Looking down the rabbit hole: Towards quantum optimal estimation of surface roughness

Quentin Muller, Tommaso Tufarelli, Mădălin Guţă, Katherine Inzani, Samanta Piano, Gerardo Adesso · 2026

Read Looking down the rabbit hole: Towards quantum optimal estimation of surface roughness by Quentin Muller, Tommaso Tufarelli, Mădălin Guţă, Katherine Inzani, Samanta Piano, Gerardo Adesso (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2603-16418.txt.

Introduction

Muller and co-authors find quantum limits for measuring surface roughness. Roughness matters across engineering and precision manufacturing. They use passive linear optics with quantum estimation methods. The team derives top precision bounds for spatial moments of point sources. Sources sit below the diffraction scale in three dimensions. For the height profile, moment information is capped by a constant. A mode-sorting imaging method reaches the bound for roughness. Classical imaging cannot.

Catalog record

CREATORQuentin Muller, Tommaso Tufarelli, Mădălin Guţă, Katherine Inzani, Samanta Piano, Gerardo Adesso
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE75093
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2603.16418

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Looking down the rabbit hole: Towards quantum optimal estimation of surface roughness Quentin Muller, Tommaso Tufarelli, Mădălin Guţă, Katherine Inzani, Samanta Piano, Gerardo Adesso Abstract Surface roughness is an important quantity to many engineering and precision manufacturing disciplines. In this paper we investigate the problem of estimating the root-mean-square roughness of a sample by passive linear optical methods. By adopting quantum parameter estimation techniques, we determine the ultimate precision limits on roughness estimation. In particular, we show that the information on the first moment (mean height) and standard deviation (roughness) of the axial profile distribution of multiple incoherent point sources is bounded by a constant. While classical imaging techniques fail to achieve this bound, a quantum inspired imaging technique based on spatial mode demultiplexing is proven to be optimal for estimating the axial standard deviation. Combined with analogous recently investigated methods for estimating radial profiles, this can provide a powerful technique for measuring roughness of nearly smooth surface patches beyond the diffraction limit. I Introduction Surface roughness plays a central role in diverse scientific and industrial contexts. In precision manufacturing, surface finish directly affects mechanical performance, wear, and lubrication properties 3 . In aerospace and automotive engineering, surface roughness influences friction, drag, and fatigue life 22 . In optics and photonics, nanometre-scale roughness of mirrors, gratings, or coatings determines scattering losses and limits device performance 7 . In semiconductor fabrication and nanotechnology, roughness control is critical for layer deposition and pattern transfer 36 . Roughness is also a critical quality metric in additive manufacturing and precision metrology, where it impacts dimensional tolerances and functional compliance 14 . Given this broad relevance, accurate measurement and characterization of surface roughness—and understanding the fundamental limits of such estimation—are of great fundamental and applied interest. Rough surfaces can be thought of as “miniature mountain ranges,” with peaks and troughs forming a height distribution over the surface. A variety of metrics exist to characterize roughness 12 , but in this work we focus on the root-mean-square height variation (the standard deviation of the surface height profile). We denote this roughness parameter by \sigma , the square root of the second central moment of the height distribution: \sigma=\sqrt{\theta_{2}-\theta_{1}^{2}}\,, (1) where \theta_{j}=\int z^{j}dF(z) (2) is the j^{\text{th}} moment of the height distribution F(z) ; in particular, \theta_{1} is the mean height and \sigma^{2}=\theta_{2}-\theta_{1}^{2} is the variance of the surface height profile. Figure 1 : A schematic displaying the focusing of a small profile of a rough surface through a lens. The image of the rough surface can then be attained via different measurement schemes. Techniques for measuring the surface roughness can be separated into contact and non-contact methods 1 . A common contact technique is the use of a stylus profilometer — a diamond tipped stylus that is dragged across a rough surface to produce a varying voltage proportional to the height of the surface contour. However, such a contact technique may damage the surface and only yields 1D information. As such, we turn our attention instead to non-contact imaging using optical sensors. In such an attempt to estimate the surface distribution, coherent light, usually in the form of a monochromatic plane wave 15 , is made incident upon the landscape, and the reflected light is then analyzed. However, as the surface roughness becomes smaller and the relative heights and radial displacements of the peaks and troughs dip below the Rayleigh limit 19 , diffraction effects resulting from the focusing of the emitted light through some aperture or lens take place, leading to loss of information at the image plane. It becomes therefore an interesting metrological problem to devise more efficient ways of passively collecting and processing light emitted from rough surfaces in the sub-diffraction limit, in order to improve both the angular and axial resolution for reconstructing relevant surface parameters. Here we address this problem using methods from quantum metrology . Our analysis is inspired by the recent body of work that reformulated the task of resolving spatially displaced point sources as a quantum parameter estimation problem 24 ; 25 ; 20 ; 2 ; 26 ; 16 ; 8 . These groundbreaking papers not only surpassed the centuries-old Rayleigh limit through a quantum-inspired measurement technique known as spatial mode demultiplexing (SPADE), but also placed the notion of resolution on a more rigorous footing by connecting it to the minimum achievable error in estimating the defining parameters of a source distribution; namely, the geometric moments. Much of the work carried out since in this realm has used either radially distributed light sources 27 (i.e., displaced within a plane parallel to the image plane) or at most two point sources distributed axially 16 ; 35 (i.e., displaced along a line perpendicular to the image plane). In this paper we expand on the previously considered cases by treating the problem of an arbitrary number of discrete axially distributed point sources: an optical “rabbit hole”. We consider this problem of utmost importance in our journey towards characterizing uncertainty in estimating light sources distributed both axially and radially as in a complete discretized surface profile. In particular, complementing existing results for moments estimation in radial source distributions 34 ; 25 ; 28 , here we compute the ultimate limits on the information available in estimating the first moment — mean height — and (square root of) the second central moment — roughness — of an axial distribution of incoherent point sources. We find that classical direct imaging techniques fail to reach these limits, and we show the quantum-inspired measurement technique SPADE (specifically decomposing output modes in the Laguerre-Gauss basis) to be optimal in fulfilling the considered estimation problem. This paper is partitioned into five sections. In Section II we give an overview of relevant quantum metrology methods followed by a brief explanation of quantum imaging theory along with a description of the theoretical model used in this analysis. In Section III we present our derivation of the fundamental bound on the information available for the estimation of root-mean-square roughness. In Section IV we show the failure of classical direct imaging techniques to reach this bound as opposed to the success of SPADE measurements to achieve optimality for the task of roughness estimation. Finally we discuss our results and future outlook in Section V . II Theoretical background II.1 Quantum Metrology Theory For clarity we divide this subsection into two parts: the first part reviews the theory of quantum estimation for finite-dimensional parameters while the second part deals with the the semi-parametric formalism 29 ; 23 ; 28 . The latter becomes useful for problems involving a very high-dimensional (and potentially infinite-dimensional) space of parameters. II.1.1 Quantum parameter estimation and the Fisher information Quantum estimation deals with the following problem: given a quantum system whose state \rho_{\bm{\lambda}} depends smoothly on an unknown parameter set \bm{\lambda}=(\lambda_{1},\ldots,\lambda_{n})^{T}\in\Lambda\subset\mathbb{R}^{n} , the task is to estimate the parameters by measuring the system 17 . Since different measurements may be mutually incompatible and convey different information about the parameters, the key questions are which measurements are more suitable for estimating \bm{\lambda} and what is the optimal estimation precision. A measurement is described by a positive operator-valued measure (POVM) \{\Pi_{\omega}\}_{\omega\in\Omega} , where each \Pi_{\omega} is a positive semidefinite

Read the complete text