Measuring ESG Risk in Supply Networks
Rudy Arthur, Guillherme Machado · 2026
Read Measuring ESG Risk in Supply Networks by Rudy Arthur, Guillherme Machado (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2603-18543.txt.
Introduction
Arthur and Machado build a way to track ESG risk as it spreads through supply networks. Ratings can hide poor practice when a firm trades with badly rated partners. Their framework extends PageRank and alpha centrality, with tuning that resists greenwashing. The scores update a firm's own rating and flag influential neighbours. They also show how exposed a firm is to bad conduct upstream. Tests run on synthetic networks, a real firm network, and world trade data.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Rudy Arthur, Guillherme Machado |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 42228 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2603.18543
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Measuring ESG Risk in Supply Networks Rudy Arthur, Guillherme Machado Abstract Environmental, Social and Governance (ESG) rating is a way for investors to prioritise investments in companies with good corporate behaviour. However, ESG ratings are vulnerable to greenwashing in a number of ways. In this paper we study the effect that trade with badly rated companies has on a target company’s own rating. To do this we introduce a measurement framework, generalising PageRank and Alpha Centrality, which allows tuning of aggregation and path counting approaches to resist greenwashing and reflect the rater’s opinions and preferences for harm accumulation. These metrics allow updating of the target’s ESG rating, identification of influential neighbours and assessment of vulnerability of the target to bad behaviour in their supply network. We study these metrics on synthetic ESG interaction networks as well as a real inter-company network and the international trade network. 1 Introduction Rising to prominence in 2004 9 , ESG, E nvironmental, S ocial and G overnance, is an investing principle building on prior ideas of corporate social responsibility (CSR) 28 . ESG refers to both the way that investors evaluate corporate behaviour according to ethical principles, as well as an investing strategy used to assess future financial performance 23 . Total assets under management in so-called responsible investment funds, which prioritise ESG rating over other metrics, are in the tens of trillions according to industry reports 17 , although precise numbers vary. ESG relies on accurate analysis of corporate behaviour. Ratings are provided by a number of companies and funds, with the most prominent in the academic literature being the Thomson Reuters ASSET4 database 11 and the MSCI KLD 400 Social Index 14 due to their accessibility, although many other ratings and ESG funds exist. Since ratings are sold as products to investors, they tend not to be freely available and their methodology not fully transparent, however the broad idea is clear and described in various industry documents e.g. 26 . Calculating a company’s ESG rating involves the analysis of the company’s Environmental, Social and Governance issues, which can be as diverse as water use, data privacy or board diversity with a weighted combination determining the final rating. With large amounts of investment capital at stake, companies have responded by trying to improve their ESG ratings, which is the intention of the architects of ESG. However, such attempts are not always honest and corporate greenwashing, misleading information about ESG performance ( 12 ) , is an issue. Greenwashing can involve selective disclosure of information 24 or using past ethical behaviour to cover for current unethical behaviour 27 . 21 find that good ESG ratings are only moderately correlated with good environmental performance and positively correlated with the number of greenwashing cases reported for that company. Figure 1: (a) Shows an ostensibly good company a , with a good ESG rating, being supplied by and supplying badly rated companies. (b) Shows a company with a bad ESG rating, b effectively trading with a through an intermediary w . Corporate networks create opportunities, deliberate or not, for greenwashing. Figure 1 (a) shows a simple example: company a has good ESG metrics, but is supplied by a badly rated company (e.g. a highly polluting mine) and sells to badly rated customers (e.g. aggressive militaries). It is reasonable to suppose ethical investors would be concerned by such associations. Failing to incorporate them into the ESG rating should be considered a form of greenwashing. Figure 1 (b) shows a slightly more subtle example, where company b with low ESG rating, can form a ‘clean’ subsidary or wholesaler, w , which launders the reputation of company b allowing other companies to invest and trade with the subsidiary without the reputational damage that might come from trading with b directly. Many similar scenarios can be envisaged and need not be deliberate to be a form of greenwashing. Rating agencies do incorporate supply chain effects 5 , however, as with all aspects of ESG rating, the methods are opaque. In the academic literature some studies exist on the interaction of corporate networks with ESG ratings. 32 ; 34 suggest peer effects operate, where network attention enhances the ESG performance of companies in a network. 2 uses this operationally, using company networks to predict ESG scores. Most of this literature uses regression based approaches i.e. modelling ESG score as a function of various factors like network attention. In this paper we use tools from network science which give us a more detailed picture of how ESG scores are affected by the structure of the corporate network. This is, to our knowledge, a novel approach with the closest work we can locate from Ioannidis et. al. 20 who use network science to study the network produced from correlations between different ESG components, rather than the company network itself. It is important to note that unlike credit rating, ESG ratings from different issuing agencies are only moderately correlated 7 ; 5 . This reflects the opinions and intentions of different raters on how to quantify or even define the ESG concept 13 ; 15 . This ambiguity is somewhat inevitable. An ESG rating attempts to combine disparate aspects of corporate behaviour, from polluting a river to worker harassment, into a single score and this involves many value judgements which have no unambiguous resolution. Our view in this paper is that the ambiguity in ESG scores is a design constraint. Different raters want to evaluate companies in different ways with different priorities. A useful ‘rating tool’ should allow for diverse opinions on what matters for ESG. In this paper we develop metrics that allow us to update a company’s ESG rating based on their network. To do so we present a deconstruction and generalisation of some well known tools from network science to build a flexible framework for network ESG analysis. This allows an investor or rater to specify how different scenarios should be scored. We provide guidance on how robust or vulnerable different approaches are to greenwashing or obfuscation patterns. Ultimately the aim is that if network effects are incorporated into ESG ratings, then the ratings will become strongly interdependent. This would lead to community enforcement of good practices, with badly rated suppliers or customers excluded out of self-interest, enhancing the peer effects described in previous research 32 ; 34 , realising the aims of ESG proponents. In Section 2 we introduce our metrics, showing how they come from generalising well known metrics like PageRank to cover other forms of score aggregation and path counting. In Section 3 we analyse some networks designed to show the metrics in simplified settings to build intuition. In Section 4 we cover two case studies on real networks, a company network and the international trade network. We conclude in Section 5 . 2 Network ESG Metrics Figure 2: An example supply network. We will mostly focus on the target company a . Colours represent ESG ratings, the more red, the worse the rating. Different rating agencies use different scales for ESG scores. For example, MSCI uses grades CCC to AAA and Sustainalytics uses values between 0 and 100 15 . We will find it convenient to transform the