Open vs. Sealed: Auction Format Choice for Maximal Extractable Value
Aleksei Adadurov, Sergey Barseghyan, Anton Chtepine, Antero Eloranta, Andrei Sebyakin, Arsenii Valitov · 2026
Read Open vs. Sealed: Auction Format Choice for Maximal Extractable Value by Aleksei Adadurov, Sergey Barseghyan, Anton Chtepine, Antero Eloranta, Andrei Sebyakin, Arsenii Valitov (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2603-16333.txt.
Introduction
Adadurov and co-authors study auction formats for maximal extractable value on Ethereum. Their data cover 2.2 million transactions from three orderflow providers. Extracted values follow a log-normal shape with a heavy right tail. Searcher valuations are affiliated, which breaks revenue equivalence. The team models that link with a Gaussian common factor. They derive bidding and revenue for five auction formats. Open and second-price formats beat Dutch and first-price ones. The gap cost an estimated 10 to 18 million dollars.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Aleksei Adadurov, Sergey Barseghyan, Anton Chtepine, Antero Eloranta, Andrei Sebyakin, Arsenii Valitov |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 86604 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2603.16333
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Open vs. Sealed: Auction Format Choice for Maximal Extractable Value Aleksei Adadurov, Sergey Barseghyan, Anton Chtepine, Antero Eloranta, Andrei Sebyakin, Arsenii Valitov Abstract We study optimal auction design for Maximum Extractable Value (MEV) auction markets on Ethereum. Using a dataset of 2.2 million transactions across three major orderflow providers, we establish three empirical regularities: extracted values follow a log-normal distribution with extreme right-tail concentration, competition intensity varies substantially across MEV types, and the standard Revenue Equivalence Theorem breaks down due to affiliation among searchers’ valuations. We model this affiliation through a Gaussian common factor, deriving equilibrium bidding strategies and expected revenues for five auction formats, first-price sealed-bid, second-price sealed-bid, English, Dutch, and all-pay, across a fine grid of bidder counts n n and affiliation parameters ρ \rho . Our simulations confirm the Milgrom-Weber linkage principle: English and second-price sealed-bid auctions strictly dominate Dutch and first-price sealed-bid formats for any ρ > 0 \rho>0 , with a linkage gap of 14-28% at moderate affiliation ( ρ = 0.5 \rho=0.5 ) and up to 30% for small bidder counts. Applied to observed bribe totals, this gap corresponds to $10-18 million in foregone revenue over the sample period. We also document a novel non-monotonicity: at large n n and high ρ \rho , revenue peaks in the interior of the affiliation parameter space and declines thereafter, as near-perfect correlation collapses the order-statistic spread that drives competitive payments. I Introduction Block builders auction tens of millions of dollars worth of Maximum Extractable Value opportunities to competing searchers each year in the Ethereum ecosystem. These auctions determine how the surplus from transaction ordering is divided between searchers, who identify and execute profitable strategies, and orderflow providers, who control access to transaction flow. Despite the economic magnitude of these markets, relatively little attention has been paid to the question of mechanism optimality: which auction format should a block builder use to maximize their own revenue? This question is non-trivial for several reasons. First, standard auction theory treats valuation distributions as a background parameter, but the shape of that distribution turns out to matter enormously here. Our empirical analysis shows that MEV valuations follow a log-normal distribution, where the top 1% of transactions generate 68% of all revenue. When value is this concentrated in the right tail, mechanism choice for high-value transactions dominates overall revenue performance, and formats that differ only in their handling of typical transactions may diverge sharply on the rare events that matter most. Second, competition is highly heterogeneous across MEV types. Sandwich attacks, which exploit publicly observable mempool information, attract intense competition and exhibit average bribe percentages above 95% indicating that searchers bid away nearly all of their surplus. By contrast, naked arbitrage and liquidations attract fewer searchers, with correspondingly lower bribe ratios. A single auction format optimized for one competitive regime will generally be suboptimal in another, suggesting that mechanism design for MEV markets should be segmented rather than uniform. Third, standard revenue equivalence arguments break down in this environment. The Revenue Equivalence Theorem establishes that all standard auction formats yield identical expected revenue when bidders hold independent private values, are symmetric and risk-neutral, and the object is allocated to the highest-value bidder. But MEV valuations are plausibly affiliated: if market conditions make a cross-DEX arbitrage opportunity valuable to one searcher, they tend to make it valuable to others, since all searchers observe the same on-chain state and off-chain price signals. Under affiliation, the linkage principle of Milgrom and Weber (1982) milgrom1982 predicts a strict revenue ranking: formats with truthful bidding (English and second-price sealed-bid) outperform formats with strategic bid shading (first-price sealed-bid and Dutch). We address these questions through a combination of empirical analysis, equilibrium theory, and numerical simulation. Using a dataset of 2.2 million transactions, documenting MEV extraction across Blink, Merkle, and MEV Blocker, we first establish the empirical regularities that motivate our theoretical framework. We then derive equilibrium bidding strategies and expected revenues for five auction formats under log-normal valuations, using the Gaussian copula construction to model affiliation. Finally, we simulate revenue outcomes across a fine grid of bidder counts and affiliation levels and compare counterfactual revenues for each format using the empirical transaction data. Our main findings are as follows. Under an independent private values setting, all five formats satisfy revenue equivalence, consistent with theory and confirmed by our Monte Carlo verification. Under affiliation, a clear ranking emerges: English and SPSB auctions dominate Dutch and FPSB auctions, which in turn dominate the all-pay format. At the baseline affiliation level of \rho=0.5 with n=5 bidders, English and SPSB auctions yield revenues 17% higher than Dutch and FPSB formats, and the all-pay mechanism falls 41% below the FPSB baseline. Applied to the empirical transaction data, these differences translate to substantial sums: switching from a first-price to second-price or English format would have increased auctioneers’ revenues by between 3.3% and 32.0%, though the magnitude is sensitive to the assumed affiliation parameter and the number of bidders. We also document a novel non-monotonicity: at high affiliation and large bidder counts, revenue peaks in the interior of the affiliation parameter space and then declines as near-perfect correlation collapses the order-statistic spread that drives competitive payments. The remainder of the paper proceeds as follows. Section 2 reviews relevant auction theory and the existing literature on MEV auction mechanisms. Section 3 describes the data and documents the empirical regularities. Section 4 develops the theoretical framework and derives equilibrium characterizations for each auction format. Section 5 reports the numerical results and robustness checks. Section 6 concludes the paper. II Auction Theory and Related Work II.1 Auction Theory and Mechanism Design Auctions serve as a fundamental mechanism for price discovery across diverse markets, from government bonds and online advertising placements to construction contracts and airport landing slots. By eliciting competitive bids from participants with private valuations, auctions reveal willingness-to-pay and facilitate efficient allocation of scarce resources mcafee1987 . Different auction formats such as English (or, ascending), Dutch (or, descending), first-price sealed-bid, second-price sealed-bid (or, Vickrey), and all-pay each possess distinct properties that make them suited to particular market contexts klemperer2004 . The choice of auction design influences bidding behavior, revenue outcomes, allocative efficiency, and fairness, depending on factors such as the number of participants, information asymmetries, and the nature of the good being traded milgrom2004 . Each auction format presents a distinct tradeoff in terms of efficiency, revenue generation, and strategic complexity. English auctions promote price discovery through transparent, sequential bidding, allowing participants to observe competitors’ valuations and adjust strategies accordingly; however, this transparency can facilitate collusion and may disadvantage bidders with slower information processing or execution capabilities klemperer2004 ; mcafee1987 . Dutch auctions offer speed and simplicity, concluding as soon as any bidder accepts the current price, but they provide limited price discovery and may result in suboptimal outcomes when bidders face uncertainty about asset value or competitor valuations krishna2009 . Vickrey auctions are theoretically optimal in encouraging truthful bidding, since participants pay the second-highest bid rather than their own, thereby simplifying strategy and promoting allocative efficiency vickrey1961 ; myerson1981 ; however, they are vulnerable to manipulation through rigged bidding, require strong trust in the auctioneer’s execution, and are therefore rarely used in high-stakes settings ausubel2006