Stars stably accreting from substellar objects

Aaron Householder, Kaitlyn Shin, Kevin B. Burdge, Thomas R. Marsh, Saul A. Rappaport, Kareem El-Badry, Joheen Chakraborty, Emma Chickles, Fei Dai, Matthew J. Graham, S.R. Kulkarni, Pablo Rodríguez-Gil, Andrew Vanderburg, Samuel Whitebook · 2026

Read Stars stably accreting from substellar objects by Aaron Householder, Kaitlyn Shin, Kevin B. Burdge, Thomas R. Marsh, Saul A. Rappaport, Kareem El-Badry, Joheen Chakraborty, Emma Chickles, Fei Dai, Matthew J. Graham, S.R. Kulkarni, Pablo Rodríguez-Gil, Andrew Vanderburg, Samuel Whitebook (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2603-17039.txt.

Introduction

Householder and co-authors report the first direct sightings of stars stably accreting from substellar companions. Brown dwarfs near a host star are usually expected to be engulfed and destroyed. Theory allows stable, long lived mass transfer in some cases, but it had never been observed. The team identifies two binaries, with orbital periods of 87 and 67 minutes. In each, a brown dwarf steadily feeds mass onto an M dwarf companion. They argue such systems may be consumed slowly over billions of years instead of destroyed at once.

Catalog record

CREATORAaron Householder, Kaitlyn Shin, Kevin B. Burdge, Thomas R. Marsh, Saul A. Rappaport, Kareem El-Badry, Joheen Chakraborty, Emma Chickles, Fei Dai, Matthew J. Graham, S.R. Kulkarni, Pablo Rodríguez-Gil, Andrew Vanderburg, Samuel Whitebook
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE55660
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2603.17039

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Stars stably accreting from substellar objects Aaron Householder, Kaitlyn Shin, Kevin B. Burdge, Thomas R. Marsh, Saul A. Rappaport, Kareem El-Badry, Joheen Chakraborty, Emma Chickles, Fei Dai, Matthew J. Graham, S.R. Kulkarni, Pablo Rodríguez-Gil, Andrew Vanderburg, Samuel Whitebook Abstract Substellar objects such as brown dwarfs and planets are generally expected to remain detached from their main-sequence host stars unless orbital decay or stellar expansion brings them into contact, leading to rapid engulfment and destruction (e.g., De2023 ). Such a fate is predicted for the Earth and other rocky planets in our solar system Schroder2008 ; however, in certain cases, theory also allows for stable long-lived mass transfer from a substellar object onto its main-sequence host Hjellming1987 , though such accretion has never been directly observed. Here we report the first direct observations of stable mass transfer from a substellar object onto a main-sequence star. In particular, we identify two binaries, ZTF J0440+2325 and ZTF J1444+4820, with orbital periods of just 87 and 67 minutes, respectively, in which a brown dwarf stably transfers mass onto an M dwarf companion. These systems demonstrate that the fate of some substellar objects is not rapid engulfment and destruction, but instead gradual consumption for potentially billions of years. We identified ZTF J0440+2325 in a systematic search for short-period variables in data from the Zwicky Transient Facility (ZTF) Bellm2019 ; Graham2019 ; Masci2019 . The system had a highly significant periodic signal at an orbital period of P=86.65 minutes, which motivated ground-based follow-up. On UT 2023 October 18, we obtained high-speed simultaneous five-band ( u,g,r,i,z ) photometry of ZTF J0440+2325 with HiPERCAM Dhillon2021 on the 10.4 -m Gran Telescopio Canarias (GTC). The light curves showed extreme chromatic variability, with amplitudes that increased toward shorter wavelengths (Figure 1 ). In particular, ZTF J0440+2325 brightened by more than a factor of 30 in the u band relative to minimum brightness, while the corresponding increase in brightness in the z band was comparatively modest (a factor of roughly 1.4 ). Such short period and large wavelength-dependent modulations are not produced by isolated late-type stars, but are characteristic of compact binaries in which one component is actively accreting material from a companion and develops a bright hot spot that rotates in and out of view Warner1995 . Indeed, light-curve modeling with lcurve Copperwheat2010 showed that the HiPERCAM data are well described by a large self-eclipsing hot spot on one component of the binary (Methods). However, the photometry alone does not reveal the nature of the binary or what physical process is powering the hot spot. To better understand the photometric behavior of ZTF J0440+2325, we obtained phase-resolved spectroscopy with the Low Resolution Imaging Spectrometer (LRIS) on the 10 -m Keck I telescope Oke1995 as well as the Echellette Spectrograph and Imager (ESI) on the Keck II telescope Sheinis2002 . The spectra of ZTF J0440+2325 had M dwarf absorption features and showed excellent agreement with the empirical M8 dwarf template from PyHammer Kesseli2017 (Figure 1 ). We also measured the radial velocities of the M dwarf and found a semi-amplitude of K=24.7\pm 2.6\,\mathrm{km\,s^{-1}} (Methods), placing the unseen companion in the substellar mass regime. For instance, adopting a typical late-M dwarf mass of M=0.11\,M_{\odot} and numerically solving the exact mass-function relation yields a minimum companion mass of M\sin i=11.7\pm 1.3\,M_{\mathrm{Jup}} . Combined with the strong optical variability, we therefore conclude that ZTF J0440+2325 is a mass-transferring M dwarf–brown-dwarf binary. This interpretation is also supported by the phase-resolved LRIS blue-arm spectra of ZTF J0440+2325, which are largely featureless apart from transient Balmer absorption near peak optical brightness (Extended Data Figure 9 ). Such behavior is consistent with a buried accretion shock, in which the stream penetrates beneath the photosphere of the accretor to the depth where its ram pressure matches the atmospheric pressure of the accretor Marsh2002 . The resulting heated photosphere produces transient Balmer-absorption–dominated spectra, analogous to those observed on the dayside of many strongly heated companions in black widow pulsars (e.g., Romani2021 ). One remarkable aspect of ZTF J0440+2325 is that both the phase-dependent Balmer absorption and the overall light-curve morphology are extremely similar to black widow pulsar systems, where a neutron star irradiates a low-mass companion. Indeed, Burdge2022 identified ZTF J1406+1222, a 62 -minute binary with very similar optical variability, transient Balmer features, and a small radial velocity semi-amplitude and interpreted it as a black widow pulsar. However, this black widow pulsar scenario is strongly disfavored for ZTF J0440+2325 for multiple reasons. Most importantly, the measured radial-velocity semi-amplitude of the M dwarf is K=24.7\pm 2.6\,\mathrm{km\,s^{-1}} , which would require an orbital inclination i\leq 2.5^{\circ} if the unseen companion were a 1.4\,M_{\odot} neutron star, corresponding to an a priori probability of only 9\times 10^{-4} (Methods). Furthermore, ZTF J0440+2325 is not detected in X-rays, with a 3\sigma X-ray luminosity upper limit of 7.1\times 10^{29}\,\mathrm{erg\,s^{-1}} (Methods), below the luminosities typically observed from black widow pulsars ( L_{X}\sim 10^{30} – 10^{32}\,\mathrm{erg\,s^{-1}} ) Gentile2014 . In addition to ZTF J0440+2325, we identified ZTF J1444+4820, a second brown dwarf–M dwarf mass-transferring system with nearly analogous photometric behavior that definitively cannot be a black widow pulsar. ZTF J1444+4820 has an orbital period of P=67.16 minutes and showed eclipses in its ZTF light curves. On UT 2024 August 3, we obtained high-speed simultaneous five-band photometry of ZTF J1444+4820 with HiPERCAM, which confirmed the eclipse and the same extreme wavelength-dependent variability seen in ZTF J0440+2325, with very large amplitudes in the blue and much smaller amplitudes in the red (Figure 2 ). As in ZTF J0440+2325, the HiPERCAM light curves of ZTF J1444+4820 are also well fit by a hot spot (Methods), with the primary difference being that the hot spot in ZTF J1444+4820 is eclipsed by the companion near peak brightness (Extended Data Figure 5 ). In black widow pulsar systems, the optical variability is entirely driven by irradiation of the companion, so such systems do not produce sharp eclipses in the optical. While the presence of eclipses strongly rules out a black widow pulsar interpretation for ZTF J1444+4820, the eclipses do not impose the usual geometric and dynamical constraints associated with eclipsing binaries. This is because the eclipses correspond to occultations of the hot spot, not of the underlying stellar photospheres. To further characterize the system, we thus obtained phase-resolved Keck/LRIS spectroscopy of ZTF J1444+4820. However, a focusing issue prevented us from obtaining usable red-arm spectra, and the available blue-arm data show only transient Balmer absorption near peak brightness (which help constrain the nature of the system but do not provide stable photospheric features for phase-resolved radial-velocity measurements). As a result, the component masses and spectral types of ZTF J1444+4820 cannot yet be dynamically constrained as directly as in ZTF J0440+2325. Nonetheless, the SPHEREx spectrum of ZTF J1444+4820 shows clear evidence for a late-type photosphere consistent with an M dwarf, suggesting that one component in the binary is indeed an M dwarf (Figure 2 ; Extended Data Figure 7 ). While we do not yet have radial velocities, the ultra-short orbital period of ZTF J1444+4820 severely restricts the nature of the unseen companion, as only objects with very high mean densities can exist at such small separations (see e.g., Rappaport2021 ). In particular, at this orbital period

Read the complete text