Uncertainty Relation for Entropy and Temperature of Gibbs States

Francis J. Headley · 2026

Read Uncertainty Relation for Entropy and Temperature of Gibbs States by Francis J. Headley (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2603-16456.txt.

Introduction

Headley derives the quantum Fisher information for estimating entropy in a Gibbs state. The value turns out to equal the inverse heat capacity. That pairs neatly with the known temperature information. Their product depends only on temperature, not on the Hamiltonian. This gives an uncertainty relation between entropy and temperature estimators. All system-specific terms cancel out. Energy measurement is the best route for entropy reads. The link ties to the Ruppeiner metric in entropy coordinates.

Catalog record

CREATORFrancis J. Headley
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE29217
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2603.16456

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Uncertainty Relation for Entropy and Temperature of Gibbs States Francis J. Headley Abstract We derive the quantum Fisher information for entropy estimation in a Gibbs state and show that F S = 1 / C v F_{S}=1/C_{\!v} , dual to the temperature Fisher information F T = C v / T 2 F_{T}=C_{\!v}/T^{2} . Their product F S ⋅ F T = 1 / T 2 F_{S}\cdot F_{T}=1/T^{2} is independent of the Hamiltonian, yielding the universal uncertainty relation Δ 2 ​ S ​ Δ 2 ​ T ≥ T 2 / n 2 \Delta^{2}S\,\Delta^{2}T\geq T^{2}/n^{2} in which all system-specific quantities such as heat capacity, the Hamiltonian, and the number of degrees of freedom cancel identically. This is the metrological expression of the Legendre conjugacy between S S and T T . We identify energy measurement as the optimal protocol for entropy estimation, analyse critical-point scaling where F S ∼ | t | α → 0 F_{S}\sim|t|^{\alpha}\to 0 , and connect F S F_{S} to the Ruppeiner metric in entropy coordinates. The uncertainty relation is shown to hold for all standard thermodynamic conjugate pairs, and we examine the distinguished role of the von Neumann entropy within the Rényi family. Generalisations to the grand canonical and generalised Gibbs ensembles are given. I Introduction The Legendre structure of thermodynamics pairs each intensive variable with a conjugate extensive one: temperature T with entropy S , pressure P with volume V , chemical potential \mu with particle number N . Among these, the pair (T,S) occupies a distinguished role. Temperature governs the statistical weight of microstates, p_{k}\propto e^{-E_{k}/T} , and temperature estimation from quantum measurements of thermal states has a well-developed metrological theory 2 ; 17 ; 4 ; 11 ; 6 . The quantum Fisher information (QFI) for temperature is F_{T}=C_{\!v}/T^{2} (we set k_{\mathrm{B}}=1 throughout), yielding the Cramér–Rao bound \mathrm{Var}(\hat{T})\geq T^{2}/(nC_{\!v}) . Yet the dual question, with what precision can entropy itself be inferred from quantum measurements, has not been addressed. This gap is notable, as entropy is a central quantity not only in theory but also in experiment, where its determination via thermodynamic integration 15 is a key tool in systems such as ultracold quantum gases and quantum dots 3 ; 7 . Maxwell relations also provide a complementary route to thermometry: high precision in temperature estimation occurs when the entropy changes rapidly with respect to a control parameter 13 , and the interplay between thermometric and entropic sensitivity in nanoelectronic devices has been explored through the Fisher information 14 . In this Letter we derive the QFI for entropy estimation, show that it is dual to the temperature QFI, and demonstrate that their product yields a universal uncertainty relation whose form is dictated entirely by the Legendre structure of thermodynamics. II Entropy Fisher information Consider n independent copies of a Gibbs state \rho(\beta)=e^{-\beta H}/Z at inverse temperature \beta=1/T . Because \rho(\beta) belongs to an exponential family, its eigenvalues p_{k}=e^{-\beta E_{k}}/Z are determined by \beta alone and the energy eigenbasis \{|k\rangle\} is \beta -independent. The QFI with respect to \beta is therefore purely classical 2 : F_{\beta}=\sum_{k}\frac{(\partial_{\beta}p_{k})^{2}}{p_{k}}=\mathrm{Var}(H)=\frac{C_{\!v}}{\beta^{2}}\,, (1) where C_{\!v}\equiv\beta^{2}\mathrm{Var}(H) is the heat capacity. The von Neumann entropy S=-\mathrm{Tr}(\rho\ln\rho)=\beta\langle H\rangle+\ln Z is a smooth, strictly monotone function of \beta ( dS/d\beta=-C_{\!v}/\beta<0 for any thermodynamically stable system with C_{\!v}>0 ). It therefore provides a valid reparametrisation of the one-dimensional Gibbs manifold, and the QFI transforms covariantly as F_{S}=\left(\frac{d\beta}{dS}\right)^{\!2}F_{\beta}=\frac{1}{C_{\!v}}\,. (2) The Cramér–Rao bound gives \mathrm{Var}(\hat{S})\geq\dfrac{1}{nF_{S}}=\dfrac{C_{\!v}}{n}. (3) This bound is saturated asymptotically by a projective energy measurement (see Appendix). Equation ( 2 ) indicates a duality: the heat capacity governs the precision of S - and T -estimation inversely. Having a large C_{\!v} allows for precise temperature estimation ( F_{T}\propto C_{\!v} ) as small temperature differences produce large, distinguishable shifts in the energy distribution. Conversely, large C_{\!v} makes entropy hard to estimate ( F_{S}\propto 1/C_{\!v} ) because many distinct entropy values map to nearly identical energy statistics. III Universal uncertainty relation The product of the two Fisher informations is F_{S}\cdot F_{T}=\frac{1}{C_{\!v}}\cdot\frac{C_{\!v}}{T^{2}}=\frac{1}{T^{2}}\,, (4) in which C_{\!v} cancels identically. Applying the Cramér–Rao bounds to both variables for n independent copies gives \Delta^{2}S\;\Delta^{2}T\;\geq\;\frac{T^{2}}{n^{2}}\,, (5) where \Delta^{2}X\equiv\mathrm{Var}(\hat{X}) denotes the variance of the estimator. The bound depends only on the temperature of the state; no system-specific quantity appears. It is tight when both estimators are constructed from energy measurements on n copies. Crucially, this bound is saturatable: because projective energy measurement simultaneously saturates both individual Cramér–Rao bounds, the product \Delta^{2}S\,\Delta^{2}T=T^{2}/n^{2} is achievable, distinguishing Eq. ( 5 ) from a generic (and potentially vacuous) product of independent lower bounds. Equation ( 5 ) is the metrological signature of thermodynamic conjugacy : for any pair of Legendre-conjugate variables, an analogous relation holds in which all response functions cancel. The relation is structurally parallel to the Heisenberg uncertainty principle \Delta q\,\Delta p\geq\hbar/2 , with T/n playing the role of \hbar/2 . The analogy is suggestive but imperfect: the Heisenberg relation is state-independent and follows from the canonical commutation relation, whereas Eq. ( 5 ) is statistical ( \propto 1/n^{2} ) and restricted to Gibbs states. What distinguishes it from a generic product of Cramér–Rao bounds is the complete cancellation of all system-specific quantities. IV Two-level system For a two-level system with energy gap \Delta , the heat capacity is C_{\!v}=(\beta\Delta)^{2}e^{\beta\Delta}/(1+e^{\beta\Delta})^{2} , giving F_{S}=\frac{(1+e^{\beta\Delta})^{2}}{(\beta\Delta)^{2}\,e^{\beta\Delta}}\,. (6) At high temperature ( \beta\Delta\to 0 ), C_{\!v}\to 0 and F_{S}\to\infty : the state approaches the maximally mixed state ( S=\ln 2 ), which is sharply localised in entropy space. At low temperature ( \beta\Delta\to\infty ), C_{\!v}\to 0 exponentially and F_{S}\to\infty again: the nearly pure ground state has entropy close to zero and is equally well localised. The minimum of F_{S} —the point of greatest difficulty for entropy estimation—occurs at intermediate temperature where C_{\!v} is largest. At every temperature, F_{S}\cdot F_{T}=1/T^{2} holds exactly. Figure 1 : Fisher information for entropy and temperature estimation in (a) a two-level system with energy gap \Delta and (b) a quantum harmonic oscillator with frequency \omega . Solid curves show F_{S}=1/C_{\!v} (blue) and F_{T}=C_{\!v}/T^{2} (red); the dashed curve is their product F_{S}\cdot F_{T}=1/T^{2} . V Quantum harmonic oscillator For a quantum harmonic oscillator at frequency \omega , the heat capacity is C_{\!v}=\frac{(\beta\hbar\omega)^{2}\,e^{\beta\hbar\omega}}{(e^{\beta\hbar\omega}-1)^{2}}\,, (7) so F_{S}=(e^{\beta\hbar\omega}-1)^{2}/[(\beta\hbar\omega)^{2}\,e^{\beta\hbar\omega}] . Unlike the two-level system, C_{\!v} is monotonically increasing: the spectrum is unbounded and there is no Schottky anomaly, so the metrological structure is qualitatively different. As T increases, entropy estimation steadily approaches a constant while temperature estimation steadily worsens. The condition F_{S}=F_{T} reduces to C_{\!v}=T , which has two solutions: T_{1}\approx 0.22\,\hbar\omega and T_{2}\approx 0.90\,\hbar\omega . Below ( T\ll T_{1} ), the nearly pure ground state is sharply localised in entropy space and F_{S} dominates; The regime ( T_{1}<T<T_{2} ), F_{T}>F_{S} , favours thermometry over entropy estimation. In the classical regime ( T\gg T_{2} ), equipartition sets in and the two informations assume their classical asymptotic values. In the classical limit, a system of f quadratic degrees of freedom has C_{\!v}\to f/2 , yielding: F_{S}\;\to\;\frac{2}{f}\,,\qquad F_{T}\;\to\;\frac{f}{2T^{2}}\,. (8) Each additional degree of freedom dilutes the per-copy information about entropy, making S harder to estimate: the energy distribution broadens as \mathrm{Var}(H)=fT^{2}/2 , so a wider range of entropy values produces statistically similar measurements. The approach to this classical floor is not

Read the complete text