrainibe, B. Schneider, M. Serrau, L. Slavcheva-Mihova, O. Sokoliuk, H. Sun, A. Takey, M. Tanasan, K. S. Tinyanont, D. Turpin, A. de Ugarte Postigo, B.T. Wang, L.T. Wang, X.F. Wang, Z.M. Wang, A.M. Watson, H.Z. Wu, Q.Y. Wu, J.J. Xu, Y.S. Yan, H.N. Yang, W. Yuan, H.S. Zhao (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2603-18956.txt.

Introduction

Ducoin and co-authors report on the bright afterglow of a gamma-ray burst seen across many bands. The burst sits at a redshift of 1.411 and recalls a record event from 2022. They gather data from a minute to a week after the flash, all through one pipeline. Two models fit the X-ray to optical light with a structured jet in a steady medium. Both fits demand extreme values. The jets look very strong yet wasteful, with weak shares for electrons and fields.

Catalog record

CREATORJ.-G. Ducoin, C. Pellouin, V. Aivazyan, D. Akl, F. Alvarez, C. Andrade, C. Angulo, S. Antier, J.-L. Atteia, S. Basa, R.L. Becerra, Z. Benkhaldoun, E. Bissaldi, A. Breeveld, E. de. Bruin, E. Burns, N.R. Butler, M.W. Coughlin, F. Daigne, T. Dietrich, D. Dornic, C. Douzet, T. du Laz, P.-A. Duverne, H.B. Eggenstein, E. Elhosseiny, A. Esamdin, P.A. Evans, J. F. Agüí Fernández, M. Ferro, F. Fortin, M. Freeberg, L. García-García, R. Gill, N. Globus, N. Guessoum, G.M. Hamed, P. Hello, A. Holzmann Airasca, D.F. Hu, T. Hussenot-Desenonges, R. Inasaridze, A. Iskandar, S.Q. Jiang, C.C. Jin, A. Kaeouach, S. Karpov, N. J. Klingler, A. Klotz, N. Kochiashvili, H. Koehn, R. Kneip, T. Kvernadze, A. Le Calloch, W.H. Lee, A. Lekic, Y. F. Liang, C. Limonta, J. Liu, K. Ocelotl. C. López, D. López-Cámara, R.H. Mabrouk, F. Magnani, J. Mao, M. Mašek, E. Moreno Méndez, B.M. Mihov, M. Molham, K. Noysena, M. Odeh, N. Omodei, H. Peng, M. Pereyra, M. Pillas, R. Pillera, T. Pradier, Y. Rajabov, N.A. Rakotondrainibe, B. Schneider, M. Serrau, L. Slavcheva-Mihova, O. Sokoliuk, H. Sun, A. Takey, M. Tanasan, K. S. Tinyanont, D. Turpin, A. de Ugarte Postigo, B.T. Wang, L.T. Wang, X.F. Wang, Z.M. Wang, A.M. Watson, H.Z. Wu, Q.Y. Wu, J.J. Xu, Y.S. Yan, H.N. Yang, W. Yuan, H.S. Zhao
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE90231
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2603.18956

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

GRB 241030A: a bright afterglow challenging forward shock emission J.-G. Ducoin, C. Pellouin, V. Aivazyan, D. Akl, F. Alvarez, C. Andrade, C. Angulo, S. Antier, J.-L. Atteia, S. Basa, R.L. Becerra, Z. Benkhaldoun, E. Bissaldi, A. Breeveld, E. de. Bruin, E. Burns, N.R. Butler, M.W. Coughlin, F. Daigne, T. Dietrich, D. Dornic, C. Douzet, T. du Laz, P.-A. Duverne, H.B. Eggenstein, E. Elhosseiny, A. Esamdin, P.A. Evans, J. F. Agüí Fernández, M. Ferro, F. Fortin, M. Freeberg, L. García-García, R. Gill, N. Globus, N. Guessoum, G.M. Hamed, P. Hello, A. Holzmann Airasca, D.F. Hu, T. Hussenot-Desenonges, R. Inasaridze, A. Iskandar, S.Q. Jiang, C.C. Jin, A. Kaeouach, S. Karpov, N. J. Klingler, A. Klotz, N. Kochiashvili, H. Koehn, R. Kneip, T. Kvernadze, A. Le Calloch, W.H. Lee, A. Lekic, Y. F. Liang, C. Limonta, J. Liu, K. Ocelotl. C. López, D. López-Cámara, R.H. Mabrouk, F. Magnani, J. Mao, M. Mašek, E. Moreno Méndez, B.M. Mihov, M. Molham, K. Noysena, M. Odeh, N. Omodei, H. Peng, M. Pereyra, M. Pillas, R. Pillera, T. Pradier, Y. Rajabov, N.A. Rakotondrainibe, B. Schneider, M. Serrau, L. Slavcheva-Mihova, O. Sokoliuk, H. Sun, A. Takey, M. Tanasan, K. S. Tinyanont, D. Turpin, A. de Ugarte Postigo, B.T. Wang, L.T. Wang, X.F. Wang, Z.M. Wang, A.M. Watson, H.Z. Wu, Q.Y. Wu, J.J. Xu, Y.S. Yan, H.N. Yang, W. Yuan, H.S. Zhao Abstract Context. Gamma-Ray Burst GRB 241030A ( z = 1.411 z=1.411 ) exhibited a particularly bright afterglow (similar to the “BOAT”, GRB 221009A), detected across gamma-ray, X-ray, UV, and optical bands. The extensive, multi-wavelength observations of this remarkable event provide a valuable opportunity to advance our understanding of GRB afterglow physics. Aims. We aim to constrain the physical properties of the jet, its microphysics, and the characteristics of the circumburst environment in the context of forward-shock emission Methods. We compiled multi-wavelength observations spanning from a minute to a week after the prompt emission, processing the data through a unified photometry pipeline. Leveraging this comprehensive dataset, we analysed the observations both analytically and using Bayesian inference with two independent models. Our models assume that the afterglow emission arises from the strong forward shock of a laterally structured jet, with possible contributions from synchrotron self-Compton (SSC) scatterings. Results. We find that our models do reproduce the afterglow observations accurately, from the X-rays to the optical, favouring a jet propagating into a constant-density interstellar medium, with a viewing angle within the jet core. However, both analyses – with and without the inclusion of SSC scatterings – require parameter values that are extreme compared to expectations from standard theory. In particular, our results imply extremely energetic jets despite regular prompt energy, leading to a very inefficient prompt emission. Furthermore, the jets are particularly inefficient at accelerating particles, with low ϵ e \epsilon_{\mathrm{e}} and ϵ B \epsilon_{\mathrm{B}} , leading to significant SSC emission. Finally, our analyses indicate that the jets have large opening angles and propagate in high-density media. Conclusions. If the afterglow is indeed powered by radiation emitted behind a strong forward shock, our results place GRB 241030A within a sub-class of GRBs characterised by extreme kinetic energies, large jet opening angles, and very low prompt emission efficiencies, below 10 − 3 10^{-3} , with strong SSC radiation. These predictions are difficult to reconcile with typical expectations from other GRBs. We therefore suggest that the afterglow of GRB 241030A is not solely powered by forward shock emission, and we discuss other options such as a long-lasting reverse-shock contribution. 1 Introduction Gamma-ray bursts (GRBs) are among the most energetic and luminous events occurring in the Universe. They are typically divided into two broad categories based on the duration of their gamma-ray emission and the hardness of their spectra: long-duration bursts, which last more than two seconds and have ‘soft’ spectra, and short-duration bursts, which last less than two seconds and have ‘hard’ spectra. Long GRBs are generally associated with the core collapse of massive stars, events that are often referred to as ‘collapsars’, while short GRBs are due to the merger of a neutron star with another neutron star or a black hole (e.g. 16 ; 1 ). At least one (GRB 170817A) has been associated with gravitational waves ( 1 ; 34 ) . In both long and short GRBs, highly relativistic jets are launched from the vicinity of the newly formed compact object. As these jets propagate outward and interact with the surrounding environment, they generate shocks which allow for particle acceleration and give rise to the so-called afterglow emission, from radio to very high energies ( 89 ; 90 ; 88 ; 79 ) . GRB 241030A is a long GRB detected at t_{0} = 05:48:03 UT (used in the following as reference t_{0} ) on 2024 October 30 ( T_{90}=166 s in 50–300 keV) by the Fermi Gamma-ray Burst Monitor (GBM, 26 ). It was also detected by many other gamma-ray detectors. An observational campaign including several follow-up facilities led to the discovery of the X-ray and optical counterparts and is summarized in Appendix E . Spectroscopic observations provided a redshift measurement of \mathrm{z}=1.411 ( 111 ; 56 ) . Previous studies have shown a moderate correlation between the afterglow brightness and the isotropic equivalent energy of the prompt gamma-ray emission E_{\rm iso} ( 31 ; 67 ; 46 ; 45 ) . The case of GRB 241030A offers an opportunity to explore these connections further, to probe the structure and environment of the GRB jet and test the limits of models where only synchrotron emission is accounted for. In the standard model for GRB afterglows, the GRB jet interacts with the surrounding medium, forming a relativistic forward shock behind which the magnetic field is amplified and electrons are accelerated. This general model, first proposed in the late 1990s, successfully explains the broad-band, smoothly decaying light curves observed in many GRBs ( 64 ; 89 ; 78 ) . These accelerated electrons emit synchrotron radiation, whose spectral and temporal evolution depends on microphysical parameters (e.g. \epsilon_{e} , \epsilon_{B} , the fractions in the electrons and magnetic field of the total internal energy in the shocked material behind the shock, and p , the power-law index of the energy distribution of the electrons) and the density profile of the circumburst medium n(r) , where r is the radial distance to the source, of the surrounding medium. Two main types of circumburst media are typically considered: a uniform interstellar medium (ISM) and a stellar wind environment with a density decreasing as r^{-2} . The ISM model is appropriate for GRBs occurring in constant-density regions, potentially short GRBs associated to mergers which have migrated in their host galaxy away from star-forming regions, while the wind model is consistent with progenitors such as Wolf-Rayet stars that eject strong stellar winds prior to collapse ( 23 ; 17 ) . The evolution of the afterglow flux and spectral breaks (for example, the cooling frequency, \nu_{\mathrm{c}} ) differs significantly between these environments, and distinguishing between them provides insight into the nature of the progenitor and its surroundings. Furthermore, reverse shocks propagating into the ejecta can produce early-time optical flashes, providing further diagnostics of the outflow properties ( 90 ; 50 ) . Synchrotron photons

Read the complete text