When do real observers resolve de Sitter’s imaginary problem?

Ahmed Farag Ali · 2026

Read When do real observers resolve de Sitter’s imaginary problem? by Ahmed Farag Ali (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2603-18068.txt.

Introduction

Ali derives when real observers can resolve the imaginary phase problem of de Sitter space. The Euclidean path integral phase blocks a plain state-counting read of Gibbons-Hawking entropy. He splits observers into gravitational observers and topological spectators. At quadratic order, any sector with a metric-free infrared action factors out, so the phase stays. Only observers whose fluctuations share the conformal factor's negative modes can remove it, he shows.

Catalog record

CREATORAhmed Farag Ali
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE19716
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2603.18068

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

When do real observers resolve de Sitter’s imaginary problem? Ahmed Farag Ali Abstract The universal phase i D + 2 {\color[rgb]{0,0,0}\mathrm{i}}^{D+2} of the Euclidean de Sitter path integral obstructs a straightforward state-counting interpretation of the Gibbons–Hawking entropy. Building on Maldacena’s proposal that specific black-hole observers can reorganize this phase, we derive a general constraint on when such “real observers” can succeed. By distinguishing gravitational observers from topological spectators , we show at quadratic semiclassical order that any sector whose infrared effective action is metric independent at the de Sitter saddle factorizes in the path integral, Z tot = Z grav ( obs ) ​ Z top Z_{\text{tot}}=Z_{\text{grav}}^{(\text{obs})}Z_{\text{top}} , so the imaginary phase persists regardless of the sector’s information-processing capabilities. Using confining SU ⁡ ( 3 ) \mathrm{SU}(3) gauge theory and topological orders as examples, we demonstrate that an information-bearing clock is necessary but insufficient: only observers whose fluctuations share the negative modes of the conformal factor belong to the special class that can remove the de Sitter phase. Motivation.— The Euclidean path integral on the round de Sitter sphere S^{D} , Z_{\text{grav}}(S^{D})=\int{\color[rgb]{0,0,0}\mathrm{D}}g\,{\color[rgb]{0,0,0}\mathrm{e}}^{-I_{\text{EH}}[g]}, (1) has long been known to carry subtle pathologies. While Gibbons and Hawking showed that the saddle reproduces the thermodynamic entropy of the cosmological horizon, 14 Gibbons, Hawking and Perry noted the indefinite sign of the gravitational action, 13 and Polchinski explicitly identified D+2 negative modes in the conformal sector which generate a universal phase: 22 Z_{\text{grav}}(S^{D})\;\sim\;\exp\!\left(\frac{A_{c}}{4G_{N}}\right)\,{\color[rgb]{0,0,0}\mathrm{i}}^{D+2}\,\big|\det\nolimits^{\prime}(\Delta_{\text{grav}})\big|^{-1/2}. (2) Here A_{c} is the area of the cosmological horizon. The sign is such that I_{\text{EH}}[g_{\text{dS}}]=-A_{c}/(4G_{N}) , so that {\color[rgb]{0,0,0}\mathrm{e}}^{-I_{\text{EH}}[g_{\text{dS}}]} has the usual entropy-counting form. To resolve the interpretational difficulties posed by the phase {\color[rgb]{0,0,0}\mathrm{i}}^{D+2} , Maldacena recently proposed a concrete remedy: by coupling gravity to a charged near-extremal black hole equipped with a physical clock, the additional negative modes of the observer reorganize the path integral so that the static-patch density of states becomes real. 20 This proposal has catalyzed a wave of precise investigations into the nature of observers and phases in de Sitter gravity. Regarding the phase structure, Ivo, Maldacena and Sun traced the Euclidean phase to specific physical instabilities of the conformal factor, 17 while Shi and Turiaci generalized this analysis to arbitrary Einstein manifolds. 24 Chen, Stanford, Tang and Yang emphasized a sharp tension, showing that the Euclidean path integral carries a robust complex phase that resists simple cancellation, though they argue that a positive density of states is nevertheless recoverable, 10 building on earlier classifications of sphere path integrals by Law 19 and explicit entropy computations by Anninos et al. 6 Simultaneously, the definition of the observer itself has been formalized algebraically. Harlow, Usatyuk and Zhao identified observers with subalgebras and cyclic states in a closed-universe Hilbert space; 15 Chen further developed this by modeling observers as “sources” for gravitational Hilbert spaces; 9 and Chen and Xu constructed an explicit algebra for covariant observers. 8 In the holographic context, Akers et al. analyzed how such observers map to dual descriptions, 2 while Chandrasekaran, Longo, Penington and Witten provided an algebra of observables adapted to the horizon, distinguishing static observers from the global geometry. 7 Related flow-geometry developments include the centaur-algebra of observables for asymptotically AdS spacetimes with infalling-observer protocols, and a two-dimensional flow-geometry microstate construction reproducing the Gibbons–Hawking entropy. 1 ; 12 . From a constraints perspective, Horowitz, Marolf and Santos proved that the gravitational constraints alone are insufficient to fix the quantum theory, necessitating explicit observer data. 16 Finally, microscopic proposals in which \mathrm{SU}(3) confinement fixes the vacuum energy and nature’s constants offer a concrete realization of gravitational clocks tied to the fundamental vacuum architecture. 3 ; 5 . For an \mathrm{SU}(3) clock realization in de Sitter, see Ref. 4 . These developments suggest a natural conceptual picture: once an observer with a clock is included, the de Sitter phase might be brought under control. The main purpose of this Letter is to make this picture precise by identifying which ingredients—gravitational backreaction, informational clocks, or topological structure—are actually responsible for changing the phase, and to formulate this as a criterion on which observers qualify as genuinely gravitational. Three notions.— We distinguish three logically independent notions that frequently appear under the single label “observer”. Worldlines. Any localized subsystem defines a worldline (or worldvolume) in spacetime: examples range from cosmic strings and monopoles to anyons in a quantum Hall fluid or vortices in a superconductor. 25 ; 26 ; 27 A worldline is a geometric object; by itself it does not yet encode any temporal ordering of internal states. Informational clocks. In relational and informational approaches to time, a “clock” is a subsystem whose internal state provides an intrinsic ordering of distinguishable events. 21 ; 11 Concretely, we say a subsystem along a worldline carries an informational clock if it has an internal Hilbert space \mathcal{H}_{\text{clock}} and undergoes a sequence of operations U_{n}:\mathcal{H}_{\text{clock}}\to\mathcal{H}_{\text{clock}}, (3) such that the states \{U_{n}|\psi_{0}\rangle\}_{n\in\mathbb{Z}} are distinguishable and naturally ordered, with n serving as a logical or circuit-time parameter. This framework encompasses Page–Wootters relational time, thermal-time constructions, and circuit-based notions of time. 21 ; 11 . Many topological and condensed-matter sectors supply such clocks very naturally: braiding anyons in a fractional quantum Hall state, 26 acting with stabilizers in a toric code, 18 or tracking reconnection events in a defect network. 25 ; 27 Gravitational observers. The Euclidean de Sitter phase problem, however, is a statement about the index of the Hessian of the gravitational action. 22 ; 10 ; 17 ; 24 We call a subsystem a gravitational observer if its action I_{\text{obs}}[g,\gamma,\Phi] has a localized stress tensor that is non-negligible at the de Sitter scale and whose quadratic couplings to metric fluctuations h_{\mu\nu} mix with the conformal sector. In other words, the combined Hessian \Delta_{\text{grav+obs}} (4) has a different index (number of negative directions) from \Delta_{\text{grav}} alone. Maldacena’s black-hole observer is an explicit and well-controlled realization: the additional negative modes live in a joint configuration space of metric and worldline degrees of freedom, and their net effect is to alter the overall phase in a carefully constructed static-patch partition function 20 . These three notions are independent: a system may have worldlines without a clock; a clock without appreciable gravitational coupling; or strong gravitational coupling without a large internal Hilbert space. The mechanism of Ref. 20 implicitly uses the full intersection: a worldline carrying an informational clock whose fluctuations also share the conformal negative modes, as illustrated schematically in Fig. 1 . Worldlines (Localization) Informational Clocks (Internal \mathcal{H} ) Gravitational Observers (Backreaction \Delta_{\text{grav+obs}} ) Maldacena Mechanism Topological Spectators (No phase correction) Figure 1: Schematic relation between worldlines, informational clocks, and gravitational observers. The Maldacena mechanism operates only in the triple intersection, where a system both carries a clock and backreacts on the conformal factor so as to share its negative modes. Sectors that have worldlines and clocks but decouple from the metric (bottom overlap) are topological spectators: they can store and order information, but they cannot modify the universal de Sitter phase. Topological spectators and factorization.— We now identify a broad class of sectors that, while often rich from the informational point of view, do not affect the de Sitter phase at the level of semiclassical path integrals. By a

Read the complete text