An Energetic Constraint for Qubit-Qubit Entanglement

Kiarn T. Laverick, Samyak P. Prasad, Pascale Senellart, Maria Maffei, Alexia Auffèves · 2026

Read An Energetic Constraint for Qubit-Qubit Entanglement by Kiarn T. Laverick, Samyak P. Prasad, Pascale Senellart, Maria Maffei, Alexia Auffèves (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2603-16225.txt.

Introduction

Laverick and co-authors link qubit entanglement to energy. Each qubit's internal energy splits into coherent and incoherent parts. For a pure, separable pair, the coherent parts are at their peak. As entanglement grows under energy-preserving local steps, coherent energy falls. That drop, the coherent energy deficit, matches a known entanglement measure. For mixed states, the deficit splits into quantum and classical parts.

Catalog record

CREATORKiarn T. Laverick, Samyak P. Prasad, Pascale Senellart, Maria Maffei, Alexia Auffèves
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE23663
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2603.16225

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

An Energetic Constraint for Qubit-Qubit Entanglement Kiarn T. Laverick, Samyak P. Prasad, Pascale Senellart, Maria Maffei, Alexia Auffèves Abstract We analyze qubit-qubit entanglement from an energetic perspective and reveal an energetic trade-off between quantum coherence and entanglement. We decompose each qubit internal energy into a coherent and an incoherent component. The qubits’ coherent energies are maximal if the qubit-qubit state is pure and separable. They decrease as qubit-qubit entanglement builds up under locally-energy-preserving processes. This yields a “coherent energy deficit” that we show is proportional to a well-known measure of entanglement, the square concurrence. In general, a qubit-qubit state can always be represented as a mixture of pure states. Then, the coherent energy deficit splits into a quantum component, corresponding to the average square concurrence of the pure states, and a classical one reflecting the mixedness of the joint state. Minimizing the quantum deficit over the possible pure state decompositions yields the square concurrence of the mixture. Our findings bring out new figures of merit to optimize and secure entanglement generation and distribution under energetic constraints. Introduction. —Entanglement is a key resource for quantum technologies. The question of its fundamental energy cost has been explored from multiple perspectives, from its creation Huber et al. 2015 ; Galve and Lutz 2009 and distillation Das et al. 2017 , to its extraction Bény et al. 2018 ; Hackl and Jonsson 2019 , and distribution Horodecki et al. 2025 . Conversely, entanglement generation has been optimized under fixed energy constraint Chiribella and Yang 2017 ; de Oliveira Junior et al. 2024 . In this paper, we bring a new conceptual tool to this research line: we introduce a structure to qubits’ internal energies and explore the impact of qubit-qubit entanglement on this structure. Up to its transition frequency, a qubit’s internal energy is equal to the population of its excited state. Thus, it can always be analyzed in terms of a coherent and an incoherent part, the former (the latter) stemming from its average dipole (its dipole fluctuations) Cohen-Tannoudji et al. 2024 . When the qubit is defined by zero and one-photon Fock states of a bosonic mode Pan et al. 2012 ; Mohanty et al. 2017 ; Wein et al. 2022 , this splitting captures the mean field’s and field’s fluctuations energy, respectively. This structure was inspired by recent analyses of qubit-light energy exchanges, showing that work (heat) exchanges only act on the coherent (incoherent) energy component Monsel et al. 2020 ; Maffei et al. 2021 ; Maillette de Buy Wenniger et al. 2023 ; Prasad et al. 2024 ; Schrauwen et al. 2025 . When a qubit is in a mixed state, or is entangled with another one, it contains less coherent energy than if it were in the pure state containing the same internal energy. We dub this difference a “coherent energy deficit”. We first show that, for pure qubit-qubit states, the coherent energy deficit is proportional to the square concurrence. This energetic measure of entanglement yields a quantitative energetic trade-off between quantum coherence and entanglement. Extending our framework to mixed qubit-qubit states splits the deficit into a quantum and a classical component respectively accounting for the entanglement and the mixedness of the state. Finally, we show, with a concrete example, that such energetic structure can be exploited to secure a protocol of entanglement distribution. Figure 1: The energetic splitting into coherent and incoherent components for a qubit with mean energy E . An illustration of the coherent energy (blue-solid line); it is always less than the maximum (nominal) value (black-dashed line) due to decoherence. The difference between these two lines is the coherent energy deficit {\cal D} (See main text). Energetics of a qubit state. —Let us consider a general qubit state \rho=(1-E)|{0}\rangle\langle{0}|+\sqrt{E(1-E)}(\epsilon^{*}|{0}\rangle\langle{1}|+\epsilon|{1}\rangle\langle{0}|)+E|{1}\rangle\langle{1}| . |\epsilon| relates to the purity of the state, |\epsilon|=1 corresponding to a pure state and |\epsilon|=0 to a mixture. If |{1(0)}\rangle is defined by (zero) photon(s) in a bosonic mode, be it frequency, temporal or spatial, the qubit’s internal energy reads (in photon units) \langle{a^{\dagger}a}\rangle=E , where a ( a^{\dagger} ) is the annihilation (creation) operator for the mode. While we shall use this notation from now on, note that our results extend to any qubit system by replacing the mode operator a by the qubit operator \hat{\sigma}_{-} . Applying a mean-field decomposition a=\langle{a}\rangle+\delta a splits the internal energy into two components, E=E_{\cal C}+E_{\cal I} , with E_{\cal C}=|\langle{a}\rangle|^{2} and E_{\cal I}=\langle{\delta a^{\dagger}\delta a}\rangle . We refer to E_{\cal C} ( E_{\cal I} ) as the coherent energy (the incoherent energy ) 1 1 1 The term ‘coherent’ can be motivated from the resource theory of coherence Streltsov et al. 2017 as {\cal C}[\rho]=|\langle{a}\rangle| , for a qubit, is a valid measure of coherence in the energy basis, with |\langle{a}\rangle|^{2}={\cal C}^{2} being its associated energy. See SM for details . This splitting is operational; the total (the coherent) energy can be accessed through photon detection (-dyne detection). For the general qubit state \rho defined above, the coherent energy reads E_{\cal C}=E(1-E)|\epsilon|^{2} . For a fixed internal energy E , E_{\cal C} is maximal when the state is pure, reaching \overline{E}_{\cal C}=E(1-E) , and \overline{E}_{\cal I}=E^{2} is minimal. We dub \overline{E}_{\cal C} and \overline{E}_{\cal I} the nominal coherent and incoherent energies, respectively, which correspond to the reference pure state |{\overline{\psi}}\rangle=\sqrt{1-E}|{0}\rangle+\sqrt{E}e^{i\phi}|{1}\rangle , where \phi=\arg(\epsilon) . Finally, we define the coherent energy deficit {\cal D} as {\cal D}=\overline{E}_{\cal C}-E_{\cal C}=(1-|\epsilon|^{2})\overline{E}_{\cal C}\,. (1) {\cal D} captures a measurable, energy-based witness of the qubit decoherence and is a key quantity of our analysis. This subdivision is depicted in Fig. 1 , where the various energies are plotted as a function of the qubit’s energy E . E=1/2 corresponds to the maximal energy uncertainty, yielding the maximal amount of nominal coherent energy \overline{E}_{\cal C} . \overline{E}_{\cal C} always remains lower than the mean energy E because of the fundamental phase fluctuations affecting the dipole. Under complete decoherence ( \epsilon=0 ), the coherent energy deficit is maximal and equals the nominal coherent energy. Energetics of pure qubit-qubit states. —We now consider a pure two-qubit state, |{\Psi_{AB}}\rangle=\sqrt{p_{00}}|{0,0}\rangle+\sqrt{p_{01}}e^{-i\phi_{01}}|{0,1}\rangle+\sqrt{p_{10}}e^{-i\phi_{10}}|{1,0}\rangle+\sqrt{p_{11}}e^{-i\phi_{11}}|{1,1}\rangle , with |{x,y}\rangle\equiv|{x}\rangle^{A}\otimes|{y}\rangle^{B} and the superscripts label qubits A and B . Qubit A ’s internal energy reads E^{A}=p_{10}+p_{11} , similarly for qubit B , and their sum captures the total energy. We rewrite the state |{\Psi_{AB}}\rangle as |{\Psi_{AB}}\rangle=\sqrt{1-E^{A}}|{0,M^{A}_{0}}\rangle+\sqrt{E^{A}}|{1,M^{A}_{1}}\rangle\,, (2) where |{M^{A}_{0}}\rangle=(\sqrt{p_{00}}|{0}\rangle+\sqrt{p_{01}}e^{-i\phi_{01}}|{1}\rangle)/\sqrt{1-E^{A}} and |{M^{A}_{1}}\rangle=(\sqrt{p_{10}}e^{-i\phi_{10}}|{0}\rangle+\sqrt{p_{11}}e^{-i\phi_{11}}|{1}\rangle)/\sqrt{E^{A}} . In this rewriting, the normalized states of qubit B , |{M^{A}_{0}}\rangle and |{M^{A}_{1}}\rangle , are correlated with A ’s energy states. Thus B plays the role of a quantum meter extracting information on the energy of A . Eq. ( 1 ) yields {\cal D}^{A}=(1-|\epsilon^{A}|^{2})\overline{E}_{\cal C}^{A} . \overline{E}_{\cal C}^{A}\equiv(1-E^{A})E^{A} is the nominal coherent energy of the reference pure state |{\overline{\psi}_{A}}\rangle=\sqrt{1-E^{A}}|{0}\rangle+\sqrt{E^{A}}|{1}\rangle . \epsilon^{A}=\langle{M^{A}_{0}}|{M^{A}_{1}}\rangle refers to the indistinguishability of the meter’s states, which is related to the information extracted Maillette de Buy Wenniger et al. 2026 . {\cal D}^{A} can be fruitfully interpreted as the change of coherent energy of qubit A along a fictitious unitary process, by which its energy is measured by the initially uncorrelated qubit B . Since it does not change qubit A ’s populations, this process is locally-energy-preserving 2 2 2 This is a non-local process and should

Read the complete text