Power-Law Running of the Higgs Mass
Kang-Sin Choi · 2026
Read Power-Law Running of the Higgs Mass by Kang-Sin Choi (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2603-15081.txt.
Introduction
Choi argues that the Higgs mass looks natural once its power-law running is taken seriously. The renormalized scalar mass squared runs as the square of the energy scale. Far above the electroweak scale, couplings drift slowly, so the Standard Model stays nearly scale invariant. An order-one value at the unification scale then maps down exponentially to the electroweak scale. The 28 orders of magnitude between the scales reflect a small anomalous dimension, driven by the top Yukawa coupling, not fine tuning.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Kang-Sin Choi |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 23002 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2603.15081
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Power-Law Running of the Higgs Mass Kang-Sin Choi Abstract The renormalized scalar mass squared is a function of the energy scale and power-runs as its square: it is 𝒪 ( M GUT 2 ) \mathcal{O}(M_{\text{GUT}}^{2}) at M GUT 2 M_{\text{GUT}}^{2} and 𝒪 ( m W 2 ) \mathcal{O}(m_{W}^{2}) at m W 2 m_{W}^{2} . The 28 orders of discrepancy is naturally explained by the loop-correction factor of the Standard Model, dominated by the top quark Yukawa coupling 16 π 2 / ( N c y t 2 ln 10 ) 16\pi^{2}/(N_{c}y_{t}^{2}\ln 10) . The Higgs boson mass parameter ATLAS:Higgs:2012 ; CMS:Higgs:2012 m_{h}^{2} , close to (125~\text{GeV})^{2} , is 28 orders of magnitude below the square of the scale M_{\text{GUT}}\sim 10^{16} GeV at which the Standard Model is expected to be completed by new physics such as string theory, not necessarily Grand Unified Theory (GUT). In the Standard Model (SM), the one-loop correction to the scalar mass squared from a field of mass M_{\text{GUT}} takes the form \delta m_{h}^{2}\sim g^{2}M_{\text{GUT}}^{2} , where g is the relevant coupling. The correction overwhelms the observed mass, requiring an apparent cancellation between huge quantities—the bare mass and the loop correction—to one part in 10^{28} . This is the hierarchy problem Veltman:1981 ; tHooft:1980 ; Susskind:1979 ; Barbieri:Giudice:1988 ; Giudice:2008 . ’t Hooft gave the symmetry account tHooft:1980 : a mass parameter is protected if setting it to zero increases the symmetry. For fermions, setting the mass to zero, m_{f}\to 0 , restores chiral symmetry; for the scalar, m_{h}\to 0 restores no symmetry. The resulting corrections are \displaystyle\delta m_{f} \displaystyle\propto m_{f}\log M_{\text{GUT}}^{2} \displaystyle\text{fermion (protected),} (1) \displaystyle\delta m_{h}^{2} \displaystyle\propto M_{\text{GUT}}^{2} \displaystyle\text{scalar (unprotected).} This was taken to mean that a light scalar is unnatural unless a new symmetry (supersymmetry Dimopoulos:Georgi:1981 , compositeness Kaplan:Georgi:1984 , extra dimensions ArkaniHamed:1998 ; Randall:Sundrum:1999 ) stabilizes it, or the value is environmentally selected Bousso:Polchinski:2000 . The Large Hadron Collider has found no evidence for such symmetries. We show that none are needed. The fully renormalized mass function virtual ; Choi:2023:observables ; Choi:2025:Higgs shows that the scalar mass squared runs as the square of the energy scale q^{2} . This is not an additional assumption but a consequence of the standard quantum field theory tHooft:1971 ; tHooft:Veltman:1972 , once the renormalization is carried out completely. Therefore it is \mathcal{O}(M_{\text{GUT}}^{2}) at M_{\text{GUT}}^{2} and \mathcal{O}(m_{W}^{2}) at m_{W}^{2} —the natural scaling of an unprotected quantity. In a grand unified theory, an order-one boundary condition at the unification scale suffices to produce an electroweak-scale Higgs, replacing the traditional 10^{-28} cancellation. The q^{2} -dependence of the scalar self-energy has long been perceived—but only as a part of the divergent, unrenormalized expression. It appeared in the earliest one-loop calculations Veltman:1981 ; Fleischer:Jegerlehner:1981 ; gauge-invariant formulations were developed in Cornwall:1982 ; Binosi:Papavassiliou:2009 ; the physical significance of the quadratic term was explored in Jegerlehner:2014 ; Jegerlehner:2021 ; and the Wilsonian functional renormalization group Wilson:Kogut:1974 , which naturally captures the quadratic scaling, was recently applied to the full SM in Garces:2025 . These works treat the q^{2} dependence within the framework of cutoff-dependent bare parameters or Wilsonian flows. What is new in Choi:2023:observables ; Choi:2025:Higgs is the extraction of a finite, physical mass function in which the q^{2} dependence is not a cutoff artifact or a source of fine-tuning but the entire observable content of the scalar mass. The mass function The mass function constructed in Ref. virtual defines the scalar mass at every external momentum q . On-shell renormalization yields Choi:2023:observables ; Choi:2025:Higgs \begin{split}m^{2}(q^{2})&=m_{h}^{2}+\Sigma(q^{2})-\Sigma(m_{h}^{2})-(q^{2}-m_{h}^{2})\frac{d\Sigma}{dq^{2}}(m_{h}^{2})\\ &\equiv m_{h}^{2}+\Sigma_{\text{ren}}(q^{2}),\end{split} (2) with the dressed propagator i/(q^{2}-m^{2}(q^{2})) and pole mass m_{h} fixed by m^{2}(m_{h}^{2})=m_{h}^{2} . 1 1 1 Above particle-production thresholds, \Sigma acquires an imaginary part; \Sigma_{\text{ren}} denotes \text{Re}\,\Sigma_{\text{ren}} throughout. The mass function is finite Bogoliubov:Parasiuk:1957 ; Hepp:1966 ; Zimmermann:1969 , and regularization-independent Choi:2023:observables ; Choi:2024:decoupling . In particular, the q^{2} dependence of m^{2}(q^{2}) is a physical effect that is present regardless of the renormalization scheme. The contribution from gauge bosons can be made gauge-parameter invariant by absorbing non-invariant terms to the vertices, thanks to the Ward–Takahashi identity. The result coincides with the Feynman gauge choice, which we assume from now on Cornwall:1982 ; Binosi:Papavassiliou:2009 ; Papavassiliou:1997fn ; Papavassiliou:1997pb ; virtual . What runs is the mass function m^{2}(q^{2}) , the full momentum-dependent dressing. The pole mass is a fixed number; it does not run. The power-law behavior at momenta far from the pole is a prediction; the pole mass itself is data. The mass function m^{2}(q^{2}) is the same kind of object as the running coupling \alpha_{s}(q^{2}) Gross:Wilczek:1973 ; Politzer:1973 : both are gauge-invariant, physically measurable, and defined at the recoil momentum of the process. Two properties of the mass function are central to what follows. 1. Decoupling The complete renormalization ( 2 ) removes the leading sensitivity to heavy fields. A field of mass M^{2}\gg q^{2} contributes Choi:2024:decoupling ; Choi:2024:stability \Sigma_{\text{ren}}^{\text{heavy}}(q^{2})={\cal O}\left(\frac{(q^{2}-m_{h}^{2})^{2}}{M^{2}}\right), (3) extending the Appelquist–Carazzone theorem Appelquist:Carazzone:1975 to the super-renormalizable scalar mass. In ( 3 ), m_{h} and M are both pole masses—physical, measurable quantities—so the suppression is a physical statement, independent of any scheme or convention. Figure 1: The Higgs mass function in units of the external momentum squared, r=m^{2}(q^{2})/q^{2} , vs. external energy \sqrt{q^{2}} on a log scale. It shows power-law running up to a \log q^{2} correction and maintains order-one value up to the GUT scale. The point corresponds to the measured pole mass. The requirement (1-r)>0 bounds the SM’s perturbative domain at \sim 10^{18} GeV. 2. Power-law running of the scalar The large- q^{2} behavior of the renormalized self-energy becomes 2 2 2 To be precise, the fermion mass function is m_{f}(q)=m_{f}+\Sigma(\not{q})-\Sigma(m_{f})-(\not{q}{-}m_{f})\left[d\Sigma/d\not{q}\right]_{\not{q}=m_{f}}\equiv m_{f}+\Sigma_{\text{ren}}(\not{q}) . (see Appendix) \displaystyle\Sigma_{\text{ren}}(\not{q}) \displaystyle\sim m_{f}\log q^{2} \displaystyle\text{fermion,} (4) \displaystyle\Sigma_{\text{ren}}(q^{2}) \displaystyle\sim q^{2}\log q^{2} \displaystyle\text{scalar,} This verifies the ’t Hooft account ( 1 ). The crucial difference is that the ’t Hooft estimate gives a correction at M_{\text{GUT}} , whereas the renormalized mass function m^{2}(q^{2}) is defined at every scale and is computed bottom-up from the measured pole mass. Using m_{h}=125.08 GeV ATLAS:2023 ; CMS:2025 , the complete one-loop correction to the Higgs mass parameter (see Appendix) gives, at \sqrt{q^{2}}=M_{\text{GUT}}=10^{16} GeV, \frac{m^{2}(M_{\text{GUT}}^{2})}{M_{\text{GUT}}^{2}}\approx\underbrace{1.135}_{\text{top}}\underbrace{{}-0.169}_{W}\underbrace{{}-0.109}_{Z}+\underbrace{0.002}_{h}=+0.858, (5) which is \mathcal{O}(1) . The mass function, measured in units of the scale at which it is probed, is order one at every scale. Decoupling resolves the technical part of the hierarchy problem, which results in inconsistency Choi:2024:decoupling ; Choi:2024:stability . Super-renormalizable quantities like the Higgs mass have been suspected of violating decoupling, giving \delta m_{h}^{2}\sim M^{2} . This expectation follows from naive dimensional analysis of the unrenormalized self-energy; the complete renormalization ( 2 ) replaces it with ( 3 ). The 28 orders of magnitude between m_{h}^{2} and M_{\text{GUT}}^{2} are the natural scaling of a dimension-2 quantity that runs as q^{2} —not a hierarchy that requires explanation. The reason is nothing but the absence of symmetry protection of the scalar mass. Power-law running of the scalar The total can be written as ( v=246 GeV is the Higgs vacuum expectation value) \frac{\Sigma_{\text{ren}}^{\text{SM}}}{q^{2}}=\frac{N_{c}m_{t}^{2}}{8\pi^{2}v^{2}}\log\frac{q^{2}}{m_{t}^{2}}-\cdots\approx 0.0142\log\frac{q^{2}}{m_{\text{EW}}^{2}}-0.045, (6) where m_{\text{EW}} denotes a representative electroweak mass ( m_{t} , m_{W} , m_{Z} are all \mathcal{O}(m_{\text{EW}}) ; threshold differences are absorbed into the constant). The leading top coefficient N_{c}m_{t}^{2}/(8\pi^{2}v^{2})=0.0187 ( N_{c}=3 is the