Dynamic Theory of Mind as a Temporal Memory Problem: Evidence from Large Language Models

Thuy Ngoc Nguyen, Duy Nhat Phan, Cleotilde Gonzalez · 2026

Read Dynamic Theory of Mind as a Temporal Memory Problem: Evidence from Large Language Models by Thuy Ngoc Nguyen, Duy Nhat Phan, Cleotilde Gonzalez (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2603-14646.txt.

Introduction

Nguyen, Phan and Gonzalez treat dynamic theory of mind as a temporal memory problem. Most tests ask for a belief judgment at one moment. Real social tracking needs beliefs kept and updated over time. Their DToM-Track frame probes multiturn conversations for three skills. Models must recall old beliefs, infer current ones and spot belief change. Current beliefs come easily to the models tested. Past beliefs fade once updates land, across model families and scales. The pattern mirrors recency bias known from cognitive science, they note.

Catalog record

CREATORThuy Ngoc Nguyen, Duy Nhat Phan, Cleotilde Gonzalez
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE28554
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2603.14646

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Dynamic Theory of Mind as a Temporal Memory Problem: Evidence from Large Language Models Thuy Ngoc Nguyen, Duy Nhat Phan, Cleotilde Gonzalez Abstract Theory of Mind (ToM) is central to social cognition and human–AI interaction, and Large Language Models (LLMs) have been used to help understand and represent ToM. However, most evaluations treat ToM as a static judgment at a single moment, primarily relying on tests of false beliefs. This overlooks a key dynamic dimension of ToM: the ability to represent, update, and retrieve others’ beliefs over time. We investigate dynamic ToM as a temporally extended representational memory problem, asking whether LLMs can track belief trajectories across interactions rather than only inferring current beliefs. We introduce DToM-Track, an evaluation framework to investigate temporal belief reasoning in controlled multi-turn conversations, testing the recall of beliefs held prior to an update, the inference of current beliefs, and the detection of belief change. Using LLMs as computational probes, we find a consistent asymmetry: models reliably infer an agent’s current belief but struggle to maintain and retrieve prior belief states once updates occur. This pattern persists across LLM model families and scales, and is consistent with recency bias and interference effects well documented in cognitive science. These results suggest that tracking belief trajectories over time poses a distinct challenge beyond classical false-belief reasoning. By framing ToM as a problem of temporal representation and retrieval, this work connects ToM to core cognitive mechanisms of memory and interference and exposes the implications for LLM models of social reasoning in extended human-AI interactions. Keywords: Theory of mind; temporal belief tracking; large language models; social cognition; human–AI interaction. Introduction Theory of Mind (ToM) refers to the capacity to represent and reason about others’ unobserved mental states, such as beliefs, intentions, and desires, as internal representations that guide social interaction ( Premack & Woodruff 1978a ) . While ToM is often studied as belief attribution at a single moment, social reasoning in natural interaction unfolds over time: agents must infer current beliefs while maintaining and retrieving earlier belief representations as new information is introduced. This temporally extended aspect of ToM is essential for everyday conversation, where beliefs are revised, corrected, or displaced over time, and is increasingly critical in human–AI interaction, where systems must adapt to users’ evolving goals and beliefs ( Walsh et al. 2025a ; Lee et al. 2020a ) . Cognitive science research suggests that the success of such temporal belief tracking is shaped by general-purpose memory and judgment mechanisms that operate over time ( Hogarth & Einhorn 1992a ) . In particular, belief reasoning is systematically influenced by recency bias, whereby recent information disproportionately affects judgments ( Murdock 1962a ) , as well as by interference effects, in which updated representations compete with and disrupt access to earlier belief states ( Hoch 1984a ; Birch & Bloom 2007a ) . These mechanisms imply that retrieving prior beliefs after an update may pose a distinct cognitive challenge, even when current belief attribution remains accurate. From this perspective, ToM is not only a matter of representational competence but also of maintaining and retrieving mental state representations under temporal and memory constraints. Despite evidence that belief reasoning over time is shaped by recency and interference, most of the ToM literature, both in cognitive science and in computational modeling, has focused on static belief attribution ( Hu et al. 2025a ) . Canonical tasks typically ask what an agent believes at a single moment (e.g.,“What does X believe?”), often contrasting that belief with reality in false belief paradigms ( Wimmer & Perner 1983a ; Le et al. 2019a ) . While such tasks have been instrumental in establishing the representational nature of ToM, they treat belief attribution as a snapshot inference rather than as a process unfolding over interaction. As a result, it remains underspecified how mental state representations are maintained, updated, and retrieved over time, and how memory constraints affect access to earlier beliefs once new information is introduced. Moreover, this emphasis on false belief has narrowed the scope of ToM evaluation, despite evidence that social reasoning involves a broader range of mental states, including intentions, desires, emotions, and knowledge ( Ma et al. 2023a ) . (a) Example interaction with hidden inner speech and planned belief updates. Pre-Update (prior belief) Post-Update (current belief) Update Detection Before Turn 3, what did Alex believe about reservations? After Turn 4, what does Alex believe about reservations? At which turn did Alex’s belief change? (A) 24-hour notice required (B) Online booking only (C) No reservations needed (D) Same-day accepted ✓ (A) Same-day accepted (B) No reservations needed (C) 24-hour notice required ✓ (D) Online booking only (A) Turn 2 (B) Turn 3–4 ✓ (C) Turn 5 (D) Did not change (b) Illustrative temporal question types evaluating prior belief, current belief, and belief-change timing. Figure 1: Illustration of DToM-Track. (a) Role-playing interaction with information asymmetry induced by hidden inner speech and mid-conversation belief updates. (b) Examples of temporal questions examining belief recall and change. Computational cognitive approaches that use artificial agents to test hypotheses about the structure and limitations of human social reasoning provide an initial means to isolate temporal and memory components of ToM that are difficult to observe in static evaluations ( Baker et al. 2011a ; Nguyen & Gonzalez 2022a ; Kostka & Chudziak 2025a ) . However, many existing approaches model belief attribution as inference over a limited state space, emphasizing belief updating while underemphasizing belief maintenance, retrieval after revision, and interference over extended interaction. Contemporary large language models (LLMs) can successfully infer others’ mental states in constrained one-shot settings ( Brown et al. 2020a ; Kosinski 2023a ) , largely by encoding broad patterns of human behavior from large scale training data. However, their performance varies widely across tasks and formulations ( Strachan et al. 2024a ; Street et al. 2025a ; Ullman 2023a ; Shapira et al. 2024a ) . We adopt the view that LLMs can serve as computational probes for examining how belief representations are constructed and accessed over time. In particular, evaluating whether models can retrieve beliefs held prior to an update, rather than only inferring the current belief state, isolates temporal and memory-related components of ToM that are unclear in static evaluations. To operationalize this temporally extended view of ToM, we introduce DToM-Track, an evaluation framework designed to probe how mental state representations are maintained, updated, and retrieved across interaction (Fig. 1 ). DToM-Track tests whether LLMs can track belief trajectories over the course of a conversation, including recalling beliefs held prior to a change, inferring beliefs after an update, and identifying when belief revisions occur. The framework adopts a controlled generation paradigm based on inner-speech prompting ( Shinoda et al. 2025a ) , in which agents verbalize their mental states before each utterance while these internal representations remain concealed from their conversational partners. This induced information asymmetry ( Guo et al. 2023a ) mirrors false belief settings ( Wimmer & Perner 1983a ; Braüner et al. 2020a ) and enables systematic evaluation of mental states. By maintaining structured mental states across turns, DToM-Track isolates temporal and memory-dependent components of ToM that are absent from static evaluations. Using controlled LLM–LLM conversations, DToM-Track

Read the complete text