Thermodynamic criticality in seismicity: Uniqueness of surface-energy scaling in the fragment-asperity model

O. Sotolongo-Costa, A. V. Mora-Rodríguez, M. E. Mora-Ramos · 2026

Read Thermodynamic criticality in seismicity: Uniqueness of surface-energy scaling in the fragment-asperity model by O. Sotolongo-Costa, A. V. Mora-Rodríguez, M. E. Mora-Ramos (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2603-14759.txt.

Introduction

Sotolongo-Costa, Mora-Rodríguez and Mora-Ramos test entropy scaling in a fragment-asperity earthquake model. Stress-bearing contacts carry energy tied to their contact surface. A linear energy-surface law is put forward as the sole workable choice. Only it yields a closed, clean total Tsallis entropy in the parameter q. Scanning q marks a critical band from about 1.4 to 1.8. Entropy swings hardest inside that band. Reported main-shock q values from recent decades mostly land there. The band casts q as a criticality gauge, they argue.

Catalog record

CREATORO. Sotolongo-Costa, A. V. Mora-Rodríguez, M. E. Mora-Ramos
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE32433
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2603.14759

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Thermodynamic criticality in seismicity: Uniqueness of surface-energy scaling in the fragment-asperity model O. Sotolongo-Costa, A. V. Mora-Rodríguez, M. E. Mora-Ramos Abstract We propose that a linear relation between the energy of stress-bearing interactions and the surface of contact within the fragment-asperity model for earthquakes. It reveals as the only one that leads to a closed elementary form for a well-defined total entropy as a function of non-extensivity parameter, q q . By writing the total Tsallis entropy as a function of q q , a critical range of values is identified: 1.4 ≲ q ≲ 1.8 1.4\lesssim q\lesssim 1.8 . Such interval of q q -values corresponds to the strong variation of entropy and contains the most of reported results for this parameter determined for main-shocks around the world in recent decades, indicating the role of q q as a criticality indicator, more than just a fitting parameter. I Introduction Earthquakes result from the sudden release of accumulated strain along tectonic faults, a process governed by stick-slip dynamics and heterogeneous stress distributions. The inherent complexity of fault systems—characterized by fractal geometries, scale-invariant stress correlations, and nonlinear interactions—makes deterministic earthquake prediction an elusive goal. Instead, statistical and thermodynamic approaches have emerged as powerful tools for understanding seismic phenomena. Among these, Non-Extensive Statistical Mechanics (NESM), introduced by Tsallis (1988) 23 ; 24 , provides a robust framework for describing systems with long-range interactions, multifractality, and strong correlations—features intrinsic to seismogenesis. The fragment-asperity model, which conceptualizes fault zones as a collection of irregular, stress-bearing fragments (asperities) embedded in a viscoelastic matrix, aligns naturally with NESM, offering a way to describe the statistical distribution of earthquake magnitudes and energy release. The analysis of seismic events using NESM, particularly Tsallis entropy, has provided significant insights into the complex dynamics of earthquakes. Several studies have demonstrated the presence of non-extensivity in earthquake magnitude and inter-event time distributions, supporting the applicability of Tsallis statistics in seismology. Silva et al . 16 and Vilar et al . 28 were among the first to apply NESM to seismic catalogs, showing that earthquake magnitude distributions deviate from the traditional Gutenberg-Richter law and are better described by a q -exponential distribution. In subsequent years, several authors have reported on the NESM treatment in relation with different tectonic seismic events throughout the world 4 ; 19 ; 20 ; 18 ; 27 ; 26 ; 21 ; 10 ; 1 ; 15 ; 6 . Figure 1 : (Top panel - Pre-seismic phase) Before an earthquake occurs, the system exhibits heterogeneous stress distribution and a broad spectrum of fragment sizes. (Bottom panel - Co-seismic phase) The earthquake rupture process leads to fragmentation of asperities and breakdown of barriers, resulting in size homogenization of the fractured materials. As pointed out by Barahona Cárdenas and Araujo Soria, the complex system under study also encompasses all faults in the Earth’s crust, which themselves exhibit intricate structural properties. By applying nonextensive statistical analysis to subduction zones, we can account for the diverse mechanisms driving seismic activity. Such systems are characterized by long-range spatio-temporal correlations, non-Markovian processes (indicating long-term memory effects), additive and multiplicative noise in mesoscopic Langevin-type equations, weak chaos with near-zero Lyapunov exponents, multifractal geometry, and long-range interactions in many-body systems. Additionally, they often involve nonlinear and/or inhomogeneous mesoscopic Fokker-Planck equations 1 . Within this context, the fragment-asperity model considers this complexity and describes the tectonic plates having numerous surface asperities with variable size and a whole distribution of fragments accommodating in between. It can be said that all asperities interact to each other via the stress propagation through the fragments. Therefore, this interaction has long range nature. In the relative motion of subduction certain asperities can break, giving origin to a seismic event. Sotolongo and Posadas put forward this idea in 2004 17 , and extended it in 2023 11 . Their proposal allowed to modify the Gutenberg-Richter (GR) law into one that includes the q -parameter. This makes possible to determine q from the analysis of earthquake catalogs. Examples of the most recent studies along these lines are the references 1 ; 15 ; 6 . Essentially, the fragment-asperity model relies on the following physical picture: Before an earthquake occurs, the system exhibits heterogeneous stress distribution and a broad spectrum of fragment sizes. This configuration allows for numerous possible microscopic configurations (”microstates”), corresponding to a state of relatively high entropy. Then, the earthquake rupture process leads to fragmentation of asperities and breakdown of barriers, resulting in size homogenization of the fractured materials. This reduction in geometric variability decreases the number of allowable microstates, causing a sudden drop in entropy. The entropy reduction occurs rapidly during the dynamic rupture phase, followed by gradual recovery as tectonic stresses begin to rebuild in the post-seismic period 11 . A schematic representation of the fragment-asperity situation in a tectonic seismic phenomenon appears in Fig. 1. In this work, we provide an explanation for the above-mentioned interval of criticality for the q -parameter reported in many situations linked to tectonic earthquakes. This is done within the fragment-asperity model by making the novel assumption that the energy is, actually, proportional to the surface of interacting elements (asperities and fragments). Then, the calculation of total entropy, S , leads to a functional dependence of this quantity versus q in which it is straightforward to identify the role of this parameter by maximizing S(q) . We are also aimed at discussing the possible role of q -value as a useful tool in accessing seismic hazard. II Theoretical Framework The main assumption within the original non-extensive treatment of the fragment-asperity model 17 is that the released seismic energy, \varepsilon is directly related to the size of the fragments that occupy the space between fault blocks in tectonic plates: \varepsilon\sim r . The revision made by Silva et al. put forward a volume-related relationship \varepsilon\sim r^{3} , and a consequent statistical treatment and its relation with G-R description was given 16 . The same treatment is adopted by Telesca, who considers the relation \sigma\sim\varepsilon^{2/3} linking the area of fragments and the released energy to derive an expression relating q and the G-R parameter b 21 ; 22 . However, in the present study we propose that the seismic energy is, actually, proportional to the contact surface of the fragments: \varepsilon\sim\sigma . This assumption is physically grounded in the classical Griffith theory of fracture 7 and the subsequent applications of ideas based on surface energy, brittle rupture and interfacial contacts to the case of fragments that displace with mutual friction 2 ; 3 ; 5 ; 13 ; 12 . According to that theory, the energy balance governing crack nucleation and propagation is dominated by competition between the elastic energy released in the volume and the surface energy required to create new fracture interfaces. At the breaking threshold, the main energetic cost is associated with the creation and evolution of surfaces, implying that energy dissipation is essentially interfacial rather than volumetric. Concepts along the same lines have been relevant to establish a relation between asperities, surface creation and energy dissipation in fault zones, explaining friction and seismicity as interfacial processes (see a broader discussion in the book by Scholz 14 ) . Within the

Read the complete text