On the performance of QTP functionals applied to second-order response properties II: Dynamic polarizability and long-range C 6 coefficients Preprint: AIP/123-QED
Rodrigo A. Mendes, Peter R. Franke, Ajith Perera, Rodney J. Bartlett · 2026
Read On the performance of QTP functionals applied to second-order response properties II: Dynamic polarizability and long-range C 6 coefficients Preprint: AIP/123-QED by Rodrigo A. Mendes, Peter R. Franke, Ajith Perera, Rodney J. Bartlett (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2603-15788.txt.
Introduction
Mendes and co-authors grade density functionals on frequency-dependent response traits. Part one of the series covered static polarizabilities and NMR traits. Part two turns to dynamic polarizabilities at five wavelengths. Some 25 functionals face HF and EOM-CCSD reference runs. TPSS0 and QTP01 led the Kohn-Sham pack on dynamic values. The team also checks pole structure in the CO molecule. For C6 dispersion coefficients, O3LYP ranked first overall. QTP01 and LC-QTP led inside the QTP family.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Rodrigo A. Mendes, Peter R. Franke, Ajith Perera, Rodney J. Bartlett |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 31301 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2603.15788
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
On the performance of QTP functionals applied to second-order response properties II: Dynamic polarizability and long-range C 6 coefficients Preprint: AIP/123-QED Rodrigo A. Mendes, Peter R. Franke, Ajith Perera, Rodney J. Bartlett Abstract This work is the second in the series “On the performance of QTP functionals applied to second-order response properties.” In the first paper (J. Chem. Phys. 162, 054105, 2025), we demonstrated the good performance of Quantum Theory Project functionals in predicting static perturbed second-order properties, such as static polarizabilities, nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) spin-spin coupling constants, and NMR chemical shifts. In the present study, we focus on frequency-dependent properties, namely dynamic polarizabilities and C 6 C_{6} dispersion coefficients. For completeness, a total of 25 exchange-correlation (XC) functionals were investigated. Dynamic polarizabilities were evaluated at five different perturbation wavelengths: 632.99 nm, 594.10 nm, 543.52 nm, 514.50 nm, and 325.13 nm. This property was also computed using HF and EOM-CCSD. In general, EOM-CCSD results are very close to those obtained with linear-response CC3, except at the highest frequency. Among Kohn-Sham calculations, TPSS0 and QTP01 showed the best overall performance for dynamic polarizabilities. We also assessed how well QTP functionals reproduce the pole structure of the CO molecule. For the C 6 C_{6} dispersion coefficients, calculations were performed using the Casimir-Polder equation. The best overall performance was obtained with O3LYP; however, the first eleven ranked functionals show very similar accuracy. Within the QTP family, QTP01 and LC-QTP provide the best results for C 6 C_{6} coefficients. I INTRODUCTION The Correlated Orbital Theory (COT) Bartlett 2009 can be viewed as a frequency-independent form of the Dyson equation from Electron Propagator (EP) theory, reformulated within the coupled-cluster (CC) framework. Meissner and Bartlett 1993 COT offers a coherent solution to the so-called “Devil’s Triangle” of Kohn–Sham Density Functional Theory (KS-DFT): the self-interaction error, the lack of integer discontinuity, and the incorrect one-particle spectra, Bartlett 2019 ; Mendes, Haiduke, and Bartlett 2021 all which are different manifestations of the self-interaction error, but offer different route toward fixing the problem. According to COT, a one-particle theory should produce orbitals whose eigenvalues directly correspond to exact physical observables, including ionization potentials (IPs) for the occupied space and electron affinities (EAs) for some of the virtual orbitals (it depends on the number of stable anionic states in the specific chemical system). In this context, these orbitals are conceptually analogous to Dyson orbitals in EP theory, except they correspond to an infinite order sum provided by the frequency-independent self-energy from CC theory. The functionals from the Quantum Theory Project (QTP) family, e.g., QTP00, Verma and Bartlett 2014 QTP01, Jin and Bartlett 2016 QTP02, Haiduke and Bartlett 2018 and LC-QTP Haiduke and Bartlett 2018 , are developed mapping KS-DFT onto COT. These functionals have proven successful in accurately describing a wide range of ground-state properties, such as ionization potentials (core and valence), Ranasinghe et al. 2019 ; Mendes et al. 2025a electron affinities, Pavlicek et al. 2024 isotropic hyperfine coupling constants, Windom, Perera, and Bartlett 2022a and reaction barrier heights. Haiduke and Bartlett 2018 We showed in the previous paper of this series excellent performance from QTP functionals for static polarizabilities, NMR coupling constants, and chemical shifts for different isotopes, 13 C , 15 N , 17 O , 19 F , 31 P , and 33 S . Mendes et al. 2025b For this, we investigated several functionals from the different rungs of Jacob’s ladder, always against EOM-CCSD results. Thus, LC-QTP ranked first in terms of the static polarizability. Regarding the total nuclear spin-spin coupling constants, QTP01 performed best (QTP02 and LC-QTP were second and third best). In the case of chemical shift analysis, TPSS0 surpassed the others for the majority of the chemical shifts. However, QTP00, QTP01, and QTP02 were among the best. In addition, QTP functionals perform very well for various response properties, such as core excitation energies, Park, Perera, and Bartlett 2022 vertical excitation energies (including Rydberg and charge-transfer states), Mendes, Haiduke, and Bartlett 2021 two-photon absorption cross sections, Elayan et al. 2024 and magnetizabilities. Lehtola et al. 2021 Notably, QTP functionals have also demonstrated CC/EOM-CC quality in predicting both the fundamental and optical gaps of challenging extended systems, such as polyacene and trans-polyacetylene oligomers. Windom, Perera, and Bartlett 2022b In this second paper of our series on second-order properties, we examine how well QTP functionals describe frequency-dependent properties. For example, the dynamic polarizability can be expressed as the second derivative of the energy with respect to an oscillating electric field, \frac{\partial^{2}E(\omega)}{\partial F_{i}\partial F_{j}} . This property measures how a molecule’s dipole moment responds to a time-varying electric field. Thus, the dynamic polarizability can be formally described by the sum-over-states (SOS) form, \alpha_{ij}(\omega)=\sum_{n}\left[\frac{\matrixelement{0}{\mu_{\alpha}}{n}\matrixelement{n}{\mu_{\beta}}{0}}{\omega_{n}-\omega_{1}}+\frac{\matrixelement{0}{\mu_{\beta}}{n}\matrixelement{n}{\mu_{\alpha}}{0}}{\omega_{n}+\omega_{2}}\right] (1) where \mu_{\alpha,\beta} is the Cartesian dipole moment component and \omega_{n} is the excited state energy represented by excitations from \ket{0} to an excited state \ket{n} , and is obtained from linear response TDDFT as, Casida and Huix-Rotllant 2012 \left(\begin{matrix}A&B\\ B^{\ast}&A^{\ast}\\ \end{matrix}\right)\left(\begin{matrix}X\\ Y\\ \end{matrix}\right)=\omega\left(\begin{matrix}1&0\\ 0&-1\\ \end{matrix}\right)\left(\begin{matrix}X\\ Y\\ \end{matrix}\right). (2) In this case, X and Y are particular eigenvectors having the \omega eigenvalue for virtual-occupied and occupied-virtual elements of the density matrix. The matrices \bm{A} and \bm{B} have the following elements: \bm{A}_{ai,bj}=\delta_{ij}\delta_{ab}(\varepsilon_{a}-\varepsilon_{i})+(ai|jb)+(ai|f_{xc}|jb), (3) \bm{B}_{ai,bj}=(ai|bj)+(ai|f_{xc}|bj), (4) where the labels i,j represent occupied orbitals, while a,b denote virtual orbitals. \varepsilon is the respective orbital eigenvalue. Furthermore, f_{xc} is the “kernel", i.e. , the second derivative of the exchange-correlation functional (the adiabatic approximation is assumed), f_{xc}=\frac{\delta^{2}E_{xc}}{\delta\rho\left(1\right)\delta\rho\left(2\right)}. (5) In this work, we assess the performance of the QTP functionals in predicting the isotropic frequency-dependent polarizabilities under five distinct perturbations. We further examine their accuracy in describing the dispersion C_{6} coefficients, which are directly related to the dynamic polarizability and provide information regarding the long-range interactions between chemical species. For completeness and a broader perspective, we also include a representative set of exchange-correlation (XC) functionals spanning the different rungs of Jacob’s ladder. Altogether, this results in a total of 25 XC functionals, in addition to the Hartree-Fock (HF) and coupled-cluster (CC) based post-HF methods. II Computational Details The linear-response CC3 Christiansen, Koch, and Jo/rgensen 1995 calculations were performed using the Coupled-Cluster techniques for Computational Chemistry (CFOUR) software, version 1.2. Stanton et al. Equation-of-Motion Coupled-Cluster with single and double excitations (EOM-CCSD) Stanton and Bartlett 1993a calculations were performed using the Advanced Concepts in Electronic Structure (ACES) II Perera et al. 2020 package. No orbitals were frozen in any of the calculations. All DFT investigations were carried out using the PySCF package version 2.7.0 Sun et al. 2018 ; pys 2020 combined with the LibXC exchange-correlation library. Lehtola et al. 2018 In this sense, the XC functionals of the following rungs of Jacob’s ladder were investigated: Perdew and Schmidt 2001 Local Density Approximation (LDA), Generalized Gradient Approximation (GGA), meta-GGA (MGGA), global hybrids, and range-separated hybrids (RSH). For these calculations, we employed a dense numerical integration grid in PySCF by setting the grid level to 6. This corresponds to Lebedev angular grids of 302 points for hydrogen, and 434 points for all heavier atoms, combined with Treutler-Ahlrichs radial grids (80 points for hydrogen, 120 points for second-row elements, and 125 points for third-row elements). The SCF convergence tolerance for the energy was set to 1.0\text{\times}{10}^{-09} . All calculations were performed using