Benchmarking quantum simulation with neutron-scattering experiments

Yi-Ting Lee, Keerthi Kumaran, Bibek Pokharel Allen Scheie, Colin L. Sarkis, David A. Tennant, Travis Humble, André Schleife, Abhinav Kandala, Arnab Banerjee · 2026

Read Benchmarking quantum simulation with neutron-scattering experiments by Yi-Ting Lee, Keerthi Kumaran, Bibek Pokharel Allen Scheie, Colin L. Sarkis, David A. Tennant, Travis Humble, André Schleife, Abhinav Kandala, Arnab Banerjee (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2603-15608.txt.

Introduction

Lee and co-authors test whether today's quantum processors can simulate quantum materials with real accuracy. They run a superconducting processor with up to 50 qubits. A quantum-classical workflow computes dynamical structure factors for the material KCuF3. The team compares the spectra with neutron-scattering measurements from the lab. Circuit depth and fidelity shape how close the match is. They also simulate a gapped XXZ chain linked to CsCoX3 compounds.

Catalog record

CREATORYi-Ting Lee, Keerthi Kumaran, Bibek Pokharel Allen Scheie, Colin L. Sarkis, David A. Tennant, Travis Humble, André Schleife, Abhinav Kandala, Arnab Banerjee
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE31381
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2603.15608

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Benchmarking quantum simulation with neutron-scattering experiments Yi-Ting Lee, Keerthi Kumaran, Bibek Pokharel Allen Scheie, Colin L. Sarkis, David A. Tennant, Travis Humble, André Schleife, Abhinav Kandala, Arnab Banerjee Abstract A central goal of quantum computation is the realistic simulation of quantum materials. Although quantum processors have advanced rapidly in scale and fidelity, it has remained unclear whether pre–fault-tolerant devices can perform quantitatively reliable material simulations within their limited gate budgets. Here, we demonstrate that a superconducting quantum processor operating on up to 50 qubits can already produce meaningful, quantitative comparisons with inelastic neutron-scattering measurements of KCuF 3 , a canonical realization of a gapless Luttinger liquid system with a strongly correlated ground state and a spectrum of emergent spinons. The quantum simulation is enabled by a quantum–classical workflow for computing dynamical structure factors (DSFs). The resulting spectra are benchmarked against experimental measurements using multiple metrics, highlighting the impact of circuit depth and circuit fidelity on simulation accuracy. Finally, we extend our simulations to a 1D XXZ Heisenberg model with next-nearest-neighbor interactions and a strong anisotropy, producing a gapped excitation spectrum, which could be used to describe the CsCoX 3 compounds above the Néel temperature. Our results establish a framework for computing DSFs for quantum materials in classically challenging regimes of strong entanglement and long-range interactions, enabling quantum simulations that are directly testable against laboratory measurements. Accurately predicting the properties of quantum materials has been enabled by decades of advances in classical computational methods [ 14 , 65 , 51 , 58 ] . However, strongly correlated systems with long-range entanglement and complex dynamics remain beyond the reach of these approaches. Quantum computers offer a potential alternative to addressing this challenge [ 1 ] , as envisioned by Feynman [ 12 ] . Rapid advances in qubit number and gate fidelity have enabled studies of both static [ 55 , 76 ] and dynamical [ 25 , 18 , 50 ] properties of many-body systems at scales beyond exact diagonalization. Yet, despite recent advances in algorithms and hardware, resource estimates suggest that extending these simulations to realistic materials is expected to require circuit depths and error rates that are beyond near-term capabilities [ 9 ] . It has therefore been unclear whether current, pre-fault tolerant quantum computers can ever perform quantitatively reliable many-body simulations of quantum materials that can be closely compared with laboratory measurements. Inelastic neutron scattering (INS) provides an experimentally accessible pathway to bridge quantum simulation with laboratory measurements. In an INS experiment, incident neutrons scatter off magnetic ions in a material, exchanging both energy and momentum with its spins. The measured signal can be used to compute two-point dynamical correlation functions that capture how local excitations propagate through the system in space and time. Expressed in momentum and frequency space, these correlations form the dynamical structure factor (DSF), which directly reveals the spectrum of collective excitations and dispersion relations in a material. As many quantum materials can be modeled by spin-1/2 Hamiltonians that are naturally mapped onto qubit systems, digital quantum processors can compute the DSF [ 8 , 2 , 11 , 6 , 53 ] by preparing the ground state, perturbing it locally, evolving under the system Hamiltonian, and measuring two-point correlation functions. This correspondence establishes a direct pathway from quantum circuits to experimentally observable quantities. Classical approaches to computing DSFs—including semiclassical spin-wave methods [ 13 ] , exact diagonalization [ 34 ] , Krylov-space techniques [ 38 ] , and tensor-network methods such as time-dependent density-matrix renormalization group (t-DMRG) [ 15 ] —have achieved significant success. However, they are fundamentally limited by exponential growth in Hilbert-space dimension or by entanglement growth during real-time evolution, restricting their applicability in strongly interacting regimes such as quantum spin liquids or near quantum criticality. For general local Hamiltonians, evaluating the dynamical structure factor is believed to be BQP-hard, inheriting the computational complexity of simulating real-time quantum dynamics [ 2 ] , and highlighting the potential advantage of quantum processors for accessing these observables [ 4 ] . Here we demonstrate that quantum computers can serve as reliable tools for simulating experimentally measurable spectra of quantum materials. We perform a direct experimental validation by benchmarking quantum simulations against INS measurements of the quasi-one-dimensional antiferromagnet KCuF 3 , whose spectrum is a canonical realization of a Tomonaga–Luttinger liquid exhibiting fractionalized spinon excitations [ 32 , 62 , 61 ] . Using 50-qubit circuits executed on superconducting quantum processors, we compute spatiotemporal correlation functions and reconstruct the DSF for quantitative comparison with experiment. We show that the agreement between simulation and experiment is enabled by reductions in two-qubit error rates towards 0.1%, and the intrinsic robustness of the DSF estimation to noise-induced damping of the correlation functions. We further extend this framework to a non-integrable XXZ model with next-nearest-neighbor interactions, relevant to CsCoX 3 (X = Halides) above their Néel temperature [ 39 , 40 , 66 ] , demonstrating applicability beyond analytically solvable regimes. These results establish a pathway for quantum simulations that are directly testable against laboratory measurements, providing a benchmark for the scientific capabilities of near-term quantum processors. Inelastic neutron scattering When the neutrons interact with a material, they exchange energy and momentum with its microscopic degrees of freedom; therefore, measuring the scattered neutrons provides direct access to the underlying eigenstates and excitation spectra of the material. INS using moderated thermal and cold neutrons, typically from a reactor or spallation source, is a non-destructive experimental technique widely used to probe spin dynamics at the atomic scale. Evaluating the INS spectrum involves computing the magnetic neutron scattering cross-section [ 37 ] ( I(q,\omega) ), which is directly related to the DSF S(q,\omega) , as follows. I(q,\omega)=r_{0}^{2}\frac{k_{f}}{k_{i}}\left|\frac{g}{2}F(q)\right|^{2}\sum_{\alpha,\beta=x,y,z}(\delta_{\alpha,\beta}-\hat{q}_{\alpha}\hat{q}_{\beta})\,S(q,\omega)_{\alpha,\beta}, (1) where q is the momentum transfer vector, k_{i} and k_{f} are the wave vectors of incident and scattered neutrons respectively, r_{0} is the interatomic distance, g is the gyromagnetic ratio, F(q) is the magnetic form-factor, which depends on the isotope, and S(q,\omega)_{\alpha,\beta} is the DSF. Within the framework of the fluctuation-dissipation theorem [ 27 ] , , assuming there are no phase transitions due to the change in temperature, the DSF can be evaluated at experimentally achievable temperatures directly from the imaginary part of the retarded two-point Green’s function, G^{R}(q,\omega) , as follows: S_{\alpha,\beta}(q,\omega)=-\frac{1}{\pi}[1+n_{B}(\omega)]Im[G^{R}_{\alpha,\beta}(q,\omega)] (2) where n_{B}(\omega) is the Bose distribution function and is equal to 0 at T=0 . This retarded Green’s function (RGF) can be measured efficiently in the position and time domain, G^{R}_{\alpha,\beta}(i,j,t) , via quantum simulations based on local unitary perturbations applied at each site in the system [ 2 ] , the corresponding quantum circuit is illustrated in Figure 1 and is described in detail in supplementary material Implementation details for quantum computing . Quantum simulation of INS spectrum KCuF 3 is a prototypical quasi‑one‑dimensional antiferromagnet whose magnetic properties have been extensively characterized by INS experiments. Although the compound has a tetragonal crystal structure [ 59 ] , orbital ordering leads to strong antiferromagnetic superexchange interactions along the c -axis and much weaker interactions orthogonal to the c -axis [ 52 ] . This hierarchy effectively decouples the spin chains, giving rise to an emergent one-dimensional quantum magnet well captured by the 1D spin-1/2 XXZ Hamiltonian, H=2J\sum_{i=1}^{n-1}[S_{i}^{X}S_{i+1}^{X}+S_{i}^{Y}S_{i+1}^{Y}+\epsilon S_{i}^{Z}S_{i+1}^{Z}],

Read the complete text