The Revised Evolutionary Volume Tolman Test: Cosmological Constraints from Galaxy Evolution 2022 The Revised Evolutionary Volume Tolman Test: Cosmological Constraints from Galaxy Evolution – References
Christopher J. Conselice, Edmund J. Copeland and Sergio Sevillano Muñoz · 2026
Read The Revised Evolutionary Volume Tolman Test: Cosmological Constraints from Galaxy Evolution 2022 The Revised Evolutionary Volume Tolman Test: Cosmological Constraints from Galaxy Evolution – References by Christopher J. Conselice, Edmund J. Copeland and Sergio Sevillano Muñoz (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2603-17842.txt.
Introduction
Conselice, Copeland, and Sevillano Muñoz revive the Tolman volume test for cosmology. The classic test counts galaxies per volume across redshift to pin cosmic parameters. Galaxy evolution once made that tracing too murky to trust. Known star formation and merger histories now clean the signal, they argue. With one to ten percent accuracy on those histories, the test could rival supernova and CMB methods. Dark energy dynamics are the prize measurement.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Christopher J. Conselice, Edmund J. Copeland and Sergio Sevillano Muñoz |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 65790 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2603.17842
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
The Revised Evolutionary Volume Tolman Test: Cosmological Constraints from Galaxy Evolution 2022 The Revised Evolutionary Volume Tolman Test: Cosmological Constraints from Galaxy Evolution – References Christopher J. Conselice, Edmund J. Copeland and Sergio Sevillano Muñoz Abstract In this study we adapt a classical cosmology measurement, the volume or number density test, to a modern synthesis of observed galaxy evolution. We do this by using measured galaxy mass functions and the history of galaxy evolution through star formation and galaxy mergers, inspired by the latest results from deep extragalactic surveys. We develop a new framework using measured galaxy volume number densities as a function of redshift and volume to determine cosmological parameters, especially those which alter the volume of the Universe at a given redshift. Whilst this is a classic cosmology test proposed since at least the 1930s, it has largely been abandoned for decades due to uncertainties in galaxy evolution which make it difficult to trace galaxy populations through time. However, recent advances in our understanding of star formation and the merging history of galaxies allow us to revise this method to uncover and measure cosmological parameters, especially those which involve the nature of dark energy. We present a modified version of the volume test, called the revised evolutionary volume Tolman test, using properties of known galaxy evolution as part of the cosmological calculation. We show how this method can successfully be applied and is competitive with other major cosmological measurement methods, including those using SNe and the CMB, when the merger and star formation histories can be measured accurately to between 1–10%. This accuracy is not yet achievable, but we discuss how future missions will allow these astrophysical quantities to be known at this level. Within this measurement accuracy we can measure the dynamical properties of dark energy, including its evolution through its equation of state. We also give a fuller accounting of the future use of this new method with upcoming galaxy surveys such as Euclid and LSST/Rubin. 1 Introduction One of the primary goals in astrophysics is understanding the cosmological history of the universe which includes measuring the cosmological parameters determining this evolution. Currently, one of the major questions within cosmology is the nature of the expansion of the universe, or the origin of what is now called dark energy (For reviews of dark energy see 22 ; 34 ). Understanding and measuring the dark energy and other cosmological parameters is now a major industry in astronomy, which are the focus of cosmic microwave background (CMB) missions such as WMAP ( 44 ) , Planck ( 5 ) , ACT ( 6 ) as well as galaxy surveys such as DESI ( 3 ) , DES and Euclid ( 31 ) among others. Meanwhile surveys of distant Cephid variables ( 50 ) and Type 1a supernova ( 62 ; 61 ) have led to independent determinations of the Hubble parameter (For a recent update see ( 33 ) and ( 35 ) ), some of which differ from the CMB prediction and which has led to what has become known as the Hubble Tension (for a discussion of the tension and possible theoretical resolutions see 41 and 43 ). Measuring the evolution of dark energy is a major goal of these ongoing and future missions, and a number of interesting and intriguing results are beginning to emerge. For example, using a combination of Baryon Acoustic Oscillation and Type 1a Supernova data, the DESI collaboration have argued for the first tentative evidence of dynamical dark energy ( 3 ; 2 , e.g.,) , although this has met with some resistance, see for example ( 23 ; 24 ; 29 ; 76 , e.g.,) . In the next decade very large projects such as Euclid ( 7 ; 31 ) , LSST/Rubin ( 40 ) and WFIRST ( 37 ) will continue this quest to understand the nature of dark energy. Most of these studies are done using traditional methods that have been heavily developed and built up over decades. This includes not only CMB power-spectra, but also examining the evolution of structure in the universe through weak lensing and galaxy clustering, as well as measuring the abundances of galaxy clusters over time ( 1 , e.g.,) . Whereas the analysis of Cepheid variables and Type 1a SN in distant galaxies has led to the determination of dark energy through luminosity distance measurements, this is not the first time galaxies have been used in cosmology to determine the evolution of the universe. In fact historically, cosmology was founded on the use of galaxies as cosmological probes, although the methods have in the past few decades flittered out due to the large scatter in measurables ( 64 , e.g.,) . Given that, galaxies as a cosmological probe is potentially an unexplored and long discarded method for uncovering cosmological features, which could help resolve some of the existing discrepancies by providing a new approach to determine cosmological parameters ( 47 ; 57 ; 21 , e.g.,) . Since its first proposal, galaxies have been recognised as a potentially powerful method for measuring cosmological properties. In the 1930s a few pioneering papers, ( 72 ; 38 , e.g.,) introduced a novel test which made use of galaxies, namely through a number count method with magnitude. This test was such that by determining the galaxy counts in a survey region down to an apparent magnitude, m, the total number of galaxies should grow as log N\sim 0.6\cdot{\rm log~m} in a Euclidean universe. By measuring the number of galaxies down to some magnitude the idea was to fit the slope between the magnitude and number counts. One success of this method was to show that the steady-state model of the universe was not consistent with radio galaxy counts ( 63 ) . In general, however, deviations from a \sim 0.6 slope would reveal if the universe had some positive or negative curvature. Since this method was proposed it was gradually realised that the number counts would depend on curvature of space, cosmological expansion, and the evolution of galaxies. Only later was it considered a cosmological test, in principle, and began appearing in cosmology textbooks ( 60 , e.g.,) , but it was rarely, or never fully, developed into a method of measurement. Later this method was expanded to (in principle) include the number of galaxies in a given cosmological volume in a given redshift bin, usually in terms of galaxy counts ( 67 ; 77 ; 25 , e.g.,) . This approach however was impossible to use to determine precise cosmological features as there was a degeneracy between the largely unknown galaxy distances, the fact of a ’blue’ galaxy excess, and the cosmology itself. Often there was an excess of blue galaxies seen that could be due to galaxy evolution or due to certain values of the de-acceleration parameter, q 0 ( 67 ; 13 , e.g.,) . This approach was however largely abandoned once redshifts for these objects became available with the establishment of multi-wavelength deep imaging from the Hubble Space Telescope and the discovery and study of Lyman-break galaxies ( 69 ; 75 ; 30 , e.g.,) . The method of looking