Experimental evidence for granular shear-flow instability in the Epstein regime
Holly L. Capelo, Jean-David Bodénan, Martin Jutzi, Jonas Kühn, Clément Surville, Lucio Mayer, Maria Schönbächler, Yann Alibert, Nicolas Thomas, Antoine Pommerol · 2026
Read Experimental evidence for granular shear-flow instability in the Epstein regime by Holly L. Capelo, Jean-David Bodénan, Martin Jutzi, Jonas Kühn, Clément Surville, Lucio Mayer, Maria Schönbächler, Yann Alibert, Nicolas Thomas, Antoine Pommerol (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2603-15810.txt.
Introduction
Capelo and co-authors catch a dust-gas shear instability in microgravity tests. Protoplanetary disc models predict such flows can seed planetesimal growth. Dust in a gas stream builds shear layers that may go unstable. Drag there sits in the free-molecular Epstein regime. Earth gravity spoils lab copies through buoyancy effects. The team flew a low-pressure dust-gas mix at Knudsen numbers up to 10. Particle imaging revealed a periodic granular shear pattern. A Kelvin-Helmholtz model fits the pattern to first order.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Holly L. Capelo, Jean-David Bodénan, Martin Jutzi, Jonas Kühn, Clément Surville, Lucio Mayer, Maria Schönbächler, Yann Alibert, Nicolas Thomas, Antoine Pommerol |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 65017 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY SA |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2603.15810
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Experimental evidence for granular shear-flow instability in the Epstein regime Holly L. Capelo, Jean-David Bodénan, Martin Jutzi, Jonas Kühn, Clément Surville, Lucio Mayer, Maria Schönbächler, Yann Alibert, Nicolas Thomas, Antoine Pommerol Abstract Stability analysis of two-fluid protoplanetary disc models has enriched our understanding of how solids can grow into larger bodies called planetesimals. Dust particles entrained in a gas stream modify the flow, creating shear layers prone to instability. In such environments, drag occurs in the free-molecular (Epstein) regime. Recreating these two-phase flows on Earth is difficult due to gravity-driven buoyancy. Here we use particle image velocimetry to study a low-pressure dust-gas mixture at Knudsen numbers up to 10 in microgravity. We observe a granular shear flow instability, characterized by a periodic velocity field, which can be modeled to first order as a Kelvin-Helmholtz (KH) instability. This behavior resembles a Kelvin-Helmholtz instability and provides a benchmark for two-fluid theories relevant to planet formation. keywords keyword1, Keyword2, Keyword3, Keyword4 1 Introduction In models of gaseous circumstellar discs, dust grains sediment to form a dense layer of particles 9 , or collect in filaments near local pressure maxima 29 . As these regions provide a contrast in dust and gas mass densities, the gas and solid phases experience resistance from one another, through collisions of dust particles with gas molecules and transfer of momentum back to the gas. This process of mutual solid-gas coupling creates regions with differential velocities, that result in particle-rich layers shearing against adjacent particle-poor gas layers 34 ; 33 . At the most fundamental level, this phenomenon can be understood by studying two shearing fluids of different density that have a velocity difference at their interface; under conditions where the two phases differ sufficiently in mass, density and velocity, perturbations are amplified enabling growth of waves and the onset of a fluid instability. Well-known examples of analogous processes under atmospheric conditions, occur where particulate matter such as cloud droplets or aerosols hover and drift with respect to the gas 19 . In these cases, the formation of periodic wave patterns and turbulence are important for determining the transport and concentration of particulate matter 22 . It is therefore justified to assume that related flow processes can govern the distribution and transport of dust grains in protoplanetary discs 27 ; 10 ; 14 ; 3 . Indeed, the particle-gas interaction is considered critical for driving disc evolution and converting primitive solids—including sub- \mu m size dust grains, icy particles, and cm-size pebbles—into planetesimals 31 ; 13 . There is debate about whether a thin layer of dust at the disc midplane might fragment due to self-gravity forming planetesimals or whether this process could be stalled if the dust layer density is limited by the turbulence generated by a Kelvin-Helmholtz-like shear instability (henceforth KH instability). It has also been pointed out that for enhanced dust densities, the relative motion between the dust and gas phases would lead to a runaway streaming instability which concentrates material sufficiently for planetesimals to form 35 , and that this could compete effectively against diffusive turbulence 3 . Other authors have proposed a general class of dust-drag driven instability with similar control parameters 28 . This broad class of so-called ‘resonant drag instabilities’ (RDIs) arises from differential motion between the particle and gas phases. Although there is a large body of theoretical studies of unstable two-phase flow, experimental studies on this topic are very rare. To remedy this issue, 15 showed that the signature effects of the streaming instability, in particular spontaneous particle clustering in a mass-loaded fluid, could be reproduced in a simplified non-rotating system, and provided useful scaling relationships that apply flexibly to either the sedimentation of dust particles in a protoplanetary disc, or the sedimentation of particles in a dilute laboratory flow. 5 performed experiments in an equivalent system and confirmed spontaneous clustering dynamics on the appropriate scale, and also found evidence of a collective particle-drafting effect for particles in the Stokes drag regime. The current experimental work is not focused upon the streaming instability, but similarly involves a system that is greatly simplified to capture and isolate a fundamental mechanism that underlies theory. Important distinctions apply to the growth rate and critical length scales one expects for various types of instability, which cannot, and need not, all be reproduced in experiments. Instead, this work places utmost importance upon testing the generally accepted premise that the solid-particle phase behaves as if it is a fluid. It is therefore the goal of this work to reproduce a standard fluid-dynamical phenomenon under conditions that have not been achieved before; specifically, we address the case of a potential KH-like shear flow instability, where one of the phases consists of solid dust-particle analogue material. Furthermore, it is necessary to test the analogy between atmospheric flows and the flow conditions found in circumstellar contexts, with consideration for the specific parameters and properties of the modeled fluid. Treating free-floating dust particles collectively as a fluid simplifies the modelling of the particle-gas processes in the earliest stages of planet formation 21 . It is acceptable to consider the particle phase as a pressureless fluid, since the particle number density is low enough that collisions are rare 12 . The average dust-to-gas mass density ratio, \epsilon\equiv \rho_{dust}/\rho_{gas} governs the force acting in opposition between the two phases. The quantity \rho_{dust} is the dust mass contained per unit volume, and derives from the number of particles per unit volume, the particles’ average size and material density (see also definitions in the Subsection Flow Parameters). The quantity \rho_{gas} is simply the gas density, assuming an ideal gas. In a circumstellar context the mean free path of the gas l is typically equal to, or larger than, the size of the particles d_{p} , resulting in a high Knudsen number Kn\equiv l/d_{p} . Therefore the applicable drag force F_{\rm d} corresponds to either transitional or free-molecular flow – also referred to as Epstein drag 32 . Inviscid flow (Euler) equations apply when inertial effects dominate viscous forces within a fluid. The Reynold’s number compares the relative strengths of these forces: Re=F_{inertial}/F_{viscous}=\rho_{\rm gas}vL/\mu . Gas velocity is v , the length scale is L and the molecular viscosity is \mu . For a large L , the inertia is driven up and internal fluid friction is therefore neglected. For particles in a flow, the particles’ momentum competes with the fluid drag force resulting in a characteristic time for particle acceleration to slow down to a steady velocity, known as the particle friction timescale, T_{f}=m\delta v/F_{d} , for a particle of mass m and differential velocity \delta v . The parameter T_{f} determines whether particles directly follow fluid motions, or else obey their own inertia. A dimensionless Stokes number is typically defined by comparing T_{f} with a system timescale 1 . It has been shown that moderately decoupled solids are effective at driving fluid instabilities both in rotating systems—such as the streaming instability—and in non-rotating, local settings, where the so-called settling or drafting instability applies due to the negligible role of Coriolis forces at the particle friction length scale ( 15 ; 5 ) . In addition, RDIs can also develop in non-rotating environments through