Curvature Inequalities and Rigidity for Constant Mean Curvature and Spacetime Constant Mean Curvature Surfaces
Alejandro Peñuela Diaz · 2026
Read Curvature Inequalities and Rigidity for Constant Mean Curvature and Spacetime Constant Mean Curvature Surfaces by Alejandro Peñuela Diaz (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2603-16707.txt.
Introduction
Peñuela proves curvature bounds and rigidity for surfaces of constant mean curvature. The results cover curved spaces and spacetime alike. A classic bound ties squared mean curvature to a surface's area. His version needs a weaker check: stability only in the constant mode. When equality holds, the enclosed region must be flat Euclidean space. For spacetime surfaces he builds the matching stability theory. The sharp bound holds when matter obeys the dominant energy rule. Equality there forces a causal diamond in flat Minkowski space.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Alejandro Peñuela Diaz |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 117307 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/publicdomain/zero/1.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC0 |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2603.16707
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Curvature Inequalities and Rigidity for Constant Mean Curvature and Spacetime Constant Mean Curvature Surfaces Alejandro Peñuela Diaz Abstract . We establish curvature inequalities and rigidity results for surfaces satisfying constant mean curvature type conditions in both Riemannian and Lorentzian geometry. In the Riemannian setting we study constant mean curvature (CMC) surfaces in three-dimensional manifolds with scalar curvature bounds. Building on the Christodoulou–Yau inequality H 2 ≤ 16 π / | Σ | H^{2}\leq 16\pi/|\Sigma| (with H H the mean curvature and | Σ | |\Sigma| the area), we show that the associated rigidity phenomena persist under a weaker notion of stability controlling only the constant mode of the second variation, combined with an extrinsic curvature sign condition. This yields Euclidean rigidity without imposing intrinsic symmetry or near-roundness assumptions and extends to higher dimensions and to the hyperbolic and spherical settings. In the Lorentzian setting we consider spacetime constant mean curvature (STCMC) surfaces, a natural generalization of CMC surfaces. We introduce a stability theory for STCMC surfaces and prove the sharp inequality | H → | 2 ≤ 16 π / | Σ | |\vec{H}|^{2}\leq 16\pi/|\Sigma| under the dominant energy condition. We also obtain rigidity for the equality case: under suitable geometric assumptions the surface is intrinsically round and the spacetime region it bounds is flat, with maximal globally hyperbolic development isometric to a causal diamond in Minkowski spacetime. Finally, we show that the canonical asymptotic STCMC foliations known in both the spacelike and null settings have leaves that are stable with respect to this notion of stability. 1. Introduction and Results The study of constant mean curvature (CMC) surfaces as critical points of the area functional under a volume constraint is a central theme in differential geometry. Beyond their role as isoperimetric surfaces, stable CMC surfaces satisfy fundamental geometric inequalities that link the curvature of the ambient manifold to intrinsic properties of the surface. A landmark result in this direction was established by Christodoulou and Yau [ 11 ] , who proved that if (M,g) is a three-dimensional Riemannian manifold with nonnegative scalar curvature and \Sigma\subset M is a stable CMC surface, then (1) H^{2}\leq\frac{16\pi}{|\Sigma|}, where H denotes the mean curvature of \Sigma and |\Sigma| its area. Equality is attained by round spheres in Euclidean space. This naturally leads to the corresponding rigidity question: if equality holds, must the enclosed region be isometric to a Euclidean ball? Rigidity phenomena under scalar curvature lower bounds have been extensively studied in Riemannian geometry. In many cases, the theory of stable minimal and constant mean curvature hypersurfaces plays a central role, as the stability inequality relates ambient scalar curvature to intrinsic geometric quantities. For a general overview of such rigidity results and their geometric context, see the survey of Brendle [ 5 ] . In the specific setting of inequality ( 1 ), rigidity results have been obtained under additional geometric assumptions. In particular, Sun [ 36 ] showed that if a stable CMC sphere satisfies equality and is sufficiently close to being round, then the surface is isometric to a round sphere and the enclosed region is isometric to a Euclidean ball. These results demonstrate that equality in ( 1 ) encodes strong geometric information, though existing approaches rely on intrinsic near-roundness or symmetry assumptions [ 33 , 36 ] . Note that the inequality ( 1 ) was originally motivated by general relativity, as it ensures the nonnegativity of the Hawking quasi-local energy, while the equality case provides a rigidity statement for the Hawking quasi-local energy within totally geodesic hypersurfaces. The first goal of this paper is to refine and generalize these results. We show that Euclidean rigidity can be recovered under a purely extrinsic curvature sign condition combined with a weak stability hypothesis, namely, a condition controlling only the constant mode of the second variation, without imposing intrinsic symmetry or almost-roundness assumptions. Moreover, we establish corresponding rigidity results in the hyperbolic and spherical settings under appropriate scalar curvature bounds, as well as higher-dimensional analogues. In each case, the mechanism underlying rigidity is the interaction between curvature lower bounds and a sharp boundary inequality. The rigidity arguments ultimately rely on geometric rigidity theorems for manifolds with boundary, in particular the Brown–York mass rigidity theorem of Shi and Tam [ 34 ] and its extensions. We then turn to the Lorentzian setting, considering a four-dimensional Lorentzian manifold (\mathcal{M},g) satisfying the dominant energy condition. For a spacelike two-surface \Sigma\subset\mathcal{M} , the relevant curvature quantity is the squared norm of the mean curvature vector, |\vec{H}|^{2}=-\theta_{\ell}\theta_{k}, where \theta_{\ell} and \theta_{k} denote the null expansions of \Sigma . Surfaces with constant |\vec{H}| — known as spacetime constant mean curvature (STCMC) surfaces — provide a natural analogue of CMC surfaces in Riemannian geometry. While STCMC surfaces have appeared in several contexts in mathematical relativity, a stability theory for such surfaces has not previously been developed. In this paper, we introduce a natural notion of stability and show that it leads to a sharp curvature inequality (2) -\theta_{\ell}\theta_{k}=|\vec{H}|^{2}\leq\frac{16\pi}{|\Sigma|}. Moreover, we establish a rigidity theorem for the equality case: under a specific curvature sign condition (or an assumption of even symmetry or intrinsic near-roundness), the surface \Sigma is intrinsically round. Under the additional assumption that it bounds a spacelike region with no other boundary components, the enclosed region is flat, and its maximal globally hyperbolic development is isometric to a standard causal diamond in Minkowski spacetime. The proof of this rigidity statement builds on a theorem of Liu and Yau [ 19 , 20 ] , together with an analysis of the maximal globally hyperbolic development of the enclosed region. These results admit a natural interpretation in general relativity in terms of the Hawking quasi-local energy (or quasi-local mass) (3) \mathcal{E}(\Sigma)=\sqrt{\frac{|\Sigma|}{16\pi}}\left(1+\frac{1}{16\pi}\int_{\Sigma}\theta_{\ell}\theta_{k}\,d\mu\right). Inequality ( 2 ) is precisely equivalent to the nonnegativity of \mathcal{E}(\Sigma) under the dominant energy condition, and the equality case corresponds to rigidity when the Hawking energy vanishes. Beyond this energetic interpretation, spacetime constant mean curvature surfaces play an important role in the geometry of asymptotically flat spacetimes. In particular, it has been shown that asymptotically flat initial data sets admit a canonical foliation by STCMC surfaces near infinity [ 6 ] , which provides a geometric characterization of the center of mass of an isolated gravitational system. These foliations serve as a natural Lorentzian analogue of the classical constant mean curvature foliations [ 16 ] used to define the center of mass in the time-symmetric setting. More recently, STCMC foliations have also been constructed on asymptotically Schwarzschildean null hypersurfaces [ 17 ] . In the present work we show that the leaves of these known asymptotic STCMC foliations are stable with respect to the stability notion introduced here. Thus our results connect the positivity and rigidity properties of the Hawking energy with the geometric structure of asymptotically flat spacetimes, both in the spacelike and null settings. These applications also show that the stability theory developed here is realized by the natural STCMC surfaces arising in asymptotically flat geometry. More broadly, they illustrate the geometric meaning of the Lorentzian stability theory and place it in direct analogy with the classical Riemannian theory of stable CMC surfaces. The dominant energy condition plays in the Lorentzian setting