Casimir versus Helmholtz forces in the Gaussian model: exact results for Dirichlet–Dirichlet, Neumann–Dirichlet, Neumann–Neumann, and periodic boundary conditions Journal: Annals of Physics
D. M. Dantchev, J. Rudnick · 2026
Read Casimir versus Helmholtz forces in the Gaussian model: exact results for Dirichlet–Dirichlet, Neumann–Dirichlet, Neumann–Neumann, and periodic boundary conditions Journal: Annals of Physics by D. M. Dantchev, J. Rudnick (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2603-16030.txt.
Introduction
Dantchev and Rudnick compare two fluctuation forces in the Gaussian model. Critical Casimir force rules the grand canonical ensemble. Critical Helmholtz force rules the fixed-mean canonical twin. Exact results near the bulk critical point anchor the study. Four boundary settings face the same side-by-side test. Dirichlet pairs split the forces apart in clear ways. The Casimir pull stays attractive, while Helmholtz can flip sign. Mixed Neumann-Dirichlet walls split the pair as well. Periodic and Neumann pairs make both forces coincide.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | D. M. Dantchev, J. Rudnick |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 93115 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2603.16030
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Casimir versus Helmholtz forces in the Gaussian model: exact results for Dirichlet–Dirichlet, Neumann–Dirichlet, Neumann–Neumann, and periodic boundary conditions Journal: Annals of Physics D. M. Dantchev, J. Rudnick Abstract We present results and compare the behavior of two fluctuation-induced forces pertinent for their corresponding ensembles: the critical Casimir force in the grand canonical (fixed external field h h ) one and the critical Helmholtz force in the canonical (fixed average value of the order parameter m m ) one. We do so by deriving exact results for their behavior near the bulk critical point at T = T c T=T_{c} in the three-dimensional Gaussian model. We consider Dirichlet-Dirichlet, Neumann-Dirichlet, Neumann-Neumann, and periodic boundary conditions. For every boundary condition examined, we confirm that both forces follow a finite-size scaling. We find that for Dirichlet-Dirichlet and Neumann-Dirichlet boundary conditions the Casimir and the Helmholtz force differ from each other. For Dirichlet-Dirichlet boundary conditions the Casimir force is always attractive, while the Helmholtz force can be both attractive and repulsive as a function of T T and m m . For Neumann-Dirichlet boundary conditions the Casimir force changes sign from repulsive to attractive with increase of h h , while the Helmholtz force stays always repulsive. Under periodic and Neumann-Neumann boundary conditions the Casimir force and the Helmholtz force coincide - the first does not depend on h h , while the latter does not depend on m m ; they are always attractive. 1 Introduction Thermodynamic ensembles are generally equivalent for infinite (bulk) systems, but this equivalence does not hold for finite systems. In this article, we will discuss two fluctuation-induced forces: the Casimir force, which is relevant to the grand canonical ensemble (GCE), and the Helmholtz force, associated with the canonical ensemble (CE). We will analyze these forces as a function of temperature T and external magnetic field h for the Casimir force, and as a function of temperature T and average magnetization m for the Helmholtz force. The explicit calculations will be carried out using the Gaussian model, a fundamental model in statistical mechanics that often serves as the starting point for more advanced methods, such as normalization group calculations. Let us envisage a system with a film geometry \infty^{d-1}\times L , and with boundary conditions \tau imposed along the spatial direction of finite extent L . Take {\cal F}_{{\rm total}}^{(\tau)} to be the total free energy of such a system within the GCE. Then, if f^{(\tau)}(T,h,L)\equiv\lim_{A\to\infty}{\cal F}_{{\rm total}}^{(\tau)}/A is the free energy per area A of the system, one can define the Casimir force for critical systems in the grand-canonical (T-h) -ensemble, see, e.g. Ref. Dantchev2023 , as: \beta F_{\rm Casimir}^{(\tau)}(L,T,h)\equiv-\frac{\partial}{\partial L}f_{\rm ex}^{(\tau)}(L,T,h) (1.1) where f_{\rm ex}^{(\tau)}(L,T,h)\equiv f^{(\tau)}(L,T,h)-Lf_{\rm bulk}(T,h) (1.2) is the so-called excess, over the bulk f_{\rm bulk}(T,h) one, free energy per area and per \beta^{-1}=k_{B}T . Along these lines we define the corresponding Helmholtz fluctuation induced force in canonical (T-m) -ensemble: \beta F_{\rm Helmholtz}^{(\tau)}(L,T,m)\equiv-\frac{\partial}{\partial L}a_{\rm ex}^{(\tau)}(L,T,m) (1.3) where a_{\rm ex}^{(\tau)}(L,T,m)\equiv a^{(\tau)}(L,T,m)-La_{\rm bulk}(T,m), (1.4) with m being the average magnetization in the system, and a_{\rm bulk} is the Helmholtz free energy density of the “bulk” system. In the remainder we will take L=Na , where N is an integer number, and for simplicity we set a=1 , i.e., all lengths will be measured in units of the lattice spacing a . Note that neither f_{\rm bulk} , nor a_{\rm bulk} depend on the boundary conditions. We will show that the Helmholtz fluctuation induced force has a behavior very different from that of the Casimir force. According to finite-size scaling theory Bb83 , P90 , ET87 , BDT2000 , DD2022 near the critical point of of the bulk system the singular the excess free energies f_{\rm ex}^{(\tau)} and a_{\rm ex}^{(\tau)} (in units of k_{B}T ) take the form f_{\rm ex}^{(\tau)}(L,T,h)=L^{-(d-1)}X_{\rm ex,GC}^{(\tau)}(x_{t},x_{h})+\mbox{corrections} (1.5) and a_{\rm ex}^{(\tau)}(L,T,h)=L^{-(d-1)}X_{\rm ex,C}^{(\tau)}(x_{t},x_{m})+\mbox{corrections}, (1.6) where x_{t}=a_{t}tL^{1/\nu},\quad x_{h}=a_{h}hL^{\Delta/\nu}\quad\mbox{and}\quad x_{m}=a_{m}mL^{\beta/\nu}, (1.7) where a_{t} , a_{h} and a_{m} are non-universal constants, X_{\rm ex,GC} and X_{\rm ex,C} are universal scaling functions, and t=(T-T_{c})/T_{c} , where T has the meaning of the temperature of the system, and T_{c} is its bulk transition temperature. For the susceptibility one has, correspondingly \chi_{L}^{(\zeta)}(t,h)=a_{h}^{2}L^{\gamma/\nu}X_{\chi}^{(\tau)}(a_{t}tL^{1/\nu},a_{h}hL^{\Delta/\nu}). (1.8) Let us emphasize, that in any ensemble — not only in the grand canonical and canonical, but also, say in the micro-canonical — one can define a thermodynamic fluctuation induced force which is specific for that ensemble. By their definition, these ensembles correspond to quite different physical conditions. Thus, it is reasonable to expect that the behavior of these forces differ from one ensemble to another. The precise behavior of these forces, however, has not yet been the object of thorough and systematic study. Without a doubt, the most well-known fluctuation induced force is the Casimir force which is due to the quantum, or temperature-driven, fluctuation of the electromagnetic field between polarizable objects. This quantum-mechanical Casimir effect is the subject of multiple review articles — see, e.g., BMM2001 , M2001 , BKMM2009 , RCJ2011 , WKD2021 and literature cited therein. It is named after the Dutch physicist H. B. Casimir who first realized that in the case of two perfectly-conducting, uncharged, and smooth plates parallel to each other in vacuum, at T=0 these fluctuations lead to an attractive force between them C48 . Thirty years later, Fisher and De Gennes FG78 showed that a very similar effect exists in critical fluids, today known as critical Casimir effect. It is a force that arises in systems, theoretically described by the grand canonical ensemble. A summary of the results available for this effect can be found in recent reviews MD2018 , DD2022 , Gambassi2024 , Dantchev2024a . The description of the critical Casimir effect is based on finite-size scaling theory Ba83 , P90 , BDT2000 . We note that the critical Casimir effect has been observed experimentally GC99 , GC2002 , GSGC2006 , HHGDB2008 , Schmidt2022 . The notion of the Helmholtz fluctuation induced force has been introduced relatively recently, in Ref. DR2022 . Such a force is pertinent to systems with fixed average value of the magnetization m , i.e., for the canonical ensemble. It has been investigated for the Ising chain with periodic, antiperiodic and Dirichlet boundary conditions DR2022 , Dantchev2023b , Dantchev2024b , Dantchev2025a and in the Nagel – Kardar model Dantchev2024c , Dantchev2025b . The behavior of the force turns out to be quite different from that of the Casimir force. More specifically, it changes it sign as a function of the temperature, being both attractive and repulsive, while the Casimir force is always attractive under the very same boundary conditions. Currently, the only existing review on Helmholtz forces is given in Ref. Dantchev2024a . In the current article we complement the existing results for the Ising and Nagel-Kardar model with another basic model of statistical mechanics — the Gaussian model. The issue of the ensemble dependence of the fluctuation induced forces is, however, by no means limited to specific models and can be addressed, in principle, in any model of interest. The analysis reported here can also be viewed as a useful addition to approaches to fluctuation-induced forces in the fixed- m ensemble based on the Ginsburg-Landau-Wilson Hamiltonian RSVG2019 , GVGD2016 , GGD2017 in which the authors studied,