commuting probability of skew left braces
Susanta Mondal, Manoj K. Yadav · 2026
Read commuting probability of skew left braces by Susanta Mondal, Manoj K. Yadav (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2603-16771.txt.
Introduction
Mondal and Yadav define a commuting probability for skew left braces, in analogy with group theory. They prove upper and lower bounds for this value. For finite nontrivial braces, they show it never exceeds three quarters. They also show no brace has a value strictly between five eighths and one, apart from three quarters itself, and they give an explicit example for that case. Braces with values above a stated bound are shown to be nilpotent. The value also stays fixed under isoclinism.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Susanta Mondal, Manoj K. Yadav |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 73171 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2603.16771
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
commuting probability of skew left braces Susanta Mondal, Manoj K. Yadav Abstract . We introduce a concept of the commuting probability of a skew left brace analogous to group theory. We establish upper and lower bounds for the commuting probability and prove that, for finite non-trivial skew left braces, it is always at most 3 4 \frac{3}{4} . Interestingly, there is no skew left brace with commuting probability in the open interval ( 5 / 8 , 1 ) (5/8,1) , except 3 4 \frac{3}{4} , for which we construct an explicit example. A characterization of skew left braces having commuting probability 3 4 \frac{3}{4} or 5 8 \frac{5}{8} is presented. We further show that the finite skew left braces with commuting probability larger than 65 128 \frac{65}{128} are necessarily nilpotent. We prove that the commuting probability remains invariant under isoclinism of skew braces. We introduce a concept of a compact Hausdorff topological skew left brace B B , where we prove that the set of all elements of B B having finite centraliser index in B B is a Borel subgroup. For such infinite non-trivial skew left braces too 3 4 \frac{3}{4} is the upper bound for the commuting probability, and 3 4 \frac{3}{4} is the only rational number which occurs as commuting probability in the open interval ( 5 / 8 , 1 ) (5/8,1) . 2010 Mathematics Subject Classification 16N99, 16T25, 20F24 1. Introduction Commuting probability of groups has long been studied in the literature, starting from its genesis in [ 13 ] by Erdos and Turan, and its inception in [ 18 ] by Gustafson for groups. This article aims at introducing an analogous concept for skew left braces and obtaining several fundamental results. A set B equipped with two group structures (B,+) and (B,\circ) is said to be a skew left brace if a\circ(b+c)=(a\circ b)-a+(a\circ c) for all a,b,c\in B , where -a is the inverse of a in (B,+) . It turns out that the group identities of both the groups (B,+) and (B,\circ) coincide, which we denote by 1 . If (B,+) is an abelian group, the skew left braces is called a left brace. The concept of left braces and skew left braces were, respectively, introduced by Rump [ 30 ] and Guarnieri and Vendramin [ 17 ] in connection with the study of set-theoretical solutions of the quantum Yang-Baxter equation, suggested by Drienfeld [ 12 ] . For a finite skew left brace (B,+,\circ) , we define commuting probability, denoted by \operatorname{Pb}(B) , by the quantity \operatorname{Pb}(B):=\frac{1}{|B|^{2}}|\{(x,y)\in B\times B\mid x+y-x-y=x\circ y\circ x^{-1}\circ y^{-1}=-x+(x\circ y)-y=1\}|, where x^{-1} denotes the inverse of x in (B,\circ) . For infinite skew left brace, we first introduce the concept of compact Hausdorff topological skew left brace, and then the concept of a measure on the closed subsets of the skew left brace. To be more precise, we say that a skew left brace B topological if there exists a common topology of subsets of B under which both the groups (B,+) and (B,\circ) are topological groups. Let \mu be a probability measure on the group (B,\circ) and Z:=\{(x,y)\in B\times B\mid x+y-x-y=x\circ y\circ x^{-1}\circ y^{-1}=-x+(x\circ y)-y=1\}. Then the commuting probability of a compact Hausdorff topological skew left brace B , again denoted by \operatorname{Pb}(B) , is defined by \operatorname{Pb}(B):=(\mu\times\mu)(Z). See Section 5 for more details. The article is constituted of four sections after the present one. The second section is on preliminaries and some key observations. It is observed that \operatorname{Cb}_{B}(x) , the brace centraliser of x\in B is a subgroup of (B,\circ) . Also the set \operatorname{FCI}(B) of all elements of B whose centralisers have finite index in (B,\circ) is a subgroup of (B,\circ) . Commuting probability for finite skew braces is introduced in Section 3, where several bounds on it are obtained. We prove that if \operatorname{Pb}(B) is different from \frac{3}{4} and 1 , then \operatorname{Pb}(B)\in(0,\frac{5}{8}] . Further, \operatorname{Pb}(B)=\frac{3}{4} if and only if B/\operatorname{Ann}(B) is of order 2 , where \operatorname{Ann}(B) denotes the annihilator of the skew brace B . It is proved that if \operatorname{Pb}(B)=\frac{5}{8} , then both the additive and the multiplicative groups of quotient skew brace B/\operatorname{Ann}(B) are isomorphic to \mathbb{Z}/2\mathbb{Z}\times\mathbb{Z}/2\mathbb{Z} . It is also proved that \operatorname{Pb}(B)\leqslant\operatorname{Pb}(A) for any sub-skew brace A of a finite skew brace B . Connections between commuting probability and nilpotency of skew left braces is investigated in Section 4. It is proved that a finite skew brace B with \operatorname{Pb}(B)\geq\frac{65}{128} is nilpotent. In the same section, we also show that commuting probability is invariant under isoclinism of skew left braces. In the concluding section, Section 5, we introduce the concept of commuting probability of compact Hausdorff topological skew left braces, where, among several interesting results, we prove that \operatorname{FCI}(B) is a Borel set, and \operatorname{FCI}(B) is open in B if and only if \operatorname{Pb}(B)>0 . It is also established that if \operatorname{Pb}(B) is different from \frac{3}{4} and 1 , then \operatorname{Pb}(B)\in[0,\frac{5}{8}] . We conclude this section by setting some notations. As mentioned above, the common additive and multiplicative identity of a skew left brace is denoted by 1 . For a skew left brace (B,+,\circ) and a,b\in B , the commutator [a,b]^{+}=a+b-a-b in (B,+) is denoted by \gamma^{+}(a,b) and the commutator [a,b]^{\circ}=a\circ b\circ a^{-1}\circ b^{-1} in (B,\circ) is denoted by \gamma^{\circ}(a,b) . Left normed higher commutators in (B,+) and (B,\circ) are defined inductively. The center of a group G is denoted by \operatorname{Z}(G) , and for any element g\in G , the centraliser of g in G is denoted by \operatorname{C}_{G}(g) . 2. Preliminaries and some key results A non-empty set B , equipped with two group structures (B,+) and (B,\circ) , is said to be a skew left brace if for a,b,c\in B the following compatibility condition (skew left distributivity) holds: a\circ(b+c)=a\circ b-a+a\circ c, where -a is the inverse of a in (B,+) . A skew right brace can be defined analogously, that is, demanding skew right distributivity. A skew left brace (B,+,\circ) is said to be a two-sided skew brace if (B,+,\circ) is also a skew right brace. Note that if (B,+,\circ) is a skew left brace with (B,\circ) abelian, then (B,+,\circ) is a two-sided skew brace. The groups (B,+) and (B,\circ) are, respectively, called additive group and multiplicative group of the skew left brace (B,+,\circ) . For simplicity of notation we denote a skew left brace (B,+,\circ) by B . If we want to emphasise the role of group operations, then we use the original notation. We will normally drop the use of word ‘left’ from skew left brace, and just say skew brace, unless it is necessary to specify the property. Every group (B,+) can viewed as a skew brace by defining \circ=+ . Such a skew brace is called trivial . A skew brace which is not a trivial skew brace is called a non-trivial skew brace . Easiest among non-trivial skew braces are skew braces (B,+,+_{op}) with (B,+) any non-abelian group and (B,+_{op}) the opposite group of (B,+) , that is, a+_{op}b=b+a for all a,b\in B . Let X be a given property of groups. A skew brace (B,+,\circ) is said to be X -type if its additive group (B,+)