Multi-Scenario User Profile Construction via Recommendation Lists

Hui Zhang, Jiayu Liu · 2026

Read Multi-Scenario User Profile Construction via Recommendation Lists by Hui Zhang, Jiayu Liu (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2603-15357.txt.

Introduction

Zhang and Liu propose RAPI, a framework that infers user traits from recommendation lists alone. Recommender systems shape choices in many fields, and their output lists are easy to observe. RAPI builds a surrogate model that mimics the target recommender, using BERT content embeddings for items. An augmentation module extends the lists by output similarity. A weighted classifier then assigns dynamic weights to infer each trait. Tests on four collections reached trait inference accuracy up to about 0.76 across scenarios with varied information access.

Catalog record

CREATORHui Zhang, Jiayu Liu
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE67207
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/publicdomain/zero/1.0/
RIGHTSCC0
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2603.15357

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Multi-Scenario User Profile Construction via Recommendation Lists Hui Zhang, Jiayu Liu Abstract . Recommender systems (RS) play a core role in various domains, including business analytics, helping users and companies make appropriate decisions. To optimize service quality, related technologies focus on constructing user profiles by analyzing users’ historical behavior information. This paper considers four analytical scenarios to evaluate user profiling capabilities under different information conditions. A generic user attribute analysis framework named RAPI is proposed, which infers users’ personal characteristics by exploiting easily accessible recommendation lists. Specifically, a surrogate recommendation model is established to simulate the original model, leveraging content embedding from a pre-trained BERT model to obtain item embeddings. A sample augmentation module generates extended recommendation lists by considering similarity between model outputs and item embeddings. Finally, an adaptive weight classification model assigns dynamic weights to facilitate user characteristic inference. Experiments on four collections show that RAPI achieves inference accuracy of 0.764 and 0.6477, respectively. 1. Introduction Recommender systems provide personalized recommendation [ 37 , 19 , 25 , 31 , 10 ] services to alleviate the problem of information overload. Typically, recommender systems analyze the user’s historical interaction behaviors (ratings, clicks, views, etc.) to learn a user’s preferences and generate an appropriate recommendation list for the user. However, a more accurate recommendation list is more likely to contain the information that reflects the user’s real identity. An business analyst is able to utilize this information to infer the user’s history behaviors and personal characteristics (age, gender, occupation, etc.) Recently, research has explored the inferential capabilities of recommendation models for user characteristics. Such profiling techniques leverage relational information and interaction history to establish correlations between observed behaviors and specific user attributes. Kosinski et al. [ 17 ] exploit users’ behavioral information about Facebook likes to infer their private attribute information. However, aforementioned methods primarily focus on system’s internal architecture, or query-level access. There remains a research gap in evaluating the associative transparency between system-generated recommendation sequences and specific user characteristics. Recommendation lists can be obtained by various methods: sharing on social media, comments on forums or communities, recommendations from bloggers and websites, etc. Kosinski et al. [ 17 ] argue that recommendation lists can also be regarded as a kind of digital record. To comprehensively analyze the information embedded in recommendation lists and evaluate the potential for constructing user profiles, this research investigates the subject through several defined roles. In this work, the party constructing user profiles is referred to as the analyst; a user providing interaction history is termed a reference user; and the individual whose profile is being constructed is the target user. We establish four scenarios and utilize profiling accuracy as a quantitative indicator to assess the effectiveness of user profile analysis across different conditions. In all scenarios, the analyst is assumed to have access to the target user’s recommendation lists. Importantly, this study focuses on quantifying the extent of user information extractable from these lists, rather than the methods by which the analyst obtains historical engagement records—whether through explicit user consent or authorized third-party channels. This study encompasses four distinct analytical scenarios representing varying levels of information accessibility. Scenario 1 (External Observer) characterizes the analyst as an external entity with access limited to publicly observable recommendation outputs. Scenario 2 (Platform Insider) positions the analyst as an internal developer with privileged access to system architectures and latent embedding representations. Scenario 3 (Third-party Analyst) involves an external researcher employing content-based inference methodologies with constrained system accessibility. Scenario 4 (Comprehensive Analyst) represents an advanced analyst capable of aggregating interaction records from reference users through multiple authorized information channels. These scenarios collectively enable systematic evaluation of the effectiveness of user profile construction under varying information availability conditions.In Scenarios 1 and 2, the demographic attributes of target users can be obtained by classifying the item numbers or item embedding by an advanced classification model, respectively. However, Scenarios 3 and 4 face some challenges: (1) the analyst will not be satisfied with the original recommendation model that is blackbox for him, which would greatly limit the analyst’s ability; (2) the analyst needs more recommendation information from the user for higher accuracy, while user’s more recommendation information is hard to obtain. To solve the first challenge, an alternative model which is whitebox for the analyst is established based on the recommendation list similarity. To overcome the second challenge, an information augmentation module is introduced to generate supplementary recommendation outputs. This is achieved by calculating embedding similarities and integrating content embeddings derived from a pre-trained BERT model [ 6 ] . In this work, a generalized User Profile Analysis framework called RAPI (Recommendation Analysis for Profile Inference) is proposed, which can utilize a user’s recommendation list along with optional interaction records to accurately characterize user attributes. The RAPI framework is divided into mainly three steps. Firstly, the analyst constructs a surrogate recommendation model, which not only achieves recommendation performance similar to the original system but also operates as a whitebox for the analyst, implying that the analyst can efficiently access the embedding representations of the reference user and their interacted items. Secondly, the analyst designs an information augmentation module. It computes the similarity between a user’s original recommendation list and remaining items of the item pool, subsequently adds a subset of the most similar items to the original recommendation list. As the surrogate recommendation model has no access to item embeddings with which reference users have not interacted, a pre-trained language model, BERT, is employed to generate content embeddings for these items. The content embeddings are then aligned to recommendation embeddings in the same latent space by an alignment model. Finally, an adaptive-weight classification model is designed to accurately infer the user’s attributes based on the augmented recommendation list. This framework is evaluated on four real recommendation outputs. The experimental results indicate that the RAPI can characterize user attributes with higher accuracy compared with baseline methods, even when prior knowledge is limited to partial interaction records or entirely absent. This study underscores the potential for user attributes to be inferred from recommendation lists or interaction records, highlighting the importance of understanding user characteristic modeling in recommendation systems. Overall, our contributions in this paper are as follows: • Four scenarios are designed to demonstrate the effectiveness of user profile analysis. To the best of our knowledge, this work is the first to systematically examine the inference of user attributes from recommendation lists. • RAPI is proposed to infer user attributes from recommendation lists. Specifically, RAPI constructs a surrogate model based on the similarity between recommendation lists, performs recommendation list augmentation based on the similarity between recommendation embeddings, and dynamically assigns weights to items at different positions to enhance accuracy of inferences. • Extensive experiments on four outputs demonstrate the effectiveness of RAPI, which can characterize user attributes with high accuracy. 2. Related Work 2.1. Collaborative Filtering Collaborative filtering tasks are commonly approached through the application of matrix factorization methodologies in recommendation systems [ 16 , 14 , 30 , 29 , 4 , 36 , 5 , 22 , 34 , 23 , 13 , 24 , 33 ] . The core concept behind this approach is to project input signals, e.g. user and

Read the complete text