Moments in the CFT Landscape
Li-Yuan Chiang, David Poland, Gordon Rogelberg · 2026
Read Moments in the CFT Landscape by Li-Yuan Chiang, David Poland, Gordon Rogelberg (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2603-18140.txt.
Introduction
Chiang, Poland, and Rogelberg develop a moment-based numerical bootstrap for conformal field theories. Moments are weighted averages over conformal data, giving a coarse global probe of the spectrum. Standard semidefinite tools then yield rigorous bounds on the operator distribution. In the heavy regime, bounds converge fast toward analytic power laws. At finite dimensions, low moments recover Ising kinks and reveal two new kink families tied to operator decoupling.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Li-Yuan Chiang, David Poland, Gordon Rogelberg |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 109626 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2603.18140
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Moments in the CFT Landscape Li-Yuan Chiang, David Poland, Gordon Rogelberg Abstract We develop a novel numerical bootstrap for unitary, crossing-symmetric conformal field theories, focusing on moment observables defined as weighted averages over conformal data. Providing a global and coarse-grained probe of the operator spectrum, this framework yields numerically rigorous bounds on the operator distribution using standard semidefinite programming techniques. In the heavy correlator regime, these bounds remain robust and converge rapidly towards analytically-derived power laws. At finite external dimensions, low-lying moments capture corrections to analytic heavy limit results, while reproducing familiar bootstrap solutions such as Ising-model kinks on the boundary of moment space. Most importantly, the moment bootstrap reveals new features in previously unexplored regions of the bootstrap landscape. The lower bounds on moment variables exhibit two continuous families of kinks persisting across 2 < d < 6 2<d<6 , reflecting nontrivial spectral reorganizations connected to underlying operator decoupling phenomena. These results demonstrate that moment variables uncover bootstrap solutions and collective structures that are difficult to access within traditional numerical approaches. 1 Introduction The conformal bootstrap has emerged as one of the most powerful nonperturbative methods for studying conformal field theories (CFT) in general spacetime dimensions. Lying at the core of these techniques are the crossing equations: an infinite family of sum rules that encode the consistency of the operator product expansion (OPE) with conformal symmetry, unitarity, and crossing symmetry. Implemented as a semidefinite program (SDP), numerically optimized functionals acting on these constraints can be used to make remarkably precise predictions about the low-lying spectra of local operators in a wide range of CFTs such as the 3d Ising CFT El-Showk:2012cjh ; El-Showk2014-ce ; Simmons-Duffin:2016wlq ; Kos:2016ysd ; Chang:2024whx , O(N) vector models Kos:2013tga ; Chester:2019ifh ; Liu:2020tpf ; Chester:2020iyt , Gross-Neveu-Yukawa CFTs Erramilli2022-yi ; Mitchell:2024hix and their supersymmetric extensions Bobev:2015jxa ; Bobev:2015vsa ; Chester:2015lej ; Atanasov:2018kqw ; Rong:2019qer ; Atanasov:2022bpi , 3d conformal gauge theories such as quantum electrodynamics with fermionic and scalar matter Chester2016-tp ; Chester:2017vdh ; Li:2020bnb ; Li:2021emd ; He:2021sto ; Albayrak2021-td ; He:2021xvg ; Chester:2023njo ; Chester:2025uxb , and more. The majority of developments in the bootstrap have been aimed towards the goal of isolating known models in theory space. By using knowledge of low-lying spectra, fusion algebras of local operators, and gaps inspired by equations of motion from Lagrangian descriptions as inputs to the bootstrap equations, we can isolate islands in parameter space that reproduce CFT data, which we can then check against known perturbative results, Monte Carlo, and fuzzy sphere computations. These investigations have since become synonymous with the bootstrap and are widely regarded as the benchmark of its success. In this paper, we introduce the numerical moment bootstrap , a framework in which crossing symmetry and unitarity are used to place numerically rigorous bounds on moments of the OPE data, rather than on individual low-lying operator properties. This provides an alternative way to nonperturbatively map out theory space. We identify moments as natural bootstrap observables that capture global properties of the spectral data appearing in conformal correlators and study these observables with semidefinite programming techniques. This allows us to identify new geometrically privileged points, or kinks , in the allowed space of scalar four-point correlators with identical external dimensions. We then characterize these kink structures by identifying unique properties and operator decoupling phenomena within their low-lying spectra. Additionally, we use this new space of bootstrap observables to re-characterize known theories, such as the 3d Ising model. We hope that these results will serve as a starting point for precision investigations of these new bootstrap solutions. Related observations have appeared in a number of contexts. In Paulos:2021jxx the authors studied bounds on the value of the 4-point function in the crossing-symmetric configuration, observing kinks related to the Ising model. In Ghosh:2023onl , the authors used a basis of analytic functionals dual to extremal solutions for the generalized free field to compute gap-maximizing functionals of a correlator of identical scalar operators in a 2d CFT. In addition to yielding the known kinks associated with \langle\sigma\sigma\sigma\sigma\rangle and \langle\epsilon\epsilon\epsilon\epsilon\rangle in the Ising model, the study also revealed two new kinks that have yet to be fully understood. Similarly, in Bobev:2015jxa , the authors uncovered three families of kinks in the space of superconformal field theories (SCFT) in dimensions two through four. One of these kinks was associated with a known family of theories interpolating between the d=2,\;\mathcal{N}=(2,2) minimal model and the theory of a free chiral multiplet in d=4 . The other two kinks are more mysterious, with one coinciding with a kinematic threshold at which certain operators can appear and the other interpolating to a kink in the space of 4d \mathcal{N}=1 SCFTs, which had been previously studied in Poland:2011ey ; Poland:2015mta ; Li:2017ddj . Similar unexplained kink structures have also been observed in the 4-fermion bootstrap Iliesiu:2015qra ; Iliesiu:2017nrv ; Erramilli:2020rlr . These investigations not only reveal the uncanny ability of the bootstrap program to isolate known solutions, but also pick out new privileged solutions to crossing that have previously unknown descriptions. The aforementioned studies make use of functionals that extremize a low-energy property of the OPE spectrum, such as the scaling dimension of the lowest lying non-identity operator (gap-maximization) or the OPE coefficient of a single known operator in the theory (OPE-maximization). These low-lying features of the CFT spectrum can be used to accurately approximate correlation functions with similarly small external scaling dimensions. In Kraus:2018pax , the authors showed that the ability to do such an approximation comes from the fact that heavy states with \Delta>2\Delta_{\phi} are suppressed in the OPE by factors of size e^{-(\Delta-2\Delta_{\phi})} , where \Delta_{\phi} is the external scaling dimension. This fact makes gap-maximizing functionals a useful technique for understanding the space of correlators that are dominated by light states close to the gap. This leads one to ask how one may understand correlators with large external dimension, where the operators dominating the OPE are no longer close to the gap. The functionals that we analyze in this work are aimed at addressing this problem: they capture global properties of the OPE rather than characterizing a single low-lying operator. These functionals, which we refer to as OPE moments, are defined as averages of powers of \Delta and \ell over the OPE sum, weighted by the squared OPE coefficient times a conformal block evaluated at the self-dual point z=\bar{z}=1/2 . In Poland:2024hvb , the authors proved that OPE moments in powers of \Delta enjoy asymptotic two-sided bounds in the limit of large external dimension and are saturated by particular limits of correlators of identical scalars in a generalized free theory. In this work, we develop and implement the numerical moment bootstrap, using semidefinite programming techniques and the solver SDPB Simmons-Duffin:2015qma ; Landry:2019qug to rigorously extend these moment bounds away from the asymptotic regime to finite and small values of the external scaling dimension. This approach not only reproduces the expected large- \Delta_{\phi} behavior but also resolves the geometry of moment space at finite \Delta_{\phi} , uncovering new families of kinks in the space of CFT correlators across spatial dimensions. Bounding moments using SDP methods is not new, and has a long history in optimization, probability, and finance, see e.g.