Diversity of Type Ia supernova optical light curves among different spectroscopic subclasses
Ryotaro B. koshi, Mamoru doi, Shigeyuki sako, Keiichi maeda, Masaomi tanaka, and Naohiro takanashi · 2026
Read Diversity of Type Ia supernova optical light curves among different spectroscopic subclasses by Ryotaro B. koshi, Mamoru doi, Shigeyuki sako, Keiichi maeda, Masaomi tanaka, and Naohiro takanashi (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2603-16466.txt.
Introduction
Koshi and co-authors compare light curves across Type Ia supernova subclasses. The Branch system sorts these explosions into four groups. Prior work focused near peak brightness, leaving late times unclear. The team built average light curves for 109 events. Curves run from before maximum into the late tail. The I-band shows the strongest diversity between groups. Secondary maximum timing tracks the stable iron share. Cool events fade with a distinct late slope, a handy diagnostic.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Ryotaro B. koshi, Mamoru doi, Shigeyuki sako, Keiichi maeda, Masaomi tanaka, and Naohiro takanashi |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 79051 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2603.16466
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Diversity of Type Ia supernova optical light curves among different spectroscopic subclasses Ryotaro B. koshi, Mamoru doi, Shigeyuki sako, Keiichi maeda, Masaomi tanaka, and Naohiro takanashi Abstract Attempts to reveal the spectroscopic diversity of Type Ia supernovae (SNe Ia) have led to subclassification schemes such as the Branch system, which classifies SNe Ia into four categories: core normal (CN), broad line (BL), cool (CL), and shallow silicon (SS). The physical origin of these spectroscopic differences, including progenitor channels, explosion mechanisms, or other parameters, however, remains unclear. Moreover, previous work has concentrated primarily on properties near peak luminosity, yielding limited insight into their behavior at later epochs. In this study, we compile U B V R I UBVRI photometry for 109 SNe Ia and construct the first set of average light curves for each Branch subgroup, spanning from pre-maximum through the late tail. We find pronounced diversity in the I I -band, especially in the timing of the secondary maximum across subgroups and in the late-time decline of CL events. After correcting for light curve stretch, which reflects the combined influence of 56 Ni and ejecta masses, we show that the secondary maximum is powered by Fe II recombination, and its timing is particularly sensitive to the amount of stable iron-group elements (IGEs) synthesized in the explosion. This implies an anti-correlation between the mass of stable IGEs and 56 Ni: CL (and possibly BL) events have a larger mass ratio of IGEs/ 56 Ni resulting in earlier secondary maxima, while SS events have a smaller ratio and thus later secondary maxima. This trend is naturally explained within the near- M Ch M_{\rm Ch} delayed-detonation scenario, whereas it is inconsistent with the positive correlation predicted by the sub- M Ch M_{\rm Ch} double-detonation scenario. Finally, we show that stretch-corrected late-time slopes provide a practical diagnostic for CL events, likely linked to an emission feature around 7,200 7,200 Å. 2025 \Received \Accepted \KeyWords supernovae: general — method: data analysis — surveys 1 Introduction Type Ia supernovae (SNe Ia) are thermonuclear explosions of carbon-oxygen white dwarfs (WDs) that exhibit a characteristic Si II absorption feature in their optical spectra at maximum light. SNe Ia are widely believed to arise from a mass-accreting white dwarf in a binary system, but the nature of the companion star remains uncertain. Two leading scenarios are considered today; in the single-degenerate scenario (e.g., [ 89 ] ; [ 52 ] ), a non-degenerate star transfers mass onto the WD until it ignites, whereas in the double-degenerate channel (e.g., [ 27 ] ; [ 87 ] ), the merger of two WDs triggers the explosion. Besides the progenitor problem, the explosion mechanism itself remains under debate and is an independent factor in understanding the nature of SNe Ia. In classical models, deflagration starts near the center of the WD when the density reaches \sim{10}^{9} {\rm g} {\rm cm}^{-3} and then shifts to detonation (delayed-detonation model; [ 90 ] ; [ 28 ] ; [ 75 ] ). However, an alternative model claims that detonation can occur at lower WD masses and densities, triggered by an initial detonation at the surface helium-rich layer (double-detonation model; [ 37 ] ; [ 76 ] ; [ 62 ] ). Recent multi-dimensional simulations have further highlighted that, in the delayed-detonation model, the relative strengths of deflagration and detonation are antagonistic: stronger initial deflagration leads to greater pre-expansion, which reduces the efficiency of the subsequent detonation and lowers the 56 Ni yield ( [ 38 ] ; [ 45 ] ; [ 40 ] ). In addition, enhanced burning at high densities during strong deflagration promotes electron captures, resulting in larger amounts of stable iron-group elements such as 58 Ni and 54 Fe ( [ 9 ] ). Note that the explosion mechanism is not uniquely determined by the progenitor channel; even with the companion identified, how ignition and detonation proceed remains uncertain (see [ 46 ] for a review). Connecting observations to theoretical models provides crucial constraints on both fronts, making the observed diversity of SNe Ia a central theme in current research. Studies of photometric diversity have long underpinned our understanding and standardization of SNe Ia. The stretch–magnitude relation is an empirical correlation between the stretch of the light curve (or in some studies, the decline rate) and peak absolute magnitude, showing that slowly declining SNe Ia are intrinsically brighter ( [ 59 ] ). Another correlation stands between the color at peak luminosity and the peak absolute magnitude; bluer SNe Ia appear more luminous ( [ 84 ] ). These relations both potentially illuminate underlying explosion physics, such as the mass of synthesized 56 Ni, and enable calibration of SN Ia luminosity, establishing their use in observational cosmology ( [ 66 ] ; [ 58 ] ). More recent cosmological analyses, such as the Pantheon and Pantheon+ samples, have confirmed and refined these relations using thousands of SNe Ia ( [ 73 ] ; [ 12 ] ). In addition to these photometric diagnostics, spectroscopic diversity also provides crucial insight. Branch et al. 2006 defined four subgroups of SNe Ia based on the pseudo-equivalent widths (pEWs) of the Si II \lambda 6355 and Si II \lambda 5972 absorption lines near maximum light: core normal (CN) events, which exhibit intermediate line strengths and represent the archetypal normal population; broad line (BL) SNe Ia, distinguished by strong Si II \lambda 6355 absorption and broader profiles indicative of higher ejecta velocities; cool (CL) SNe Ia, characterized by a high \lambda 5972/\lambda 6355 ratio and generally subluminous behavior (including the 1991bg-like class); and shallow silicon (SS) SNe Ia, in which both Si II lines are weak, corresponding predominantly to the overluminous 1991T-like/1999aa-like subclass (see figure 1 of Branch et al. 2009 for representative spectra of each subtype). Wang et al. 2013 divided spectroscopically normal SNe Ia into two subgroups based on the Si II \lambda 6355 velocity near maximum light: the normal velocity (NV; v\lesssim 11,800{\rm km}{\rm s}^{-1} ) and high velocity (HV; v\gtrsim 11,800{\rm km}{\rm s}^{-1} ) groups, which exhibit differences in color and host galaxy properties (see also Benetti et al. 2005 ). The Wang NV and HV groups vaguely overlap with the Branch CN and BL groups respectively. These subclassification schemes are not merely empirical. CN events are broadly consistent with the standard Chandrasekhar-mass delayed-detonation model ( Seitenzahl et al. 2013 ; Blondin et al. 2013 ), while BL/HV events are often interpreted as having more extended outer ejecta structures or stronger asymmetry, possibly linked to off-center ignition ( Mazzali et al. 2005 ; Stehle et al. 2005 ; Maeda et al. 2010a ) or the double-detonation model ( Ogawa et al. 2023 ). CL events point to reduced 56 Ni production and cooler ejecta ( Nugent et al. 1995 ; Taubenberger et al. 2008 ; Dhawan et al. 2017 ). SS events, on the other hand, are associated with more extended burning or strong mixing ( Ruiz-Lapuente et al. 1992 ; Sasdelli et al. 2014 ). Although no subtype can yet be tied to a unique progenitor channel or explosion mechanism, these patterns suggest that spectroscopic classifications carry physical significance, providing essential clues to the diversity of SNe