Mass Inventory of the Solar System Beyond the Sun:
A Systematic Compilation with Uncertainty Budget · 2026
Read Mass Inventory of the Solar System Beyond the Sun: by A Systematic Compilation with Uncertainty Budget (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2603-17561.txt.
Introduction
Menichella compiles a mass inventory of the Solar System without the Sun. He draws on spacecraft data, orbit fits, and surveys of asteroids and trans-Neptunian objects. A Monte Carlo run with 100,000 draws gives a median total of 462 Earth masses. The giant planets hold 96.2 percent of that mass. Nearly all the error comes from the inner Oort cloud, he finds. Rubin Observatory data may shrink that gap.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | A Systematic Compilation with Uncertainty Budget |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 30808 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2603.17561
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Mass Inventory of the Solar System Beyond the Sun: A Systematic Compilation with Uncertainty Budget Abstract We compile a systematic mass inventory of the Solar System excluding the Sun, drawing on spacecraft measurements, planetary ephemerides, and population surveys of small-body populations including main-belt asteroids, trans-Neptunian objects, and long-period comets as tracers of the Oort cloud, to assemble a single reference table with propagated uncertainties for all major components. Using a Monte Carlo simulation with 10 5 10^{5} realisations, and treating poorly constrained components (scattered disc, Oort cloud) as log-normal distributions, we obtain a total non-solar mass of 462 M ⊕ 462\,M_{\oplus} (median), with a 68% credible interval of [ 451 , 515 ] M ⊕ [451,\,515]\,M_{\oplus} and a 90% credible interval of [ 449 , 642 ] M ⊕ [449,\,642]\,M_{\oplus} . The giant planets dominate with 444.6 M ⊕ 444.6\,M_{\oplus} (96.2% of the total). A variance decomposition shows that 98.2% of the total uncertainty in the current Solar System mass budget is attributable to a single component: the inner Oort cloud (Hills cloud), for which no direct observational constraints exist. The current small-body populations retain only ∼ \sim 0.2% of the primordial trans-Neptunian disc mass inferred from Nice Model simulations, and ∼ \sim 0.04% of the primordial asteroid belt mass implied by the Grand Tack hypothesis. We identify constraints on the Oort cloud from the Vera C. Rubin Observatory and improved long-period comet surveys as the primary path toward a better-determined total mass budget. Keywords: Solar System — mass inventory — Oort cloud — Kuiper belt — planetary formation 1. Introduction The Solar System is, by mass, almost entirely the Sun. The Sun contains approximately 99.86% of the total mass of the system, with everything else — eight planets, hundreds of moons, millions of asteroids, billions of trans-Neptunian objects, and a vast reservoir of cometary nuclei in the outer reaches — contributing the remaining 0.14%. Yet it is precisely this remaining fraction that records the history of the Solar System’s formation and dynamical evolution, and that determines most of its observable complexity. Surprisingly, no single published work provides a comprehensive, updated, and self-consistent inventory of this non-solar mass, complete with uncertainty budgets for each component. Individual component masses are scattered across dozens of papers in planetary science, celestial mechanics, and Solar System dynamics: planetary masses in ephemeris papers ( Park et al. 2021 ) , the asteroid belt mass from dynamical analyses of planetary residuals ( Pitjeva & Pitjev 2018 ) , the Kuiper belt from dedicated survey papers ( Petit et al. 2023 ) , and the Oort cloud from long-period comet statistics and dynamical models ( Brasser 2008 ; Francis 2005 ) . These results use different units, different reference epochs, and different definitions of component boundaries, making direct comparison and summation non-trivial. Review articles on Solar System structure discuss mass budgets qualitatively, but do not assemble a quantitative inventory with propagated uncertainties. This paper attempts to fill that gap. Our goal is simple: to compile, from the current literature, the best available mass estimate for each major component of the Solar System excluding the Sun, to express all results in a common unit (Earth masses, M_{\oplus} ), and to propagate the uncertainties honestly and systematically. The result is a single reference table that can serve as a baseline for future studies. Three considerations motivate this work beyond mere bookkeeping. The first is the extreme dynamic range of component masses and their uncertainties. The planets are known to better than one part in a million; the Oort cloud is uncertain by two orders of magnitude. A systematic inventory makes this contrast visible and quantitative in a way that no individual paper has done before, and identifies clearly where observational effort would most improve our knowledge of the Solar System’s total mass budget. The second is the relevance of the current mass inventory to models of Solar System formation. Both the Nice Model ( Tsiganis et al. 2005 ; Gomes et al. 2005 ) and the Grand Tack hypothesis ( Walsh et al. 2011 ) predict specific amounts of mass depletion from the primordial asteroid belt and trans-Neptunian disc as a result of giant planet migration and dynamical instability. An accurate current inventory, compared with these theoretical predictions, provides a quantitative test of these formation scenarios and a baseline for assessing how much mass was lost and to where. The third motivation is the growing relevance of Solar System mass comparisons in the context of exoplanetary science. ALMA observations of protoplanetary discs around other stars have made it possible to estimate the mass available for planet formation in other systems, and comparative planetology increasingly requires knowing how our own system’s mass distribution compares with the range observed elsewhere. The structure of this paper is as follows. Section 2 describes our methodology. Sections 3.1 through 3.5 treat each component in turn. Section 4 presents the integrated mass inventory and Monte Carlo uncertainty analysis. Section 5 discusses the results in the context of Solar System formation models and exoplanetary disc comparisons. Section 6 summarises our conclusions. Throughout this paper we use Earth masses ( M_{\oplus}=5.972\times 10^{24} kg) as the primary unit. Solar masses ( M_{\odot}=1.989\times 10^{30} kg) are used where appropriate. All masses refer to the present epoch. 2. Methodology Our approach is a literature compilation with systematic uncertainty propagation. We do not derive new observational constraints, nor do we construct new dynamical models. Instead, we identify, for each component of the Solar System, the most precise and up-to-date mass estimate available in the refereed literature, assign it a central value and an uncertainty, and combine the components into a total mass budget with a consistently propagated uncertainty. 2.1 Source selection For each component we prioritise, in order: (i) direct spacecraft-derived measurements, where available; (ii) dynamical estimates from high-precision planetary ephemerides; (iii) population models calibrated against observational surveys; (iv) purely theoretical estimates from formation and dynamical evolution models. The first two categories apply to the planets, major moons, and the main asteroid belt, and yield uncertainties below 1%. The third category applies to the Kuiper belt and scattered disc, with uncertainties of order 20–50%. The fourth category applies exclusively to the Oort cloud, where uncertainties span one to two orders of magnitude. Where multiple independent estimates exist for the same component, we adopt the most recent measurement consistent with the majority of published values, and note significant discrepancies explicitly. 2.2 Uncertainty characterisation We treat uncertainties differently depending on their nature and magnitude. For well-determined components (planets, major moons, asteroid belt), uncertainties are approximately Gaussian and small. We quote the 1\sigma uncertainty as reported in the source paper and propagate them in quadrature: \sigma^{2}_{\mathrm{tot}}=\sum_{i}\sigma^{2}_{i}. (1) For components with large and asymmetric uncertainties — specifically the scattered disc, the inner Oort cloud, and the outer Oort cloud — a Gaussian description is inappropriate. We use a log-normal distribution, characterised by a multiplicative factor f such that the 68% credible interval spans [M/f,\;M\cdot f] , where M is the central estimate. 2.3 Monte Carlo uncertainty propagation To obtain the uncertainty on the total mass we use a Monte Carlo simulation with N=10^{5} realisations. We draw each component mass from its