Identification Verification for Structural Vector Autoregressions with Sparse Heterogeneous Markov Switching Heteroskedasticity

Fei Shang, Tomasz Woźniak · 2026

Read Identification Verification for Structural Vector Autoregressions with Sparse Heterogeneous Markov Switching Heteroskedasticity by Fei Shang, Tomasz Woźniak (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2603-16035.txt.

Introduction

Shang and Woźniak add flexible switching volatility to structural VAR models. Each shock's variance follows its own Markov chain in their setup. Extra regimes may sit empty across the whole sample. That sparsity keeps the regime count honest and lean. A new distribution for scaled variances eases Gibbs sampling. The model sharpens structural estimates past popular rival forms. Homoskedasticity checks gain a reliable in-model test. Forecast scores match stochastic volatility benchmarks closely. A US monetary shock is identified through volatility shifts.

Catalog record

CREATORFei Shang, Tomasz Woźniak
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE62822
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2603.16035

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Identification Verification for Structural Vector Autoregressions with Sparse Heterogeneous Markov Switching Heteroskedasticity Fei Shang, Tomasz Woźniak Abstract We propose a structural vector autoregressive model with a new and flexible specification of the volatility process which we call Sparse Heterogeneous Markov-Switching Heteroskedasticity. In this model, the conditional variance of each structural shock changes in time according to its own Markov process. Additionally, it features a sparse representation of Markov processes, in which the number of regimes is set to exceed that of the data-generating process, with some regimes allowed to have zero occurrences throughout the sample. We complement these developments with a definition of a new distribution for normalised conditional variances that facilitates Gibbs sampling and identification verification. In effect, our model: (i) normalises the system and estimates the structural parameters more precisely than popular alternatives; (ii) can be used to verify homoskedasticity reliably and, thus, inform identification through heteroskedasticity; and (iii) features excellent forecasting performance comparable with Stochastic Volatility. Finally, revisiting a prominent macro-financial structural system, we provide evidence for the identification of the US monetary policy shock via heteroskedasticity, with estimates consistent with those reported in the literature. 1 Introduction Heteroskedastic Structural Vector Autoregressions (SVARs) are commonly used because they can fit macro-financial aggregates and offer flexibility across a range of empirical applications. Some examples include influential studies such as that by 35 , which estimates an SVAR with Markov-switching heteroskedasticity for a monetary system and interprets the occurrence of high and low volatility regimes in relation to the terms of particular Federal Reserve chairpersons. In other studies ( 13 ; 6 , see e.g.) , the estimated volatilities are interpreted as economic uncertainty and used to investigate the effects of uncertainty shocks. Heteroskedastic SVARs were used to identify all elements of the structural matrix and, therefore, to identify structural shocks through heteroskedasticity in the seminal studies by 34 and 4 . Time-varying volatility has been documented to improve the forecasting performance of structural models (see 11 , and other papers cited in this introduction) , and to enable order-invariant representations that make forecasts even more precise ( 8 , see) . Finally, this SVAR extension positively affects the model fit ( 35 ; 25 ; 27 , see e.g.) and is documented to improve it by a greater margin than other extensions, such as time-varying parameters or hierarchical modelling ( 9 , see) . The review of parametric specifications for structural shock heteroskedasticity in SVARs is opened by exogenous heteroskedastic regime changes in which the dates of volatility changes are fixed while the conditional variances are estimated as proposed by 34 ; 4 ; 23 . Other more flexible regime change models include Markov-switching ( 35 ; 21 ; 29 , see e.g.) or Smooth Transition ( 26 , see) models in which the probabilities of regime occurrences are estimated as well. SVAR models in which conditional variances are modelled by a dynamic propagation equation include Stochastic Volatility (SV) ( 7 ; 3 ; 8 , see) , and Generalised Autoregressive Conditional Heteroskedasticity (GARCH) ( 31 ; 24 , see e.g.) or their hybrids ( 32 , see e.g.) . Our listing is finalised by nonparametric specifications that imply heteroskedasticity via moment conditions ( 20 ; 17 ; 22 , see) . This extraordinary performance and multiplicity of modelling approaches come at various costs and challenges. SVARs with Stochastic Volatility that tend to outperform other specifications in terms of forecasting performance and model fit are computationally more demanding than, say, Markov-switching models. SV models are more difficult to estimate in the maximum likelihood than in the Bayesian approach, whereas the opposite is the case for the GARCH models. Regime change models suffer from a lack of identification due to label switching – a likelihood-invariant permutation of regimes and regime-specific parameters. Structural models identified through heteroskedasticity are identified up to shock permutation. Finally, normalisation of the structural system is required because the structural matrix and the volatility process are multiplicative in the construction of the predictive density covariance matrix. It usually leads to parameter restrictions that make estimation more tedious. In this context, our search for an adequate parametric specification is informed by the newest developments and encompasses most of the challenges. We propose a new volatility model for SVARs, which we call Heterogeneous Markov-Switching Heteroskedasticity (HMSH). We use the term heterogeneous as each regime-specific parameter, that is, the structural shock’s conditional variance, follows its own Markov process that determines its time-varying properties. It extends the existing approaches ( 35 ; 21 ; 29 , see) that impose the assumption of homogeneity, assuming that all conditional variances evolve according to one Markov process. By allowing for heterogeneity, our model is more flexible and aligns with the setup commonly adopted in SVARs with GARCH or SV, in which the conditional variances of different shocks are modelled independently. Another extension grants each Markov process the sparsity property. In this specification, the number of regimes is set higher than the hypothesised number of regimes in the data-generating process, and some of these regimes are allowed to have zero occurrences throughout the sample. It is inspired by the overfitting mixture model proposed by 30 and adapted to Markov-switching models. Therefore, in our model, the number of regimes with non-zero occurrences is determined during estimation, as only these regimes contribute to the likelihood function. This comes at a cost of the regime-specific conditional variance parameters losing their interpretability. Instead, the sequence of their values over time has standard interpretations as in the GARCH and SV models. Our original extensions of the Markov-switching heteroskedasticity models make them more flexible and closer to these two alternatives, in which the shock-specific variances are allowed to change frequently as the data require. Importantly, Markov-switching models are much faster to estimate than SV. We facilitate such modelling by several numerical and inferential developments. Firstly, we complement the normalisation restriction proposed by 4 , which we adopt in our model, by the derivation of a new distribution for normalised conditional variances which we call the Inverse Gamma-based Dirichlet distribution. This distribution is easy to sample from, facilitating Gibbs sampling, an estimation procedure much more efficient than the Metropolis-Hastings step used by 4 . Secondly, a probability density function for this distribution is derived, facilitating fast computation of Bayes factors for homoskedasticity verification using Savage-Dickey density ratio, following the approach proposed by 29 and 28 . The latter study provides suitable conditions for partial identification of a structural shock through heteroskedasticity in the context of our model. Consequently, we use the new computation of Bayes factors for homoskedasticity to make probabilistic statements about whether a shock, the corresponding structural parameters, and impulse responses are identified through heteroskedasticity. Finally, we follow recent advances and make our model identified through heteroskedasticity order-invariant as in 4 , 8 , and 28 . All of these methods are implemented in the R package bsvars by 41 ; 40 . Our methodological developments lead to substantial improvements in estimation efficiency, reliability of homoskedasticity verification, and forecasting performance. Our Monte Carlo simulations document several important results. Firstly, our SVAR model with sparse HMSH estimates the structural matrix parameters more precisely than alternative models. This conclusion is challenged

Read the complete text