Type Ia supernovae interacting with a close circumstellar material (SNe Ia-CSM) are SNe Ia inside planetary nebulae (SNIPs)
Noam Soker · 2026
Read Type Ia supernovae interacting with a close circumstellar material (SNe Ia-CSM) are SNe Ia inside planetary nebulae (SNIPs) by Noam Soker (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2603-16810.txt.
Introduction
Soker argues that type Ia supernovae seen hitting nearby gas fit a known merger scenario. In the core-degenerate scenario, a white dwarf merges with the core of a giant star during common envelope evolution. The merged remnant later explodes inside the planetary nebula the envelope formed. Soker compares two delay-time distributions with recent rate estimates. The small share of interacting events, about 0.04 percent, is compatible with the roughly 80 percent share expected to explode inside a nebula. So rare-looking events need no rare pathway.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Noam Soker |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 37543 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2603.16810
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Type Ia supernovae interacting with a close circumstellar material (SNe Ia-CSM) are SNe Ia inside planetary nebulae (SNIPs) Noam Soker Abstract I show that a newly estimated fraction of normal type Ia supernovae (SNe Ia) that interact within about 100 days of explosion with circumstellar material (CSM), called SNe Ia-CSM, is compatible with a recently estimated fraction of normal SNe Ia that interact with an old planetary nebula, hence, supporting the core-degenerate (CD) scenario for normal SNe Ia. According to the CD scenario, a white dwarf (WD) merges with the core of an asymptotic giant branch star at the end of common envelope evolution (CEE) and forms a massive WD remnant close to the Chandrasekhar mass. The CEE ejects a planetary nebula that the WD remnant ionizes. Most explosions occur within a merger-to-explosion delay (MED) time of less than a million years, before the planetary nebula material disperses to the interstellar medium, leading to a SN Ia inside a planetary nebula (SNIP). I discuss two plausible MED time distributions and show that the newly determined SNe Ia-CSM fraction of all normal SNe Ia, ≃ 0.04 % \simeq 0.04\% , is compatible with the SNIP fraction of ≃ 0.8 \simeq 0.8 . Therefore, although the fraction of SNe Ia-CSM is very small, it does not require a rare evolutionary pathway. I argue that SNe Ia-CSM follow the same scenario that accounts for 70 % − 90 % 70\%-90\% of all normal SNe Ia, namely, the CD scenario. I INTRODUCTION Despite the iconic Tycho and Kepler type Ia supernovae (SNe Ia) and the intensive usage of the images of their remnants, as well as other SN Ia remnants (SNRs), in public lectures and classes, there is no consensus on the leading scenarios of normal SNe Ia. Not only there is no consensus on the leading SN Ia scenarios, there is also no consensus on the classification of the different theoretical scenarios, as evidence from the many reviews in the last decade (e.g., Maoz, Mannucci, & Nelemans 2014 ; Maeda & Terada 2016 ; Hoeflich 2017 ; Livio & Mazzali 2018 ; Soker 2018 ; Soker 2019a ; Soker 2024a ; Wang 2018 ; Jha, Maguire, & Sullivan 2019 ; Ruiz-Lapuente 2019 ; Ruiter 2020 ; Aleo et al. 2023 ; Liu, Röpke, & Han 2023 ; Vink ’o, Szalai, & Könyves-Tóth 2023 ; Ruiter & Seitenzahl 2025 ). A prominent piece of evidence from recent classifications and studies is that the previous millennium’s classification of the single-degenerate (SD) and double-degenerate (DD) scenarios is obsolete. The core-degenerate (CD) scenario, studied in this paper, does not belong to either the SD or the DD scenarios. Some scenarios have two or more channels (sub-scenarios). Examples include the common-envelope wind model ( Meng & Podsiadlowski 2017 ; Cui et al. 2022 ; Wang & Meng 2025 ) , the HeCO hybrid channel of the DD scenario (e.g., Perets et al. 2019 ; Zenati, Toonen, & Perets 2019 ; Zenati et al. 2023 ), the channels of the SD scenario with a main-sequence star and a carbon–oxygen–neon white dwarf (WD; e.g., Guo et al. 2025 ), and the core-merger detonation model ( Ablimit 2021 ) . Some papers reconsider new processes, i.e., new mass-transfer prescriptions (e.g., Li, Liu, & Wang 2023 ). Each scenario has advantages, but also struggles to explain certain observations. Some observations challenge most scenarios, or even all (e.g., Pearson et al. 2024 ; Schinasi-Lemberg & Kushnir 2025 ; Sharon & Kushnir 2025 ; Sharon, Kushnir, & Schinasi-Lemberg 2025 ; Wang et al. 2024 ). Because there is no one emerging leading SN Ia scenario, studies in recent years have considered the different scenarios and their channels for normal and peculiar SNe Ia (e.g., Bora et al. 2024 ; Boos, Townsley, & Shen 2024 ; Bregman et al. 2024 ; Casabona & Fisher 2024 ; DerKacy et al. 2024 ; Joshi, Strolger, & Zenati 2024 ; Ko et al. 2024 ; Kobashi et al. 2024 ; Lim et al. 2024 ; Mandal et al. 2024 ; Mandal et al. 2025b ; Mehta et al. 2024 ; Palicio et al. 2024 ; Phillips et al. 2024 ; Soker 2024b ; Uchida et al. 2024 ; Burmester et al. 2025 ; Ferrand et al. 2025 ; Gaba et al. 2025 ; Griffith et al. 2025 ; Hoogendam et al. 2025a ; Hoogendam et al. 2025b ; Ito et al. 2025 ; Iwata & Maeda 2025 ; Kumar, Prust, & Bildsten 2025 ; Magee et al. 2025 ; Michaelis, Hillman, & Perets 2025 ; Michaelis & Perets 2025 ; O’Hora et al. 2025 ; Pollin et al. 2025 ; Simotas, Bildsten, & Prust 2025 ; Wang, Chen, & Pan 2025 ; Chen et al. 2026 ; Court et al. 2026 ; Pakmor et al. 2026 ; Pan, Ruiz-Lapuente, & González Hernández 2026 ; Zhao, Maeda, & Wang 2026 , for a limited list of papers since 2024). The situation might be complicated by the presence of multiple SN Ia populations (e.g., Gaba et al. 2026 ), particularly Chandrasekhar- and sub-Chandrasekhar-mass explosions (see the reviews listed above). In addition to general explorations and studies of different scenarios, there are debates about the scenarios for specific SNe Ia. While Das et al. 2025 and Mandal et al. 2025a argued for the double-detonation (DDet) scenario for SNR 0509-67.5, I argued for the CD scenario ( Soker 2025d ) . Mandal et al. 2025b argued for the DDet scenario for Tycho SNR, while I argued for the CD scenario ( Soker 2025f ) . Specifically, I argue that both SNRs are SNe Ia inside planetary nebulae (SNIPs; Dickel & Jones 1985 already argued that Tycho is an SNIP). The CD scenario predicts that a large fraction of SNe Ia are SNIPs. Earlier papers estimated that a large fraction of SNe Ia are SNIPs: f_{\rm SNIP}(2015)>0.2 ( Tsebrenko & Soker 2015 ) , f_{\rm SNIP}(2019)\simeq 0.15-0.2 ( Soker 2019b ) , f_{\rm SNIP}(2022)\simeq 0.5 ( Soker 2022 ) , f_{\rm SNIP}(2025)>0.5 ( Soker 2025d ) , and f_{\rm SNIP}(2026)\simeq 0.7-0.9 ( Soker 2025f ) . The goal of this study is to incorporate a new estimate by Desai et al. 2026 of the fraction of SNe Ia that interact early, within \simeq 100 days, with circumstellar material (CSM), termed SNe Ia-CSM, into the CD scenario and the estimated fraction of SNIPs. Before I conduct this task in Section III , I update the status of the six main scenarios in the classification I adapt here (Section II ). I summarize in Section IV . II Scenarios of normal SN Ia in 2026 In this section, I present my 2026 updated estimate of the contributions of different scenarios to normal SNe Ia. I will refer to the classification I have been using in the last two years ( Soker 2024a ; Soker 2025d ; Braudo & Soker 2024 ; Braudo & Soker 2025 ) . I present the six scenarios in Table 1 . As I emphasized in Section I , there are other classifications by different studies, as there is no consensus on the classifications. The first five rows are as in previous studies, as they describe the basic properties of the