Leg Drain: Quantifying the Global Redistribution of Football Talent through Multi-National Eligibility

Alexander Lehner, Giovanni Righetto · 2026

Read Leg Drain: Quantifying the Global Redistribution of Football Talent through Multi-National Eligibility by Alexander Lehner, Giovanni Righetto (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2603-17336.txt.

Introduction

Lehner and Righetto use football to measure how talent moves between countries. Their data cover over 92,000 professional players from Transfermarkt, with nearly 20,000 who can play for more than one nation. They call the shift in player value leg drain. France gains over three billion euros in value, they find. African and Caribbean nations lose the most compared with their economies. Old colonial ties strongly predict these flows, they report.

Catalog record

CREATORAlexander Lehner, Giovanni Righetto
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE27958
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2603.17336

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Leg Drain: Quantifying the Global Redistribution of Football Talent through Multi-National Eligibility Alexander Lehner, Giovanni Righetto Abstract Brain drain—the emigration of skilled individuals toward higher-wage economies—is a well-documented phenomenon, yet its aggregate economic cost remains difficult to quantify because individual productivity is rarely observed. We offer a novel angle on this measurement challenge by studying professional football, a global labour market in which every participant carries a publicly observable, consistently estimated market value. Using data on over 92,000 professional footballers worldwide from Transfermarkt, we identify nearly 20,000 players with multi-national eligibility and compute the implied transfer of human capital between countries. We find that the resulting “leg drain” disproportionately benefits wealthy European nations—France alone gains over €3 billion in player value—while African and Caribbean countries bear the largest losses relative to GDP. Italy is the single largest net loser in absolute terms, driven by the outflow of players with Italian heritage to Latin American national teams. A gravity model of bilateral flows reveals that former colonial ties are among the strongest predictors of leg drain intensity: countries with a colonial relationship to a major European footballing nation lose significantly more player value, even after controlling for population and income. These findings provide a transparent, quantifiable analogue to the broader brain drain debate and highlight how historical institutional links continue to shape global talent redistribution. JEL codes: F22, J61, O15, Z20, F14, N40 Keywords: brain drain; dual citizenship; football; gravity model; colonial ties; human capital; migration 1 Introduction The emigration of skilled individuals from poorer to richer countries—commonly termed “brain drain”—has been a persistent feature of globalisation over the past half-century. Beginning with the foundational contributions of 7 and 17 , economists have debated both the magnitude and welfare consequences of high-skill emigration. Subsequent work has established that brain drain is large, persistent, and geographically concentrated: 15 document that over 20 million tertiary-educated individuals from developing countries reside in the OECD, with emigration rates exceeding 80 percent in some small Caribbean and Pacific nations. More recently, 13 show through a dynamic general-equilibrium framework that liberalising high-skill migration could yield substantial global welfare gains, while 10 demonstrate that climate change will intensify these flows, disproportionately affecting the poorest countries. Yet despite decades of research, a fundamental measurement challenge remains: the economic value of individual workers is seldom directly observable, making it nearly impossible to compute how much human capital a sending country actually loses when its citizens emigrate [ 12 , 15 ] . This measurement gap has shaped—and limited—the entire brain drain debate. Theoretical predictions depend critically on the magnitude of the human capital loss: moderate outflows may generate beneficial “brain gain” incentives for education [ 3 , 11 ] , while large outflows may impoverish origin countries and widen global inequality [ 8 , 9 ] . Empirical work has therefore relied on indirect proxies—educational attainment, occupation categories, bilateral migration stocks [ 24 , 16 , 1 ] —none of which attach a market price to the individual worker. The result is that we know who moves but not precisely how much their departure costs the sending country. We propose to overcome this impasse by studying one labour market where individual valuations are both public and consistently estimated across the globe: professional football. The website Transfermarkt, the world’s most widely referenced player valuation platform, assigns crowd-sourced market values to over 800,000 players worldwide. These valuations have been shown to correlate strongly with actual transfer fees and to reflect observable player quality [ 21 , 23 , 25 ] . Crucially, Transfermarkt data spans every tier of professional football in virtually every country—enabling a global analysis that is rare even in the broader migration literature. Our key insight is simple. When a dual-citizenship footballer chooses to represent a national team other than his country of origin, he effectively “transfers” his human capital from one country to another—at least in the symbolic and sporting sense that national teams embody a country’s talent pool. We call this phenomenon leg drain , in analogy to brain drain. Unlike brain drain, however, leg drain can be precisely quantified: every player carries an observable market value, and every national team choice is publicly recorded. Football thus provides a rare setting in which the three ingredients needed for a complete accounting of skill flows—individual identification, bilateral assignment, and cardinal valuation—are simultaneously available. Using data on 92,643 professional footballers worldwide, we identify 19,956 players with multi-national eligibility who play for a national team different from at least one of their citizenships. We compute bilateral flows of player value between countries and merge these with World Bank indicators on population and GDP to produce normalised measures of leg drain intensity. Three findings stand out. First, leg drain is massive in absolute terms: the total value of players “redirected” through dual citizenship exceeds €20 billion. Second, the flows are highly asymmetric: a handful of European countries—France, England, the Netherlands, and Germany—are the primary beneficiaries, while African, Caribbean, and Central American nations bear the largest losses. Third, colonial history is a powerful predictor of these flows: former colonies of France, the United Kingdom, Belgium, and Portugal lose significantly more player value to their former colonisers than other countries, even after controlling for income and population. This pattern mirrors a well-established finding in the broader migration literature, where colonial and linguistic ties are among the strongest predictors of bilateral migration corridors [ 4 , 19 , 5 , 6 ] . Our contribution is threefold. First, we offer a methodological contribution by demonstrating that the football labour market—where individual identification, country assignment, and cardinal valuation are simultaneously observable—can serve as a transparent, globally comparable laboratory for studying the forces that shape talent redistribution. While national-team representation does not entail a change in a player’s club employment or residence, the bilateral patterns it generates are shaped by the same colonial, linguistic, and institutional links that drive labour migration. Unlike conventional approaches that infer human capital from education or occupation, our setting provides direct market valuations for each individual, enabling precise bilateral accounting. Second, we make a descriptive contribution by constructing the first comprehensive dataset of leg drain flows—covering 201 countries, over 2,300 bilateral corridors, and more than €20 billion in player value—and documenting the striking asymmetry between net gainers and losers. Third, we make an analytical contribution by embedding these flows in a gravity framework and showing that colonial ties remain a dominant determinant of talent redistribution, with effect sizes that are, if anything, larger than those found in the general migration literature [ 4 , 14 ] . Together, these results highlight how historical institutional links continue to shape the global distribution of human capital—not only in the abstract, but in a domain where the consequences are publicly visible every time a national team takes the field. The remainder of this paper is organised as follows. Section 2 describes the data. Section 3 presents descriptive evidence on leg drain flows. Section 4 introduces normalised measures and a gravity model of bilateral flows. Section 5 discusses the colonial dimension in detail. Section 6 concludes. 2 Data 2.1 Transfermarkt Our player-level data come from the football-datasets repository, 1 1 1 Accessible via https://github.com/salimt/football-datasets .

Read the complete text