Comparing optical–microwave conversion and all‑microwave control schemes for a transmon qubit Preprint: APS/123-QED
Volodymyr Monarkha, Massimo Borrelli, Reza Hajitashakkori Kenari, Mohammad Kobba, Eugenio Cataldo, Beer de Zoeten, Mahnaz Zarrinfar, Kamal Pandey, Abhinand Pusuluri, Filippo D. Michelacci, Eliot Jouan, Bennett Sprague, Simon Groeblacher, Thierry C. van Thiel, Robert Stockill, Russell E. Lake · 2026
Read Comparing optical–microwave conversion and all‑microwave control schemes for a transmon qubit Preprint: APS/123-QED by Volodymyr Monarkha, Massimo Borrelli, Reza Hajitashakkori Kenari, Mohammad Kobba, Eugenio Cataldo, Beer de Zoeten, Mahnaz Zarrinfar, Kamal Pandey, Abhinand Pusuluri, Filippo D. Michelacci, Eliot Jouan, Bennett Sprague, Simon Groeblacher, Thierry C. van Thiel, Robert Stockill, Russell E. Lake (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2603-18780.txt.
Introduction
Monarkha and co-authors compare two ways to deliver control signals to a transmon qubit. One uses a standard attenuated coaxial microwave line. The other sends laser light over telecom fiber to a photodiode at the 1K stage of a cryostat. Each setup ran repeated coherence checks over 20-hour runs. Relaxation and coherence times showed no measurable harm from the optical route. Fluctuations matched the random drift seen with microwave control. The team says optical control could scale to large qubit systems.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Volodymyr Monarkha, Massimo Borrelli, Reza Hajitashakkori Kenari, Mohammad Kobba, Eugenio Cataldo, Beer de Zoeten, Mahnaz Zarrinfar, Kamal Pandey, Abhinand Pusuluri, Filippo D. Michelacci, Eliot Jouan, Bennett Sprague, Simon Groeblacher, Thierry C. van Thiel, Robert Stockill, Russell E. Lake |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 22576 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2603.18780
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Comparing optical–microwave conversion and all‑microwave control schemes for a transmon qubit Preprint: APS/123-QED Volodymyr Monarkha, Massimo Borrelli, Reza Hajitashakkori Kenari, Mohammad Kobba, Eugenio Cataldo, Beer de Zoeten, Mahnaz Zarrinfar, Kamal Pandey, Abhinand Pusuluri, Filippo D. Michelacci, Eliot Jouan, Bennett Sprague, Simon Groeblacher, Thierry C. van Thiel, Robert Stockill, Russell E. Lake Abstract We report a comparative study on transmon qubit control using (i) conventional attenuated coaxial microwave line and (ii) an optical control system using modulated laser light delivered over telecommunications optical fiber to a photodiode located at the 1K stage of a dilution cryostat. During each experiment, we performed repeated measurements of the energy relaxation and coherence times of a transmon qubit using one of the control signal delivery methods. Each measurement run spanned 20 hours of measurement time and from these datasets we observe no measurable effect on coherence of the qubit compared to random coherence fluctuations. Our results open up the possibility of large scale integration of the optical qubit control system. I Introduction The challenge of controlling and measuring sufficiently large qubit numbers in quantum computing has motivated various approaches, including highly dense coaxial arrays 15 , flexible printed circuits 13 , and signal generation using active electrical devices in the cryogenic environment 18 . Among these approaches, optical input-output through fiber coupling offers vanishingly small passive heat load from the interconnect, while potentially providing vast bandwidth for multiplexing in the optical domain 10 . Cryogenic fiber-optic access has enabled a variety of cryogenic optical experiments, including but not limited to cavity-enhanced quantum emitters 4 ; 11 , quantum optomechanics 2 and microwave-to-optics conversion 5 ; 6 ; 12 ; 7 . Recent efforts have focused on the realization of optical interfaces with superconducting qubits 12 ; 10 ; 3 ; 19 ; 1 ; 20 . One facet of this approach focuses on optically generating qubit control pulses using a combination of room temperature (RT) electro-optic modulation of laser light followed by demodulation at cryogenic temperatures using high-speed photodiodes 10 ; 21 ; 14 . One challenge of this approach is the thermal tradeoff arising from the conversion process between optical and microwave signals, which leads to heat generation 10 . A second challenge is the question of high-frequency radiation coming from the optically coupled drive line. Standard approaches to microwave hygiene are typically incompatible with optical access, since photons with energy greater than the pair-breaking energy in a superconducting film will induce energy loss in the device. However, previous work has demonstrated that it is possible to adequately block out of band noise even when microwave signals are generated at the same thermal stage as the qubit 10 . In this article, we describe a practical implementation of the input control and readout-in signals for a transmon qubit, employing optical fibers with a photodiode array inside a dilution refrigerator. We contrast these results to those obtained using all-microwave input, within the same cooldown. The article is organized as follows. First, we display the test setup with optics and a transmon qubit in a dilution refrigerator. Next, we report the time series and statistical analysis of the qubit lifetime and coherence for each configuration. We discuss the comparison between optical qubit control and all-microwave control in terms of coherence. From previous measurements that have been implemented with a blackbody noise reference, we can also estimate the effective temperature of the drive line originating from the photodiode. Finally, we comment on the scaling potential for this system from a thermal budget perspective, and assess technological readiness for standard single-qubit gate characterization based on metrics such as time stability, power efficiency, and noise. II Experimental setup Figure 1: Schematic diagram showing the measurement layout. The drive and readout signals are either delivered to the photodiode (a) over a single mode optical fiber or injected to the sample trough a coaxial attenuated input line connected to a coupled port of a directional coupler. A photographic image of the photodiode assembly is shown on the inset (b) Fig. 1 illustrates the measurements setup used to evaluate the differences in qubit lifetime and coherence using a modulated readout/control optical signal versus a traditional all-microwave drive scheme. The figure displays the experimental setup in a Bluefors LD400 dilution refrigerator with the qubit at a bath temperature of below 10\text{\,}\mathrm{mK} , and including optical input, microwave input, and readout output. The optical interconnect between the room temperature control electronics and a transmon qubit is realized using the QphoX Optical Control System (OCS). Microwave frequency qubit control pulses are modulated onto a 1510\text{\,}\mathrm{n}\mathrm{m} laser light using an on-board laser and electro-optic intensity modulator biased at quadrature. The modulated light is transmitted from one of six optical output ports of the room temperature hardware towards the Still plate of the dilution refrigerator over single-mode telecommunications optical fiber. Via cryo-compatible fiber-optic packaging, the light is guided to a high-speed photodiode array where it is demodulated to reproduce the microwave pulses and to drive the qubit. 10 dB and 20 dB attenuators, thermalized to 0.1\text{\,}\mathrm{K} and 0.01\text{\,}\mathrm{K} respectively, were installed to improve thermalization of the microwave channel, in addition to a low pass filter (LPF) and an infrared filter (IRF) installed at the base temperature stage 16 . Additionally, the more traditional microwave input line was connected to the qubit input using a directional coupler, enabling side-by-side comaprison of transmon dynamics for optical versus all-microwave drive. We note that when optical control was in use, both the readout and gate pulses were applied using the optical to microwave conversion. The microwave input serves only as an experimental comparison. Finally, a typical readout chain was constructed, without a parametric amplifier to avoid adding additional decoherence sources such as parametric amplifier back action noise. The transmon qubit ( QiB0 fabricated by ConScience, Sweden) has a common input port for both the readout stimulus and the qubit drive pulses using the so-called hanger readout resonator architecture. The device is a fixed-frequency grounded X-mon transmon that is dispersively coupled to a two-dimensional superconducting resonator, with qubit and resonator frequencies \omega_{\textrm{q}}/\hbar=4.5 \mathrm{GHz} and \omega_{\textrm{r}}/\hbar=6 \mathrm{GHz} , respectively. The qubit was designed with a Purcell decay time of 19.5 milliseconds. The energy participation ratio is approximately E_{\textrm{j}}/E_{\textrm{c}}\approx 47 . The magnetic flux fluctuation contribution for such a device is considered to be negligible, and charge noise contribution is expected to be primarily to energy relaxation rather than pure dephasing via AC Stark effect induced shifts of the qubit transition frequency due to fluctuations in the thermal photon number of the readout resonator. Figure 2: Histograms of energy relaxation time T 1 and Ramsey T {}^{*}_{2} accumulated over the same time period of 20 hours for control and readout input signals delivered over a microwave coaxial transmission line (a,b) or optical fiber (c,d), showing mean values, standard deviation and standard error in mean. Black line shows a fit of the normal distribution to the histogram. Time evolution of T 1 ,T {}^{*}_{2} for a long interleaved measurement sequence with optical drive. III Measurement Results The main results of this study are compiled in Fig. 2 where repeated measurements were performed on the qubit, using standard interleaved T_{1} and Ramsey T^{*}_{2} sequences 8 .