Inference in Regression Discontinuity Designs with Clustered Data

Claudia Noack, Tomasz Olma, Christoph Rothe · 2026

Read Inference in Regression Discontinuity Designs with Clustered Data by Claudia Noack, Tomasz Olma, Christoph Rothe (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2603-18870.txt.

Introduction

Noack, Olma, and Rothe study statistical inference for regression discontinuity designs with clustered data. Clustered sampling is common in such designs but little studied in theory. A general model-based framework sets high-level conditions for the standard local linear estimator. Under those conditions, the estimator stays asymptotically normal. The conditions hold across many real designs, even with growing cluster sizes. Clustered standard errors in current use can be inconsistent or too wide, they show. A new nearest-neighbor variance estimator fixes the gap and is tested on real applications.

Catalog record

CREATORClaudia Noack, Tomasz Olma, Christoph Rothe
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE122602
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2603.18870

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Inference in Regression Discontinuity Designs with Clustered Data Claudia Noack, Tomasz Olma, Christoph Rothe Abstract Clustered sampling is prevalent in empirical regression discontinuity (RD) designs, but it has not received much attention in the theoretical literature. In this paper, we introduce a general model-based framework for such settings and derive high-level conditions under which the standard local linear RD estimator is asymptotically normal. We verify that our high-level assumptions hold across a wide range of empirical designs, including settings of growing cluster sizes. We further show that clustered standard errors that are currently used in practice can be either inconsistent or overly conservative in finite samples. To address these issues, we propose a novel nearest-neighbor-type variance estimator and illustrate its properties in a diverse set of empirical applications. 1. Introduction Regression discontinuity (RD) designs are widely applied in economics and other social sciences. In these settings, treatment is assigned whenever a unit’s realization of the running variable crosses a known cutoff; for instance, a candidate is elected only if their vote share exceeds 50%. Under continuity conditions on the conditional expectations of the potential outcomes, the average treatment effect at the cutoff is identified by the jump in the conditional expectation of the observed outcome given the running variable at the cutoff. This jump is typically estimated as the difference of the local linear estimates on either side of the cutoff. Most theoretical results on estimation and inference in RD designs are derived in settings where the researcher observes a sample of independent and identically distributed (i.i.d.) observations drawn from a large population ( 17 ; 20 ; 8 ; 4 , e.g.,) . In practice, however, applied researchers often regard the i.i.d. assumption as unrealistic and routinely report clustered standard errors. For example, we revisited the survey of recent RD studies published in the journals of the American Economic Association conducted by 26 and found that clustered standard errors were used in around 80% of the surveyed articles. Despite the prevalence of clustered sampling in applied RD studies, formal results for local linear RD estimators – and more generally local polynomial regression – under such dependence structures remain limited. In particular, the existing literature offers little guidance on the conditions under which these estimators are asymptotically normal across the range of clustering patterns encountered in practice, or on how to conduct valid inference in such settings. This paper makes two main contributions. First, we provide an asymptotic theory for the local linear RD estimator for clustered data with a large number of independent groups. From a statistical perspective, RD estimators are weighted averages of the outcome variable where the weights depend on the running variable, the kernel, and the bandwidth. When units are clustered, the interaction between local weighting and within-cluster dependence alters the asymptotic behavior of the local linear RD estimator. We derive high-level conditions under which the local linear RD estimator is asymptotically normally distributed. These conditions are formulated in terms of the weights assigned to units from different clusters and translate into restrictions on cluster sizes within the estimation window. To relate our high-level conditions to empirically relevant designs, we introduce four stylized asymptotic frameworks motivated by empirical RD applications. These frameworks capture how the asymptotic behavior of local linear RD estimators depends on (i) the effective number of units per cluster within the estimation window, (ii) the dependence structure of the running variable within clusters, and (iii) assumptions on the within-cluster covariance structure of the outcome. Within these frameworks, we find that distinct convergence rates and optimal bandwidth choices are qualitatively different from i.i.d. settings. Our results complement the analysis of 18 by considering nonparametric models. In contrast to their analysis, where the estimators are based on the full sample, the localization of the RD estimator leads to non-standard convergence rates. Second, we consider estimation of the conditional variance of the local linear RD estimator. We show that the conventional clustered regression residual-based standard error is consistent under the same cluster size conditions that ensure asymptotic normality of the RD estimator. However, in settings with independent data, the regression residual-based standard errors are known to exhibit less finite-sample bias than the so-called nearest-neighbors standard errors. A naive adaptation of the nearest-neighbors standard error for independent data to clustered settings is invalid, and to our knowledge, no valid nearest-neighbors-type standard error for clustered RD designs currently exists. As the second main contribution, we propose a novel clustered nearest-neighbors (CNN) standard error for RD estimators. Our proposed method chooses nearest neighbors taking into account the clustering structure and exploiting independence between clusters. We establish consistency of our proposed CNN standard error under our high-level assumptions on the cluster sizes. 1 1 1 Although our CNN standard error is developed for RD designs in this paper, the general idea behind it extends naturally to other conditional inference problems under misspecification, such as those studied by 2 . We complement our theoretical analysis with empirical applications that assess the finite-sample performance of the proposed standard error relative to existing alternatives. Related Literature Cluster-robust inference is routinely employed in empirical RD designs. Despite this fact, formal results remain limited, even for the standard nonparametric regression using local polynomial estimators. For RD designs with clustering, 5 show asymptotic normality of local polynomial RD estimators under the assumption that all clusters are of the same size and the realizations of the running variable are on the same side of the cutoff within each cluster. Clustered standard errors have been implemented in popular RD packages rdrobust and RDHonest without much theoretical foundation. Our paper contributes to this literature by providing a unified theory for all common RD variants with arbitrary clustering. 24 , 29 , and 6 study general local polynomial estimators under bounded cluster sizes. In these regimes, as the bandwidth converges to zero, the probability of having more than one unit within the estimation window converges to zero for any given cluster, and in consequence, the clustering does not affect the asymptotic distribution. 28 studies nonparametric density and local polynomial estimation under clustered sampling with heterogeneous and potentially unbounded cluster sizes. However, his framework imposes restrictions that rule out several empirically relevant RD settings. In particular, cluster sizes within the estimation window are required to remain uniformly bounded in expectation, the covariates are not allowed to be perfectly dependent within a cluster, and the within-cluster covariance structure of the residuals takes on a very specific form. Furthermore, his proposed variance estimator relies on parametric assumptions. By contrast, our framework accommodates weaker conditions on cluster sizes, allows for more general dependence structures in the running variable within clusters, and imposes milder assumptions on the covariance functions, while still delivering asymptotic normality. Moreover, our proposed nearest-neighbor standard error is fully nonparametric and does not rely on parametric modeling assumptions. In settings of regular parameters, there is a vast literature about cluster-robust inference. 23 ; 31 ; 3 provide the foundational large- G theory for cluster-robust covariances for bounded cluster sizes; see 10 ; 25 for reviews. 13 ; 18 ; 7 ; 19 extend the results to unequal, possibly large clusters. 1 discuss clustering adjustments from a design-based perspective. 11 point out that

Read the complete text