Quantum potential with no perturbative series, and nonperturbative vacuum dominated by complex classical paths
Edward Shuryak · 2026
Read Quantum potential with no perturbative series, and nonperturbative vacuum dominated by complex classical paths by Edward Shuryak (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2603-14467.txt.
Introduction
Shuryak studies a quantum potential built so its perturbative series vanishes. Standard 1D potentials yield spectra as trans-series in the coupling. Those series mix fast-growing perturbative terms with nonperturbative terms. Each part alone is ill defined, though the sum should be sound. Shuryak picks couplings that remove the perturbative part in full. He then computes the nonperturbative vacuum energy. Complex solutions of the holomorphic Newton equation match that energy, he shows.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Edward Shuryak |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 19601 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2603.14467
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Quantum potential with no perturbative series, and nonperturbative vacuum dominated by complex classical paths Edward Shuryak Abstract Spectra of standard 1d potentials (double-well, sin-Gordon etc) are given by trans-series in coupling, including (badly divergent) perturbative series (PS), and nonperturbative terms ∼ e x p ( − c o n s t / g 2 ) \sim exp(-const/g^{2}) and l o g ( 1 / g ) e x p ( − c o n s t / g 2 ) log(1/g)exp(-const/g^{2}) . All of them are badly defined (e.g. PS are badly divergent) but in sum supposed to be good. In this paper we discuss an example of a potential with specially defined couplings making PS completely absent. We calculate its nonperturbative vacuum energy and show that they are reproduced by the action of certain complex solutions to holomorphic Newton equation. I Introduction Perhaps the most spectacular early example of how Quantum Mechanics is different from the classical one was semiclassical description of tunneling 5 . It spectacularly described \alpha decays and spontaneous fissions of heavy nuclei, covering the range of probabilities spanning about 20 orders of magnitude. Instanton, a space-time soliton in gauge theories 2 , plays a very important role in gauge dynamics. As was shown in my early “instanton liquid model" (ILM) 6 and confirmed in many subsequent work, instantons create spontaneous breaking of the chiral symmetry in QCD, being thus responsible for effective quark mass (and thus, the mass of nucleons and ourselves). Lately, numerical simulations on the lattice and phenomenological studies also point to important role of correlated instanton-antiinstanton pairs, or molecules. For recent review see e.g. 7 . Very extensive developments of semiclassical theory, based on Feynman path integrals in imaginary time, was slowly developed in the meantime. The instantons were discussed in many more settings. The most studied is the double well potential (DWP) with a potential V_{DWP}\sim(x^{2}-f^{2})^{2} (1) with two degenerate minima, at x=\pm f . Tunneling between them lifts degeneracy of the spectrum and establishes parity ( x\leftrightarrow-x ) as the true quantum number. Further developments of semiclassical theory was formulating it in QFT terms. Using Feynman diagrams allows in principle calculate corrections to the instanton amplitude to any loop order. In particular, corrections up to three loops have been calculated 4 . In Fig. 1 we compare the one-, two-, and three-loop semiclassical expressions to actual gaps (splitting between lowest negative-to-positive parity states) E_{-}-E_{+} computed numerically and given as a function of the instanton action S . This plot demonstrate that, with fluctuations to few loop included, semiclassical theory becomes rather accurate, even at not-so-large values of the action S\sim 3\hbar . Figure 1: The splitting of the negative-parity state from the vacuum, gap=E_{-}-E_{+} , shown as data points. The three curves correspond to one-, two-, and three-loop semiclassical approximations. A wider perspective on semiclassics relates it to old questions of mathematics on representing solutions as series in parameters. Dependence of physical observables (such as the vacuum energy we will mostly discuss below) on coefficients of the action should in general be expressed as the so called trans-series . Those combine (badly divergent) perturbative series ( \sum a_{n}g^{n} ) with nonperturbative terms ( \sim exp(-const/g^{2}) times another series \sum b_{n}g^{n} ), for a review see e.g. 3 . Nontrivial relations between a_{n} and b_{n} coefficients is known as resurgence relations. While those are fulfilled in known examples (e.g. by two and three-loop corrections just mentioned) their generality, or even existence in the QFT context, remains a mystery. Since early 1980’s, a number of boson-fermion examples were given in the context of supersymmetric quantum mechanics 9 . In those supersymmetry holds perturbatively but gets broken nonperturbatively, by instantons. One example 8 , with potential V_{T0}=a^{2}x^{6}-2ax^{4}+(1+3a)x^{2}-1 (2) was studied extensively, showing that vacuum energy is indeed exponentially small \sim~a^{1/2}\exp{-const/a} at small a . In current paper we focus on other special 1d QM Hamiltonian H=(p^{2}+x^{2}-1)+(a^{2}x^{4}+2ax^{3}-2ax) (3) suggested to us by A.Turbiner (private communication). First of all, we will prove in the next section a total vanishing of perturbative series (all a_{n}=0 ), done without any use of fermions or supersymmetry. Yet the noperturbative effects still apparently exist, and our further study would be to look for semiclassical paths responsible for the vacuum energy. In doing so, we will follow 1 , who introduced a notion of “complex bions", solutions of he holomorphic Newton’s equation (HNE). Let us remind that this work was set for tilted double well (TDW) with potentials \displaystyle V_{\pm}(x) \displaystyle= \displaystyle{1\over 2}(W^{\prime}(x))^{2}\pm{p\over 2}W^{\prime\prime}(x), \displaystyle W(x) \displaystyle= \displaystyle x^{3}/3-x (4) and parameter p close to 1. Flipping the potential ( V\rightarrow-V ) in Euclidean time formulation, one observes that real paths starting from the global maximum cannot have a finite action. There exist however complex paths, solutions to the holomorphic Newton’s equation (HNE) with finite action. A solution of such kind, or complex bion , was found in 1 by analytic continuation. Among other important observation made by 1 let us mention that HNE separated for real and imaginary parts do not correspond to motion in any 2d potential. (Another extreme path at small a can be a real "bounce" path, starting from the lower maximum and reflected from real turning point. Yet it is of no interest for us now, as it is related to the false vacuum problem and is irrelevant to current work.) I.1 Outline of the paper In this work we focus on a specific example of 1d QM problem with Hamiltonian ( 3 ). Note a bit nonstandard selection of units in the first Harmonic bracket, without usual 1/2 and with some nonzero vacuum energy subtracted. Three other terms, \sim x,x^{3},x^{4} , depend on a single parameter a , to which we will refer as the coupling constant. We will only discuss the regime of relatively small a . Note further, that its O(a) term have different powers of the coordinate, (2a)(x^{3}-x) , so a -dependence of the action cannot be absorbed by standard redefinition of the coordinate, as is the case in several examples discussed previously. In section II we will start with arbitrary coefficients of these terms. Calculating the first perturbative correction by standard perturbative series, we will show that for this Hamiltonian the correction O(a^{2}) cancel each other. Pursuing the issue to higher orders, we evaluate generic Hamiltonian matrix and show, for this case, coefficient cancellations persists to higher orders as well. (We actually checked terms O(a^{4},a^{6},a^{8}) and stopped, although it can be continued with larger and larger submatrices.) In section II.3 we switch from Schrodinger equation to its Riccati form, and show that coefficients of the perturbative series vanish to all orders (Turbiner, private communication). The nonzero vacuum energy E_{0}(a) we first simply calculate numerically in section III , see Fig. 5 . Indeed, its observed behavior is very different from that of generic potentials, for which the lowest PS terms dominate at small a . Then, following 1 , we are looking for paths in the complex plain, classical solutions of holomorphic Newton’s equations ( HNE). Unlike those authors, we solve them numerically, thus deriving a family of the complex paths with all initial directions from their starting point, the