Comment on: “Association between quantum paradoxes based on weak values and a realistic interpretation of quantum measurements”

Juan Jose Seoane 1, Xabier Oianguren-Asua 2, Albert Solé 3, Xavier Oriols 1 · 2026

Read Comment on: “Association between quantum paradoxes based on weak values and a realistic interpretation of quantum measurements” by Juan Jose Seoane 1, Xabier Oianguren-Asua 2, Albert Solé 3, Xavier Oriols 1 (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2603-18713.txt.

Introduction

Seoane, Oianguren-Asua, Solé, and Oriols reply to a claim that realistic views of weak values must clash. Aredes and Saldanha had argued that such views lead to inconsistency in general. The commenters accept the clashes for the weak values studied there. They deny that the general argument is sound, calling it formally incorrect. Bohmian mechanics serves as the counterexample. Weak values postselected in position can act as system properties inside that frame, cut loose from the measuring device, in a consistent way.

Catalog record

CREATORJuan Jose Seoane 1, Xabier Oianguren-Asua 2, Albert Solé 3, Xavier Oriols 1
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE19085
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2603.18713

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Comment on: “Association between quantum paradoxes based on weak values and a realistic interpretation of quantum measurements” Juan Jose Seoane 1, Xabier Oianguren-Asua 2, Albert Solé 3, Xavier Oriols 1 Abstract In the paper [Phys. Rev. A 109, 022238 (2024)], Aredes and Saldanha analyze several paradoxes related to weak values and present a “General Argument” that aims to show that “realistic interpretations […] of weak values lead to inconsistencies.” Although we agree with the identified inconsistencies for the specific weak values analyzed there, in this comment, we demonstrate that the origin of these inconsistencies is not their “General Argument,” which is formally incorrect. We use Bohmian mechanics as a counterexample to confirm that their conclusions are not valid for all weak values and quantum theories. In particular, we show that weak values post-selected in position can, in fact, be interpreted within Bohmian mechanics as properties of quantum systems, detached from any measuring devices, in a consistent and meaningful way. I Introduction The paper in Ref. association2014pra initiates a discussion on whether weak values can be interpreted as referring to real properties within contextual quantum theories. The authors explore the meaning of weak values by analyzing several paradoxes. While we agree with Aredes and Saldanha that a realistic interpretation of weak values, as applied to the specific paradoxes they examine, leads to inconsistencies, we disagree with their explanation for the origin of these inconsistencies, as presented in the crucial section entitled “General Argument” of Ref. association2014pra . The authors define a “ realistic interpretation of a quantum measurement ” (RIQM) as follows: “ A measurement performed on a quantum system reveals the underlying ontological value of the measured quantity, that continues the same after the measurement ”. In addition, they define a “ realistic interpretation of weak values ” (RIWV) as follows: “ The weak value \langle O\rangle_{w} of an operator O reveals the objective reality of the physical quantity \tilde{O} associated to this operator ” footnote0b . From these definitions, through the above-mentioned “General Argument,” they conclude that: • Conclusion 1 : “ The attribution of a physical reality to the weak value \langle O\rangle_{w} is equivalent to adopting the cited realistic interpretation of quantum measurement ”. In other words, they consider that RIQM and RIWV are equivalent when dealing with weak values. Aredes and Saldanha consider that RIQM is “ highly controversial ” since it plainly contradicts the well-known quantum contextuality. Now, given this fact and the alleged equivalence between RIQM and RIWV, the authors finally conclude that: • Conclusion 2 : “ realistic interpretations […] of weak values lead to inconsistencies ”. In this comment, we present three results to show that both Conclusion 1 and Conclusion 2 are incorrect. II Fallacious argumentation Let us carefully reconstruct Aredes and Saldanha’s argument in Sect. II (entitled “General Argument”) of Ref. association2014pra to show that it is fallacious. The authors invite us to consider a weak measurement procedure of an observable O , in which the quantum system is pre-selected in a state |\psi_{i}\rangle and post-selected in a state |\psi_{f}\rangle . The obtained weak value is therefore: \langle O\rangle_{w}={\langle\psi_{f}|O|\psi_{i}\rangle}/{\langle\psi_{f}|\psi_{i}\rangle} . Next, the authors consider a situation in which the operator \hat{O} can be written as the sum of an operator \hat{P} from which the pre-selected state is an eigenvector with eigenvalue p , and an operator \hat{Q} from which the post-selected state is an eigenvector with eigenvalue q . That is, \hat{O} satisfies \hat{O}=\hat{P}+\hat{Q} with \hat{P}|\psi_{i}\rangle=p|\psi_{i}\rangle and \hat{Q}|\psi_{f}\rangle=q|\psi_{f}\rangle (see their Eq. (2) in Ref. association2014pra ). As a piece of terminology, the authors use the symbol \tilde{O} to denote the “ontological value” corresponding to the property O associated with the operator \hat{O} . These ontological values are interpreted as objective properties of the considered system and are mentioned both in RIQM and in RIWV. Now, we are prepared to present the crucial steps of Aredes and Saldanha’s argument. First, assuming RIWV, they claim that, in the scenario above, the objective physical quantities associated with the operators \hat{O} , \hat{P} and \hat{Q} are \tilde{O}=p+q , \tilde{P}=p and \tilde{Q}=q respectively. Second, assuming RIQM, and through a slightly more elaborate reasoning, the authors claim to reach the same conclusion, namely, that \tilde{O}=p+q , \tilde{P}=p and \tilde{Q}=q . So, up to this point, we can see that the authors’ claim is that both RIWV and RIQM entail the same consequence with respect to the ontological values \tilde{O} , \tilde{P} and \tilde{Q} in the considered scenario. Rather surprisingly, from this, they conclude: “ The attribution of a physical reality to the weak value value [what we named RIWV] is equivalent footnote11 to adopting the cited realistic interpretation of quantum measurements [what we referred to as RIQM] since both assumptions lead to the same objective value for the physical quantity \tilde{O}:\tilde{O}=p+q […] Since the cited realistic interpretation of quantum measurements [RIQM] is highly controversial, a reasonable way to avoid all the cited quantum paradoxes is to deny this realistic interpretation of quantum measurements [RIQM] , also denying the realistic view of the weak values [RIWV].” Now, it should be clear that this reasoning is fallacious. Two assumptions can share some consequences, yet this does not entail that they are logically equivalent. Given that Aredes and Saldanha reach Conclusion 1 in a fallacious manner, this conclusion is unfounded. In the next session we demonstrate that, moreover, it is false. III Conclusion 1 is incorrect Bohmian mechanics is a theory that accounts for all non-relativistic quantum phenomena. Its ontology consists of particles with well-defined positions regardless of whether or not they are being observed bohm1952a ; bohm1952b ; chapter1 ; chapter2 . The dynamics involve a (deterministic) equation of motion for the particles’ positions (the so-called ”guiding equation” chapter1 ) which provides the velocity of each particle as a functional of the wave function. Additionally, the law of motion for the wave function itself is the (deterministic) Schrödinger equation. III.1 Bohmian mechanics, a contextual theory When Aredes and Saldanha mention that RIQM is “highly controversial,” they explicitly refer to quantum contextuality and the Kochen-Specker theorem mermin1993 to support this claim. One standard way to avoid the refutatory charge of this theorem is to accept that any hidden-variable theory aiming to be empirically adequate must be contextual . This amounts to denying that, if a quantum system possesses a property (the ontological value of an observable), it does so independently of any measurement context. It is worth noticing that Bohmian mechanics is contextual in this sense and that, as a consequence, is not refuted by the Kochen-Specker theorem and other similar results hardy1996 . RIQM affirms (or entails) what is known in the literature as the “ Faithful Measurement Principle ”, which asserts that a measurement of an observable faithfully reveals the value which that observable had immediately prior to the measurement interaction held2022 . Quantum mechanics violates both the “ Faithful Measurement Principle ” and RIQM. In order to show this, consider a system in the state \frac{1}{\sqrt{2}}\left(|\psi_{a}\rangle+|\psi_{b}\rangle\right) , where \hat{O}|\psi_{a}\rangle=a|\psi_{a}\rangle and \hat{O}|\psi_{b}\rangle=b|\psi_{b}\rangle . Now, suppose one makes a (strong) measurement of observable O and obtains the eigenvalue a as the outcome. According to orthodox quantum mechanics and the eigenvalue-eigenstate link, this measurement does not faithfully reveal the

Read the complete text