Human/AI Collective Intelligence for Deliberative Democracy: A Human-Centred Design Approach

Anna De Liddo*, https://orcid.org/0000-0003-0301-1154, Lucas Anastasiou, https://orcid.org/0000-0002-1587-5104, Simon Buckingham Shum ∗ , https://orcid.org/0000-0002-6334-7429 · 2026

Read Human/AI Collective Intelligence for Deliberative Democracy: A Human-Centred Design Approach by Anna De Liddo*, https://orcid.org/0000-0003-0301-1154, Lucas Anastasiou, https://orcid.org/0000-0002-1587-5104, Simon Buckingham Shum ∗ , https://orcid.org/0000-0002-6334-7429 (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2603-16260.txt.

Introduction

De Liddo, Anastasiou, and Shum present a design approach for AI in democratic debate. Their concept, Collective Intelligence for Deliberative Democracy, frames such tools as systems that boost group intelligence. They argue the design must stay human-centred. Their co-design method finds key challenges and shapes user scenarios. Two real cases show civic groups' needs built with AI support. Both were piloted in live settings.

Catalog record

CREATORAnna De Liddo*, https://orcid.org/0000-0003-0301-1154, Lucas Anastasiou, https://orcid.org/0000-0002-1587-5104, Simon Buckingham Shum ∗ , https://orcid.org/0000-0002-6334-7429
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE57352
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2603.16260

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Human/AI Collective Intelligence for Deliberative Democracy: A Human-Centred Design Approach Anna De Liddo*, https://orcid.org/0000-0003-0301-1154, Lucas Anastasiou, https://orcid.org/0000-0002-1587-5104, Simon Buckingham Shum ∗ , https://orcid.org/0000-0002-6334-7429 Abstract This chapter introduces the concept of Collective Intelligence for Deliberative Democracy (CI4DD). We propose that the use of computational tools, specifically artificial intelligence to advance deliberative democracy, is an instantiation of a broader class of human-computer system designed to augment collective intelligence. Further, we argue for a fundamentally human-centred design approach to orchestrate how stakeholders can contribute meaningfully to shaping the artifacts and processes needed to create trustworthy DD processes. We first contextualise the key concepts of CI and the role of AI within it. We then detail our co-design methodology for identifying key challenges, refining user scenarios, and deriving technical implications. Two exemplar cases illustrate how user requirements from civic organisations were implemented with AI support and piloted in authentic contexts. 1 1 footnotetext: ∗ Corresponding author: Anna De Liddo, Knowledge Media Institute, The Open University, Milton Keynes, UK, E-mail: [email protected] Keywords : Deliberative Democracy, Collective Intelligence, Human-AI Collaboration, Human-Centred Design, Civic Technology 1 Introduction As we write this chapter in the final quarter of 2025, this tumultuous year has made all of us acutely aware of the fragility of democratic systems and the international rule of law. When we add to this the relentless breach of our planetary boundaries [ 42 ] , biodiversity collapse, the continued after-effects of the Covid-19 pandemic, and numerous other mutually interacting, degrading global systems, we do indeed appear to be wrestling with a “global polycrisis”, defined by Lawrence, et al. [ 34 ] as, “the causal entanglement of crises in multiple global systems in ways that significantly degrade humanity’s prospects” . Inserting itself into all of these systems is the explosive arrival of generative artificial intelligence, adding additional stressors: aggravating disinformation [ 16 ] , disrupting education [ 30 ] and employment [ 23 ] , sparking debate on intellectual property law [ 10 ] , natural resource impacts [ 41 , 3 ] , and precarious labour conditions for model training [ 24 ] . Fully recognising that, like all technology, AI confronts us with ethical compromises and dilemmas, we remain equally intrigued by the extraordinary opportunities it opens up to “augment human intellect”, to use the prescient 1960s language of Douglas Engelbart [ 19 ] . In a time when democracy is challenged by the polycrisis, we are curious to understand and harness the affordances of AI, just as it holds significant potential to augment strategic planning [ 17 ] and learning amidst the polycrisis [ 7 ] . Consequently, in this chapter we advocate for the responsible use of AI to advance deliberative democracy (DD). Furthermore, we see this as an instance of the broader class of human-computer systems designed to augment collective intelligence (CI), with hybrid forms of human/AI CI now emerging. If this holds, it follows that DD research and practice can both learn from CI, and contribute back to it. Further, we argue for a fundamentally human-centred design (HCD) approach to orchestrate how stakeholders can contribute meaningfully to shaping the artifacts and processes needed to create a trustworthy DD process. To achieve this, the paper presents a structured co-design process for developing AI tools that enhance democratic deliberation processes. In the context of a European project involving diverse DD organisations, we detail a collaborative scenario development process through four phases — Contextualization, Community Challenges, Scenario Co-creation and Validation . From this we identified key “Points of Struggle” in existing deliberative practices, and translated user aspirations into technically feasible system requirements. Our methodology bridges the gap between theoretical AI capabilities and practical deliberative needs, adhering to the principle of augmenting rather than replacing human capabilities. We demonstrate how this approach leads to contextually relevant, user-centric AI solutions that address real-world challenges in citizen participation, collective understanding, transparency, and scalability of deliberative processes. The chapter first contextualises the key concepts of CI and the role of AI within it (Sec. 2 ). We then detail our HCD methodology and its outcomes, including key challenges and a catalogue of system requirements (Sec. 3 ). Subsequently, we present two exemplar cases of how these requirements can be implemented: BCause (Sec. 4 ) and DemocraticReflection (Sec. 5 ). We conclude by summarising how these exemplars address the challenge of designing hybrid collective intelligence for deliberative democracy (Sec. 6 ). 2 CI, AI and DD Fields as diverse and intersecting as organisation science, cognitive science, computer science and neuroscience are converging on the importance of Collective Intelligence (CI), ranging in scale from small teams to companies, and to global networks [ 35 ] . In the editorial to the inaugural edition of CI Journal, Flack et al. [ 20 ] introduce CI as follows: We can find collective intelligence in any system in which entities collectively, but not necessarily cooperatively, act in ways that seem intelligent. Often—but not always—the group’s intelligence is greater than the intelligence of individual entities in the collective. Central to the concept of CI is the premise that intelligence cannot be restricted to what happens in an individual brain, but rather, intelligence (including cognition and memory) is distributed socially across agents and materially across artifacts, both physical and computational [ 28 , 36 ] . Consequently, CI considers more than the collective ability of people’s minds, with online platforms making new forms of discourse and coordination possible [ 26 , 15 , 46 , 48 ] . AI adds machine actors to the network, with human-agent teaming research clarifying the conditions under which people come to trust AI agents as members of the team [ 37 , 43 ] . The explosive arrival of large language models (LLMs), particularly their integration with a conversational user interface (marked most saliently by ChatGPT’s launch in Nov. 2022) is the most recent advance, opening new possibilities for human-computer creativity [ 27 ] , CI more broadly [ 8 ] and “extended minds” [ 11 ] . Whilst there are distinctive features of DD that do not necessarily hold in other contexts (e.g., the particular kinds of stakeholders, or the common need for policy outcomes), we propose that CI concepts are helpful in framing the challenge of convening trustworthy, computer-supported, DD processes. For instance, in a detailed survey of CI online platforms, Suran et al. [ 46 ] taxonomise approaches in terms of the individuals they bring together (including their motivation, diversity, critical mass), through coordination/collaboration activities (including the scope for emergence, trust, task allocation), enabled by different forms of online communication (including user roles, knowledge aggregation, decentralisation). Their survey includes a range of democracy-enhancing, citizen-centric cases within this framework [ 21 , 29 , 33 ] . Our previous research has proposed that complex sociotechnical problems need a specific type of discourse-centric CI, which we termed Contested Collective Intelligence (CCI) [ 15 ] . Divergence in opinion is intrinsic to the predicament, and computational support assists in making sense of this. The nature of the CCI design challenge has been characterised as a spectrum of “pain points” that may be addressed by different forms of deliberation analytics [ 45 ] . CCI deliberation platforms have been piloted

Read the complete text