Bridging the Gap in the Responsible AI Divides

Bálint Gyevnár, Atoosa Kasirzadeh, [3pt] Institute for Complex Social Dynamics, Carnegie Mellon University, Pittsburgh, USA, [-1pt] Departments of Philosophy & Software and Societal Systems, Carnegie Mellon University, Pittsburgh, USA [3pt] [email protected], [email protected] · 2026

Read Bridging the Gap in the Responsible AI Divides by Bálint Gyevnár, Atoosa Kasirzadeh, [3pt] Institute for Complex Social Dynamics, Carnegie Mellon University, Pittsburgh, USA, [-1pt] Departments of Philosophy & Software and Societal Systems, Carnegie Mellon University, Pittsburgh, USA [3pt] [email protected], [email protected] (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2603-14495.txt.

Introduction

Gyevnár and Kasirzadeh map a split inside responsible AI work. AI safety and AI ethics camps often clash over which risks matter most. The authors name four ways to engage with this divide. Options range from open clash to shared work across the gap. They weigh the gains and costs of each mode. A study of 3,555 papers then maps both research fields. Shared problems exist, they find, but ethics work stresses real harms while safety work stresses future risks.

Catalog record

CREATORBálint Gyevnár, Atoosa Kasirzadeh, [3pt] Institute for Complex Social Dynamics, Carnegie Mellon University, Pittsburgh, USA, [-1pt] Departments of Philosophy & Software and Societal Systems, Carnegie Mellon University, Pittsburgh, USA [3pt] [email protected], [email protected]
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE93873
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2603.14495

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Bridging the Gap in the Responsible AI Divides Bálint Gyevnár, Atoosa Kasirzadeh, [3pt] Institute for Complex Social Dynamics, Carnegie Mellon University, Pittsburgh, USA, [-1pt] Departments of Philosophy & Software and Societal Systems, Carnegie Mellon University, Pittsburgh, USA [3pt] [email protected], [email protected] Abstract Tensions between AI Safety (AIS) and AI Ethics (AIE) have increasingly surfaced in AI governance and public debates about AI, leading to what we term the “responsible AI divides.” We introduce a model that categorizes four modes of engagement with the tensions: radical confrontation, disengagement, compartmentalized coexistence, and critical bridging. We then investigate how critical bridging, with a particular focus on bridging problems, offers one of the most viable constructive paths for advancing responsible AI. Using computational tools to analyze a curated dataset of 3,550 3,550 papers, we map the research landscapes of AIE and AIS to identify both distinct and overlapping problems. Our findings point to both thematic divides and overlaps. For example, we find that AIE has long grappled with overcoming injustice and tangible AI harms, whereas AIS has primarily embodied an anticipatory approach focused on the mitigation of risks from AI capabilities. At the same time, we find significant overlap in core research concerns across both AIE and AIS around transparency, reproducibility, and inadequate governance mechanisms. As AIE and AIS continue to evolve, we recommend focusing on bridging problems as a constructive path forward for enhancing collaborative AI governance. We offer a series of recommendations to integrate shared considerations into a collaborative approach to responsible AI. Alongside our proposal, we highlight its limitations and explore open problems for future research. All data including the fully annotated dataset of papers with code to reproduce our figures can be found at: https://github.com/gyevnarb/ai-safety-ethics . Keywords: AI Ethics; AI Safety; AI Governance; Responsible AI 1 Introduction Tensions between “AI Safety” (AIS) and “AI Ethics” (AIE) increasingly shape how governments, firms, and researchers define “responsible AI”, and thus which risks from AI systems are prioritized, which are sidelined, and which risk mitigation strategies are ultimately developed and implemented. Over the past few years, the relationship between AIS and AIE has grown more complex and contentious [ 253 , 250 , 225 ] , giving rise to what we call the “responsible AI divide”: ongoing struggles between AIS and AIE over how to prioritize and allocate scarce resources, such as public attention, public informedness, preparedness, and funding across competing concerns about the development, deployment, and governance of AI systems. These tensions arise from divergent views about the nature, salience, and tractability of AI risks, including their origins, scope, and appropriate responses [ 235 , 182 , 6 , 150 , 107 ] . As AI development accelerates, the stakes for responsible implementation have never been higher. How do we meaningfully minimize AIE and AIS tensions from sabotaging collaboration? In this paper, we respond to this question in two ways. Figure 1: Four resolution modes for responsible AI divides. The modes differ in the extent to which they directly engage tensions between AI ethics (AIE) and AI safety (AIS), and in whether such engagement produces constructive integration or instead reproduces division. First, we distinguish between four modes of engaging with the responsible AI divides, illustrated in Figure 1 : (1) radical confrontation by active, direct efforts to primarily discredit or delegitimize the opposing side; (2) disengagement by the refusal or withdrawal from substantive engagement with the other side; (3) compartmentalized coexistence by pursuing separate agendas in a live-and-let-live fashion while acknowledging each side only rhetorically; and (4) critical bridging by explicitly mapping points of divergence while seeking good-faith common ground and concrete opportunities for collaboration in ways that empowers joint efforts for scaling responsible AI without flattening or suppressing unresolvable disagreement. Second, we argue that the fourth mode of engagement, critical bridging, would perhaps offer one of the most pragmatically useful approaches for governing AI technologies in a responsible way. The notion of “bridging” itself is ambiguous, and can be interpreted in three (potentially overlapping) ways: (i) bridging communities and forging institutional, social, or epistemic links between AIS and AIE communities; (ii) bridging worldviews and philosophical standpoints , and connecting the moral and political value systems and norms that structure or govern each community; and (iii) bridging problems by identifying shared problem spaces and challenges. This paper makes a case for (iii) bridging problems. We investigate the potential for bridging AIE and AIS problems through four distinct phases: mapping the literature, identifying commonalities, distinguishing differences, and evaluating bridging mechanisms: (1) We create a visual map of AI ethics and AI safety research paper based on a systematic literature review. (2) We identify common research problems, risks, and mitigation strategies addressed in AI ethics and AI safety. (3) We identify the non-overlapping, distinct research problems addressed in AI ethics and AI safety. (4) We discuss whether and how AIS and AIE research problems can be bridged, what aspects cannot, and how can we approach this bridging process. By mapping connections between common challenges and clarifying disagreements, we believe this approach can create meaningful, cascading progress across shared visions for responsible AI. Over time, this builds new capacities for collaborative epistemics and collective action. The development of professional bodies such as the International Association for Safe and Ethical AI (IASEAI) [ 138 ] , alongside research explicitly examining the intricate intersection of AIE and AIS [ 150 , 107 ] shows already existing bridging efforts. Building on them, we advance a bolder bridging claim by providing structural support for it. We use a systematic literature review to carefully collect a dataset comprising 1,770 AIE and 1,780 AIS papers. For each corpus, we examine the types of risks that are foregrounded and the risk mitigation strategies that are proposed. We use computational methods, in particular unsupervised topic modeling using state-of-the-art natural language processing techniques, and qualitative analysis via deductive coding, to construct a visual map of AIS and AIE research by identifying common and distinct problem clusters in each field. In particular, we identify shared risk concerns and shared mitigation strategies. We then discuss how these clusters can be linked as sites of potential critical bridging. The rest of the paper is structured as follows. In Section 2 , we give detailed descriptions of the four engagement modes, highlighting their practices and risks. In Section 3 , we present our methods including our data collection approach, computational analysis methods, and the qualitative deductive annotation process. In Section 4 , we present quantitative results then compare the risks and mitigation strategies addressed by AIE and AIS based on our annotations. Further results are also presented in Appendix A . Finally, in Section 5 , we discuss five concrete remaining open questions and assess the limitations of our approach and methodologies. 2 Responsible AI Divides While responsible AI is a broad concept, this paper focuses on a specific subset of research from AIE and AIS. We examine these as contemporary representatives of the field [ 37 , 174 ] , discussing limitations of this approach in Section 5 , and analyzing the ongoing tensions between these two domains. Our analysis is based on a combined dataset of N=3,550 papers retrieved as of July 9, 2025. The AIE corpus

Read the complete text