A Deterministic Ionization Algorithm for the OSIRIS Particle-in-Cell Framework
S. DiIorio, R. Fonseca, F. Tsung, B.J. Winjum, A. G. R. Thomas · 2026
Read A Deterministic Ionization Algorithm for the OSIRIS Particle-in-Cell Framework by S. DiIorio, R. Fonseca, F. Tsung, B.J. Winjum, A. G. R. Thomas (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2603-17885.txt.
Introduction
DiIorio, Fonseca, Tsung, Winjum, and Thomas add deterministic collisional ionization to the OSIRIS plasma code. Particle-in-cell runs often miss this electron source in laser-plasma work. Their extension swaps random sampling for a fixed-rate algorithm. Ionization rate errors fall by up to a hundredfold, they report. Cost grows only linearly with particles per cell. Benchmarks against other codes check the physics across plasma regimes.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | S. DiIorio, R. Fonseca, F. Tsung, B.J. Winjum, A. G. R. Thomas |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 104880 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2603.17885
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
A Deterministic Ionization Algorithm for the OSIRIS Particle-in-Cell Framework S. DiIorio, R. Fonseca, F. Tsung, B.J. Winjum, A. G. R. Thomas Abstract Ionization is critical in the formation and evolution of plasma dynamics; collisional ionization, in particular, is an often overlooked source of electrons when dealing with laser-plasma interactions. Ionization plays a crucial role in understanding the complex plasma kinetics, ranging from cold and sparse astrophysical settings to hot and dense fusion systems. In this paper, we describe the underlying theory for and development, validation, and verification of an extension to the standard particle-in-cell method to include a deterministic algorithm for collisional ionization physics. This algorithm offers improved accuracy, achieving up to two orders of magnitude decrease in the error of the ionization rate calculations, scales linearly in execution time with the number of macro-particles per cell, has been tested for physical correctness and benchmarked against several codes. 1 Introduction Ionization is of interest for a wide range of scenarios, including astrophysical settings [ 89 , 5 , 56 ] , fusion [ 34 , 41 , 75 ] , ion acceleration [ 2 , 1 ] , ionization-induced defocusing [ 74 ] , energy transport and stopping power [ 67 , 62 ] , instability modeling [ 79 ] , solid-density plasmas [ 98 , 99 ] , and cathode, silicon detectors, and rf plasma modeling [ 17 , 13 , 14 , 95 , 96 , 94 , 10 ] , to name but a few. Astrophysical plasmas are generally composed of completely ionized hydrogen and helium atoms. Ionized electrons play a crucial role in the general cooling of the plasmas and also help diagnose the other elements and conditions present in nebulae and coronae. Collisional ionization gives rise to unique spectral lines through the ionization of inner shell electrons that can then be measured and compared against models to diagnose their composition [ 23 , 97 ] . In fusion diagnostics, elements whose spectral behavior and ionization rates are well understood are injected into the fusion plasma to serve as a diagnostic for the plasma conditions. Silicon frequently serves as this tool, and fluctuations in its measured X-ray emission can indicate sources of energy loss within the system [ 68 ] . Another such element is krypton, which serves as a plasma diagnostic used in Tokamak divertors to assist with radiative cooling [ 51 ] . Plasmas created in magnetic confinement fusion schemes are generally low in density but quite hot (the plasmas of their divertors, on the other hand, are usually estimated to be relatively colder). Consider fig. 1 , where we show a typical phase space diagram for different plasma regimes as a function of temperature and density. In this plot, the solid magenta line \tau_{I}/\tau_{TB} marks where the ratio of timescales for collisional ionization and three-body recombination is equal. The dashed magenta line \tau_{I}/\tau_{rad} marks where the timescales for collisional ionization and radiative recombination are equal. The dashed orange line shows the ratio of the photoionization timescale to the ion plasma frequency, assuming thermodynamic equilibrium. The blue lines show different contours for the ratio of the rates of collisional ionization to the ion plasma frequency. All the curves here are calculated for atomic number Z=1 . Laser-plasma interactions are generally hot and dense, up to plasma conditions near the hohlraum walls used in inertial confinement fusion at NIF and further increasing the density to the conditions of the compressed fusion fuel. The ionization physics is complex in these extreme cases and must be computed by considering the full detailed atomic transition kinetics. At slightly lower densities, laser-generated plasmas are often generated where collisional ionization effects start to become important, for example, with timescales comparable to the characteristic ion response timescale of the plasma (the inverse ion plasma frequency \omega_{pi} ). Often, it is assumed that the laser intensity is sufficient to field ionize the plasma, but in reality, regions just outside the laser spot or within dense material where the laser cannot penetrate are ionized by hot electron flows. Creating appropriate numerical tools for modeling ionization physics, in particular both field and collisional ionization, is crucial to accurate kinetic plasma modeling in these regimes. Figure 1: Plasma properties as a function of temperature and density. Particle-in-cell (PIC) codes [ 24 , 36 , 12 , 11 ] are an essential tool in understanding a wide range of plasma scenarios. Very early on, the need for algorithms to be able to represent the short range collisions that is missing from the basic PIC method was identified and implemented by considering binary interactions between macroparticles (particle-particle interactions) [ 17 , 82 , 28 , 90 , 73 ] or as an effective force (particle-grid interactions) [ 38 , 50 , 54 , 22 ] . While these methodologies were primarily developed to simulate Coulomb scattering events, the same algorithms may be applied to simulating collisional ionization events. For the particle-particle type method, Ref. [ 65 ] refined the Coulomb scattering models of Refs. [ 61 , 80 ] to include collisional ionization and has been implemented in several PIC codes [ 4 , 25 ] . Inaccuracies have been noted when there is a large discrepancy in the weights and energies of the macro-particle pair colliding and how to fix them [ 35 ] . The PIC code Smilei [ 25 ] uses this corrected version. Ref. [ 60 ] further develops Higginson’s corrections by improving the particle pairing process when there is a large discrepancy in the number of macro-particles of the two colliding species and this is also included in the latest versions of the PIC code Epoch [ 4 ] . In this paper, a new algorithm for simulating collisional ionization within a PIC framework based on a particle-grid rather than particle-particle interaction is demonstrated. Our method treats ionization events deterministically as each particle’s contribution to the ionization rate is deposited onto a grid. This grid of ionization rates is then used to advance ion charge states. Additionally, the energy is lost per cell due to ionization physics is tracked. We interpolate this information back onto the particles; this allows for a continuous decrease in the energy of macro-particles as they participate in ionization events and allows for the easy calculation of the new momentum of ionized electrons. This algorithm is implemented within the PIC code Osiris [ 30 ] . We demonstrate several tests and benchmarks against particle-in-cell codes that, when differences in the fundamental cross sections are accounted for, are in excellent agreement. 1.1 Theoretical background The impact ionization cross sections used in this implementation are the Modified Relativistic Binary Encounter Bethe (MRBEB) cross sections [ 43 , 33 ] , which match experimental electron impact ionization cross sections for a wide range of energies. For completeness, we first review the important details of the model and the sources of data. First, we define N_{k} and B_{k} to be the electron occupation number and electron binding energy, respectively, of subshell k and T and W to be the kinetic energy of the incident and secondary electron, respectively. We further normalize these terms as follows, defining {w=W/B_{k}} , {t=T/B_{k}} , {b^{\prime}=B_{k}/m_{e}c^{2}} ,