Comments on the Emergence of 4D Topological Amplitudes in M-Theory

Panagiotis Leivadaros · 2026

Read Comments on the Emergence of 4D Topological Amplitudes in M-Theory by Panagiotis Leivadaros (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2603-18681.txt.

Introduction

Artime and co-authors revisit how topological terms emerge in M-theory compactifications. The Emergence Proposal says all low-energy action terms come from quantum effects. In four-dimensional setups with N=2 supersymmetry, kinetic terms sit inside topological string amplitudes. Recent work rebuilt the cubic term of the prepotential by summing over light state towers. Two gaps remained. The authors show the sum can be regularized in either moduli space. They also extend the method to linear terms in the one-loop prepotential F1.

Catalog record

CREATORPanagiotis Leivadaros
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE44395
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2603.18681

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Comments on the Emergence of 4D Topological Amplitudes in M-Theory Panagiotis Leivadaros Abstract The M-theoretic Emergence Proposal claims that all of the terms in the low-energy action arise from quantum effects. After reviewing the current status of this proposal, we focus on four-dimensional compactifications with N = 2 N=2 supersymmetry, where kinetic terms are encoded in topological string amplitudes, such as the prepotential ℱ 0 \mathcal{F}_{0} . Evidence for the emergence of such terms was provided recently, where in particular it was shown that the classical cubic term in ℱ 0 {\cal F}_{0} can be obtained by integrating out the light towers of states in the M-theory limit, using a novel regularization of the infinite sum over Gopakumar/Vafa invariants. We address two issues that were left open. First, we show that the regularization can be equivalently performed in complex structure moduli space and in Kähler moduli space. Second, we extend the proposed regularization to the linear terms in the one-loop prepotential ℱ 1 \mathcal{F}_{1} . [a]Ralph Blumenhagen 1 Introduction One of the central aspects of the swampland program (see [ 1 , 2 , 3 ] for reviews) is the realization that string theory, or more generally Quantum Gravity (QG), admits infinite distance limits in its moduli space where infinite towers of states become exponentially light. This is captured by the swampland distance conjecture [ 4 ] , which has been analyzed and refined during recent years. One essential refinement is the emergent string conjecture [ 5 ] , which asserts that the lightest of such towers can only be of two types. These are either Kaluza-Klein (KK) modes of a decompactifying direction or the excitation modes of a weakly coupled, critical string, both meant in an appropriate duality frame. In addition to the lightest towers appearing at infinite-distance limits, it was found that there exists a hierarchical pattern of all towers, namely that one can distinguish between light and heavy towers [ 6 , 7 ] , where the former ones are those with a typical mass scale not larger than the QG cut-off, which is taken to be the species scale [ 8 , 9 ] . Similar to the structure of the weakly coupled fundamental string, the light towers can be considered the fundamental quantum degrees of freedom and the heavy ones as classical non-perturbative contributions. From this perspective, standard perturbative string theory is just the perturbative QG theory that arises in the small string coupling regime, i.e. an infinite distance limit for the dilaton. The perturbative states are the vibration modes of the string and upon compactification also its KK and winding modes. The non-perturbative states are the NS5 -brane together with the various D -branes of the superstring theories, all with tensions larger than the species scale. In an attempt to find a microscopic explanation to the swampland distance conjecture the so-called Emergence Proposal [ 10 , 11 , 12 ] was put forward (for subsequent work see e.g. [ 13 , 14 , 15 ] ), which suggests that the kinetic terms in the low-energy effective action of (all) QG theories are emerging quantum mechanically from integrating out states below a certain UV scale. While initially less understood than some other swampland conjectures, it was subsequently realized that there exists a special limit in the QG moduli space where the conjecture seems to be realized in an even stronger sense [ 6 , 7 , 16 ] (for a complementary approach see [ 17 , 18 , 19 , 20 ] ). First, consider a compactification of type IIA string theory to d dimensions on an internal space with radii R_{i} . The M-theory limit is obtained by scaling the type IIA string coupling and the radii to infinity in such a way that, in M-theory units, one has \begin{split}R_{11}\to\lambda R_{11}\,,\qquad M_{*}\to\lambda^{\frac{1}{d-1}}M_{*}\,,\qquad M_{*}R_{i}\to 1\,,\end{split} (1) where R_{11} denotes the radius of the M-theory circle and M_{*} the eleven-dimensional Planck scale. In this limit one takes the strong coupling regime of type IIA string theory, in which a new eleventh dimension opens up. At the same time, the size of the internal space in units of the eleven-dimensional Planck scale, as well as the d -dimensional Planck scale, are kept finite. This limit is called the M-theory limit [ 7 ] and is a decompactification to d+1 dimensions where the species scale is the higher dimensional Planck scale. Second, it was proposed that in this limit the full low-energy effective action arises from integrating out the light towers of states, namely those whose typical mass scales do not exceed the species scale. In other words, all interactions are generated through quantum effects, without any classical contribution (see [ 21 ] for a review). The central challenge in providing evidence for this proposal is that we do not understand the full quantization of M-theory yet. Guided by the BFSS matrix model [ 22 ] (see [ 23 ] for a review), one realizes that this form of the Emergence Proposal is consistent with it. There, the fundamental degrees of freedom are matrices and a large scale commuting space-time can arise by solving the classical equations of motion, in particular by choosing diagonal matrices. However, interactions like gravity are known to be obtained from a quantum effect, namely from integrating out the fluctuations of matrices around the classical background. However, for more involved compact backgrounds, a similar matrix model computation is not feasible with current techniques. Nonetheless, these difficulties can be bypassed by considering certain couplings in the effective action that are protected by supersymmetry and only receive contributions from 1/2 -BPS states. The latter are well understood and admit the usual geometric interpretation we are used to from string theory. Indeed, all current evidence for the M-theoretic Emergence Proposal are based on the evaluation of such 1/2 -BPS saturated couplings. Explicit checks were carried out by deriving these couplings from a one-loop Schwinger integral, where only the light, perturbative towers of particle-like states with masses below the species scale, namely the 11D Planck scale, are integrated out. Let us briefly recall which consistency checks have been performed: • \mathbf{R^{4}} -term in supergravity theories with 32 supercharges: Arising from toroidal compactifications of type IIA/M-theory, the analysis builds on the pioneering work of Green-Gutperle-Vanhove [ 24 ] , in which the couplings in ten and nine dimensions were obtained by integrating out the KK spectrum along the eleventh direction, i.e. bound states of D0 -branes. In [ 25 ] tools were developed to regularize the appearing Schwinger integrals and shown to be consistent with string theory results. This was then applied to the evaluation of the R^{4} Schwinger integral, where the rest of the light towers of states were integrated out. For dimensions d\geq 7 integrating out the full set of light towers leads to a perfect match with the exact amplitude. This analysis will be further refined in [ 26 ] , where the various infinite distance limits as classified by the taxonomy rules [ 27 ] will be analyzed in a systematic manner. Importantly, only the M-theory limit from eq.( 1 ) remains as the limit where the full R^{4} -term arises from integrating out the

Read the complete text