Evaluating Calibration-Based Digital Twins for IBM Quantum Hardware Simulation
Edgars Bautra, Maksims Dimitrijevs, Abuzer Yakaryılmaz · 2026
Read Evaluating Calibration-Based Digital Twins for IBM Quantum Hardware Simulation by Edgars Bautra, Maksims Dimitrijevs, Abuzer Yakaryılmaz (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2603-14607.txt.
Introduction
Bautra, Dimitrijevs and Yakaryilmaz test calibration-based digital twins of IBM quantum hardware. A twin should mimic real device outcomes on a classical simulator. Twins here grow from public calibration files. Coherence times and error rates map to thermal, depolarizing and readout noise channels. A directed coupling map restores device connectivity during transpilation. Four twin types run five-qubit circuits on two IBM machines. CSV-built twins often match hardware best, they find. Match quality still shifts with device and transpiler settings.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Edgars Bautra, Maksims Dimitrijevs, Abuzer Yakaryılmaz |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 36391 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2603.14607
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Evaluating Calibration-Based Digital Twins for IBM Quantum Hardware Simulation Edgars Bautra, Maksims Dimitrijevs, Abuzer Yakaryılmaz Abstract We evaluate calibration-based digital twins for IBM Quantum hardware, aiming to reproduce hardware measurement outcomes on classical simulators. We present a workflow that builds twins from downloadable calibration CSV files by mapping coherence times, gate and readout error rates, and operation durations to thermal-relaxation, depolarizing, and readout error channels, while reconstructing a directed coupling map to restore connectivity constraints during transpilation. We compare four twin variants (CSV-built, backend-derived simulator, backend-derived noise model, and fake-backend snapshots) under a common execution and validation protocol. Experiments on two IBM QPUs, ibm_brisbane and ibm_sherbrooke , use randomized five-qubit circuits of depths 10, 20, and 30 across four optimization levels. Weighted Jaccard similarity indicates that twins constructed from downloadable calibration CSV data often achieved the closest agreement with hardware, while backend-derived twins provided competitive and practical baselines. The results further show that agreement depends on both the target device and the transpilation settings, underscoring the need to validate digital twins for the specific execution setup rather than assuming transferability across devices. 1 Introduction In today’s world, quantum computers as a technology are undergoing rapid development. Although there are large companies, such as IBM , that offer access to these computers through their cloud services [ 1 ] , demand still exceeds availability, leading to long queues of submitted circuits, because of which certain restrictions have been introduced, such as limited available computational time [ 2 ] . Quantum computer simulators can be of considerable help with this situation, allowing anyone to create and run circuits on everyday devices – classical computers, based on recreated properties of quantum physics [ 3 ] . In addition, less computational resources of quantum computers are being used by reducing the workload from unnecessary jobs that can be completed on simulators. Even so, there is one characteristic property of quantum computers that can cause the expected results to change in unpredictable ways – noise, including decoherence, gate errors, and readout errors [ 4 ] , which makes ideal simulation insufficient. This creates a need for calibration-based digital twins of quantum computers, i.e., simulator configurations that use noise models built from device-specific calibration information to approximate the noisy behavior of a corresponding real device. Availability of digital twins can compensate the restricted availability to real Quantum Processing Units (QPUs), as well as allow one to do preliminary testing before running jobs on QPUs, thus sparing quantum computational resources. Recent research explicitly frames calibration-based emulation as a digital twin problem. In particular, calibration-driven emulation of superconducting transmon devices has been presented as a way to build a digital twin from calibration data and additional benchmarking information, showing that hardware-aware emulation can improve agreement with the behavior of a real device [ 5 ] . At the same time, Qiskit already provides practical support for noisy simulation based on backends, and IBM makes QPU calibration data downloadable as CSV [ 6 , 7 ] . It is important to note that Qiskit can automatically configure a simulator to mimic an available backend via its specific methods such as AerSimulator.from_backend() , while constructing a twin directly from downloadable calibration CSV files is not provided as a native end-to-end workflow in Qiskit. CSV files open up the possibilities to work with digital twins based on a wider range of QPUs, including ones not available to user. Calibration CSV data derived from IBM has been used in quantum digital twin and simulation contexts. For example, Luo et al. imported calibration data of IBM QPUs collected as CSV files, and extend the twin concept to quantum-cloud operations like job lifecycle and fidelity estimation [ 8 ] . Simulation frameworks such as “iQuantum” support importing IBM-style calibration CSV datasets for modeling quantum computing environments [ 9 ] . These studies show the value of calibration-aware simulation; however, to the best of our knowledge, they do not describe a practical, Qiskit-native workflow for building circuit-executable twins directly from downloadable IBM calibration CSV files and validating them against IBM hardware measurement distributions. This leaves a gap for users seeking simulators that capture both device noise and execution constraints. We address this gap by developing and validating calibration-based digital twins of IBM Quantum hardware using Qiskit and downloadable IBM calibration CSV data. We build noise models from calibration attributes and reconstruct the directional coupling information needed for device-faithful simulation. We compare this CSV-based approach with backend-derived and snapshot-based alternatives and validate all twin variants against real IBM QPU outputs using Weighted Jaccard Similarity. The results show that twins based on CSV are feasible and often highly competitive, while backend-derived twins remain strong practical baselines. The code, results of our experiments, and device calibration data files are publicly available at https://github.com/BautraE/precise-qpu-simulation-extras . The remainder of the paper is organized as follows. Section 2 presents the main contributions of the paper. Section 3 describes the technical details of the conducted research. Section 4 presents the results and discussion, including implications, limitations, and concluding remarks. 2 Main Contributions The main contributions of this paper are as follows: • We present a practical method for constructing a QPU digital twin from downloadable IBM calibration CSV data, including the use of calibration attributes for noise-model creation and a workaround for reconstructing directional coupling information required for device-faithful transpilation and simulation. • We formalize and compare four digital twin variants based on different sources of device and noise information – custom noise models built from downloadable calibration CSV files, backend-derived simulator and noise-model variants, and fake-backend snapshots. • We introduce a validation procedure based on Weighted Jaccard Similarity for comparing measured state-count outputs from QPU runs and simulator runs under a common evaluation protocol. • We investigate the impact of shot count on result stability and select a practical shot budget for calibration-based digital twin evaluation. • We provide an empirical validation study on two IBM Quantum QPUs, using three randomly generated five-qubit circuits and four transpiler optimization levels to compare hardware results with simulator results across all twin variants. 3 Technical Details 3.1 Problem setting and digital twin definition Local simulation allows us to compensate for constraints on access to real quantum hardware. When preparing and testing circuits before execution on a real QPU, the usefulness of local simulation depends on how closely the simulator reproduces the noisy behavior of the QPU. In this paper, the problem is formulated as a digital twin validation problem. We evaluate the output similarity between real-device runs and simulator runs produced by multiple twin variants (agreement of measured circuit-execution results under noisy conditions). We define calibration-based digital twin of a QPU as a simulator instance parameterized with device information in order to approximate the noisy execution behavior of that device. The digital twin consists of: • a simulator backend configuration; • a noise model; • device execution constraints (e.g., basis gates and coupling topology) relevant for transpilation and simulation; • an execution workflow that returns measurement counts comparable to QPU runs. 3.2 Validation Goal and Acceptance Criteria Our goal is to validate whether the twin is useful for reproducing circuit outputs observed for a QPU, i.e., whether the received results from a circuit execution