Actionable Guidance Outperforms Map and Compass Cues in Demanding Immersive VR Wayfinding

Apurv Varshney University of California, Santa Barbara, Lily M. Turkstra University of California, Santa Barbara, Jiaxin Su University of California, Santa Barbara, Mable Zhou University of California, Santa Barbara, Scott T. Grafton University of California, Santa Barbara, Barry Giesbrecht University of California, Santa Barbara, Mary Hegarty University of California, Santa Barbara, Michael Beyeler University of California, Santa Barbara · 2026

Read Actionable Guidance Outperforms Map and Compass Cues in Demanding Immersive VR Wayfinding by Apurv Varshney University of California, Santa Barbara, Lily M. Turkstra University of California, Santa Barbara, Jiaxin Su University of California, Santa Barbara, Mable Zhou University of California, Santa Barbara, Scott T. Grafton University of California, Santa Barbara, Barry Giesbrecht University of California, Santa Barbara, Mary Hegarty University of California, Santa Barbara, Michael Beyeler University of California, Santa Barbara (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2603-17238.txt.

Introduction

Varshney and co-authors compare three navigation aids for wayfinding in immersive virtual reality. The aids are a directional arrow, a minimap, and a compass. In a room scale study, 42 participants ran 1,008 trials in a time pressured maze with low visibility and forced route changes. Arrow guidance gave the strongest navigation performance on behavior and eye tracking measures. The minimap sat in the middle, and the compass did worst. The authors argue that direct movement cues beat richer displays users must translate while moving.

Catalog record

CREATORApurv Varshney University of California, Santa Barbara, Lily M. Turkstra University of California, Santa Barbara, Jiaxin Su University of California, Santa Barbara, Mable Zhou University of California, Santa Barbara, Scott T. Grafton University of California, Santa Barbara, Barry Giesbrecht University of California, Santa Barbara, Mary Hegarty University of California, Santa Barbara, Michael Beyeler University of California, Santa Barbara
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE50212
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2603.17238

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Actionable Guidance Outperforms Map and Compass Cues in Demanding Immersive VR Wayfinding Apurv Varshney University of California, Santa Barbara, Lily M. Turkstra University of California, Santa Barbara, Jiaxin Su University of California, Santa Barbara, Mable Zhou University of California, Santa Barbara, Scott T. Grafton University of California, Santa Barbara, Barry Giesbrecht University of California, Santa Barbara, Mary Hegarty University of California, Santa Barbara, Michael Beyeler University of California, Santa Barbara Abstract Navigation aids are central to immersive virtual reality (VR) experiences that involve physical locomotion. Their effectiveness depends not only on how much spatial information they provide, but also on how directly that information supports movement decisions. We compared three common guidance techniques for immersive VR wayfinding: a directional arrow, a minimap, and a compass. In a controlled room-scale VR study with 42 participants completing 1008 trials, participants navigated to target landmarks in a time-pressured maze with reduced visibility and forced route replanning. Across behavioral and eye-tracking measures, arrow guidance produced the strongest navigation performance, minimap guidance yielded intermediate performance, and compass cues performed worst, suggesting that during immersive locomotion users benefit from guidance that can be interpreted rapidly while moving. These results suggest that in demanding immersive locomotion tasks, interfaces that translate spatial information directly into actionable movement cues can outperform richer but more interpretive spatial representations. Our findings highlight the importance of designing XR navigation interfaces that minimize the cognitive translation between spatial information and movement decisions. \onlineid 0 \vgtccategory Research \vgtcinsertpkg \preprinttext \teaser Overview of the immersive VR navigation task. Left: Navigation aid conditions presented during the task: minimap, arrow, and compass. Middle: Schematic of in-world view during maze navigation. Participants physically walked through the environment to locate target landmarks. Dashed lines indicate the participant’s visual field, and the soccer ball denotes an incidental attention probe used to measure selective attention during navigation. Right: Environmental elements used to increase task demands, including time pressure, fog, ambient audio, and dynamic obstacles. In every trial, a wall descended as participants entered the first corridor, blocking the initially available route and forcing online replanning. Introduction keywords virtual reality, wayfinding, navigation interfaces, spatial guidance, locomotion, situational awareness, cognitive load, human-computer interaction Wayfinding is a core interaction in immersive extended reality (XR) [ 3 , 26 ] . Navigation aids differ not only in how much spatial information they provide, but also in how much effort users must expend to translate that information into action [ 8 , 22 , 7 , 23 ] . This distinction becomes especially important during room-scale locomotion, where users must make navigation decisions while walking, monitoring obstacles, and maintaining spatial orientation under continuous perceptual load [ 28 , 25 , 30 , 39 ] . Under such conditions, richer spatial representations do not necessarily translate into better guidance [ 1 , 11 ] . This distinction matters because common navigation aids place different interpretive demands on the user [ 23 ] . Directional arrows provide immediate egocentric guidance toward a goal [ 7 ] . Minimaps provide a spatial overview of the environment, requiring users to interpret the map and align it with their viewpoint [ 8 , 22 , 4 , 25 ] . Compasses provide only goal direction, leaving users to determine a feasible route [ 23 , 28 , 25 ] . Consequently, these interfaces differ not only in the information they provide but also in the cognitive demands they impose during navigation. These demands become especially consequential during immersive locomotion. Prior work shows that navigation interfaces can shape not only wayfinding success but also visual attention and situational awareness [ 1 , 4 , 35 ] . For example, navigation aids in mobile and wide-area augmented reality (AR) can affect users’ ability to locate targets and recall surrounding objects [ 25 , 24 ] . Other work shows that the placement and anchoring of guidance cues influence how users allocate visual attention during navigation [ 33 , 42 ] . Navigation behavior can also shift under demanding conditions such as time pressure or uncertainty, increasing reliance on simpler and more reactive forms of guidance [ 6 , 41 , 43 , 14 , 19 , 18 ] . Together, these findings suggest that the effectiveness of a navigation aid depends not only on the information it provides but also on how readily that information supports action during locomotion. Despite their widespread use, many immersive navigation interfaces are still guided more by convention than by direct empirical comparison. Prior work has examined arrows [ 7 ] , minimaps [ 8 , 22 ] , compass-style tools [ 23 , 28 ] , and related aids in mobile AR [ 25 , 32 ] . However, these techniques are often evaluated in isolation or in different tasks and environments. As a result, it remains unclear how actionable guidance compares with richer but more interpretive spatial aids within the same immersive wayfinding scenario. In this paper, we examine this question in a controlled room-scale virtual reality (VR) navigation task by directly comparing three widely used guidance techniques: a directional arrow, a minimap, and a compass ( Figure Actionable Guidance Outperforms Map and Compass Cues in Demanding Immersive VR Wayfinding ). The arrow provides a direct action cue by indicating the egocentric direction of the goal relative to the user. Unlike world-anchored arrows embedded in the environment to guide users along a path [ 25 ] , our arrow is a view-fixed interface element that indicates the direction of the goal even when a feasible route is not directly visible, allowing users to progress toward the target while resolving local route choices. In contrast, the compass provides only goal bearing, requiring users to align their heading (“ | ” in Figure Actionable Guidance Outperforms Map and Compass Cues in Demanding Immersive VR Wayfinding , Left ) with the target direction (“V”) and determine a valid route through the maze. The minimap provides an allocentric overview of the maze layout, requiring users to interpret the map and translate it into movement decisions during navigation. In a study with 42 participants and 1008 total trials, participants navigated to target landmarks in a time-pressured maze with reduced visibility, forced route replanning, and environmental stressors. Our primary outcome measure was navigation performance, defined as a composite metric combining path efficiency and completion time. As secondary measures, we examined selective attention to incidental objects and perceived workload to assess potential tradeoffs between navigation efficiency and situational awareness or task demand. We additionally conducted exploratory analyses of gaze behavior and self-reported navigation strategies. Across measures, we observed a consistent ordering: arrow guidance produced the strongest navigation performance, minimap guidance provided intermediate support, and compass cues performed worst. This pattern suggests that in demanding immersive locomotion tasks, reducing the interpretive steps between interface information and movement decisions may improve navigation efficiency. This work makes two contributions: • We present a controlled comparison of three common navigation aids (arrow, minimap, and compass) in a room-scale VR wayfinding task involving time pressure, reduced visibility, and forced route replanning. • We show that directional arrow guidance improves navigation performance relative to minimap and compass cues in this demanding immersive navigation scenario, while requiring less interface inspection

Read the complete text