Periodic orbits and gravitational waveforms of black holes in bumblebee gravity

Zijian Shi, Xiangdong Zhang, Yunlong Liu · 2026

Read Periodic orbits and gravitational waveforms of black holes in bumblebee gravity by Zijian Shi, Xiangdong Zhang, Yunlong Liu (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2603-14413.txt.

Introduction

Shi, Zhang, and Liu study particle orbits and gravitational waveforms around black holes in bumblebee gravity. This Einstein variant breaks Lorentz symmetry through a coupling set by one parameter. The authors work out geodesics and the effective potential for charged and uncharged holes. Charge and the Lorentz-breaking parameter widen the space of bound orbits. Periodic orbits are sorted by whirl, zoom, and vertex counts. The uncharged case matches Schwarzschild in its static potential, yet its orbit shapes differ in clear ways.

Catalog record

CREATORZijian Shi, Xiangdong Zhang, Yunlong Liu
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE45099
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2603.14413

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Periodic orbits and gravitational waveforms of black holes in bumblebee gravity Zijian Shi, Xiangdong Zhang, Yunlong Liu Abstract In this paper, we investigate the dynamics of massive particles and the associated gravitational waveforms in the spacetime of a black hole within the framework of Einstein-Bumblebee gravity. Our analysis encompasses both charged and uncharged black hole configurations, with a particular focus on the spontaneous Lorentz symmetry breaking mechanism inherent to this model, which is governed by a dimensionless coupling parameter l l . We analyze the geodesic equations and the effective potential to determine the allowed parameter space for bound orbits, demonstrating that in the charged case, both the Lorentz-violating parameter l l and the electric charge Q Q significantly enhance the confinement capacity of the potential, thereby broadening the energy and angular momentum windows for bound states. A key focus is placed on the classification and properties of periodic orbits, characterized by rational frequency ratios using the whirl, zoom, and vertex taxonomy. We demonstrate that in the uncharged case ( Q = 0 Q=0 ), the radial effective potential and standard innermost stable circular orbit (ISCO) properties are degenerate with those of a Schwarzschild black hole. However, despite this degeneracy in static potential properties, the structure of periodic orbits exhibits qualitative differences, providing a possible observational signature that can break this degeneracy. Finally, we compute the corresponding gravitational waveforms extracted from these periodic orbits using the quadrupole formula. The results reveal that l l and Q Q introduce contrasting phase-shifting effects on the waveforms. This suggests that bumblebee gravity leaves measurable imprints on gravitational-wave signals that could be detected by future space-based gravitational-wave observatories. I introduction General relativity (GR) stands as one of the pillars of modern physics, providing an elegant and empirically successful description of gravity. Its most dramatic predictions—the existence of black holes and the propagation of gravitational waves—have transitioned from theoretical curiosities to observational cornerstones, thanks to groundbreaking experiments like LIGO/Virgo LIGOScientific:2016aoc and the Event Horizon Telescope (EHT) EventHorizonTelescope:2019dse ; EventHorizonTelescope:2022wkp . These discoveries have catapulted black holes from mere mathematical solutions to prime astrophysical laboratories, where the dynamics of matter and light in the most extreme gravitational fields can be used to test the very fabric of spacetime Barack:2018yly . Despite its triumphs, GR is famously incompatible with quantum mechanics at a fundamental level, motivating the search for a unified theory. A promising avenue involves exploring potential low-energy relics of quantum gravity. One such relic is spontaneous Lorentz symmetry breaking, a phenomenon where the vacuum state of the universe picks out a preferred direction, thereby violating the isotropic symmetry of spacetime Gambini:1998it ; Ellis:1999uh ; Kostelecky:1988zi ; Kostelecky:1989jp . The Einstein-Bumblebee model offers a concrete and well-motivated effective field theory framework to investigate such Lorentz-violating effects Kostelecky:2003fs . In this model, Lorentz symmetry is spontaneously broken by a dynamical vector field (the “bumblebee” field) that couples non-minimally to the curvature of spacetime, leading to modified gravitational dynamics. A critical test for any modified gravity theory is its prediction for compact astrophysical objects, particularly black holes. The properties of black hole solutions—their event horizon structure, orbital dynamics, and emitted radiation—carry unique imprints of the underlying gravitational theory. Recently, significant progress has been made within the bumblebee gravity framework Casana:2017jkc ; Maluf:2020kgf ; Liu:2024axg ; Li:2025rjv ; Liu:2025oho ; Bailey:2025oun ; Xu:2022frb ; Marques:2023suh ; AraujoFilho:2025rvn ; Ovcharenko:2026rvj . By incorporating a non-minimal coupling between the bumblebee field and an electromagnetic field, Liu et al. derived a new class of exact charged black hole solutions Liu:2024axg . Among these is a particularly relevant solution: a charged, spherically symmetric black hole without a cosmological constant. This solution represents a Lorentz-violating generalization of the classic Reissner-Nordström (RN) black hole, characterized by an additional dimensionless parameter, l , which quantifies the strength of Lorentz symmetry breaking. This novel spacetime geometry provides a controlled, parametrized deviation from GR, ideal for studying how fundamental symmetry violations might manifest in observable astrophysical phenomena. This novel charged bumblebee black hole solution has attracted considerable attention. Subsequent research has explored various physical aspects of this spacetime Liu:2024axg ; Lambiase:2024uzy ; Ali:2025znb ; Singh:2025hor ; Singh:2025hor ; Xu:2025jvk ; Singh:2025tvk ; Li:2025itp ; Singh:2025fuv ; deOliveira:2025yeo ; Li:2026uwx . The existing literature has addressed the thermodynamic properties Liu:2024axg ; Ali:2025znb , including Hawking spectra Singh:2025tvk . The optical appearance, encompassing phenomena like black hole shadows Liu:2024axg ; Singh:2025hor ; Xu:2025jvk ; Singh:2025fuv , photon rings Xu:2025jvk , and strong gravitational lensing Singh:2025tvk , has been investigated in detail. In particular, studies have used EHT data to constrain the Lorentz-violating parameter l Lambiase:2024uzy ; Xu:2025jvk . Furthermore, field perturbations have been studied through the calculation of quasinormal modes Singh:2025hor ; Li:2025itp ; Singh:2025fuv ; deOliveira:2025yeo , providing insights into the dynamical stability of the black hole. The study of test particle dynamics around black holes is of paramount importance in the era of gravitational-wave astronomy. A prime example is extreme-mass-ratio inspirals (EMRIs), where a stellar-mass compact object orbits a supermassive black hole—a system that can be modeled as a test particle moving in a curved spacetime Babak:2017tow . These systems are recognized as primary sources for future space-based gravitational-wave observatories, including LISA LISA:2017pwj ; LISA:2022yao , TianQin TianQin:2015yph ; TianQin:2020hid , Taiji Hu:2017mde ; Ruan:2018tsw , and DECIGO Kawamura:2020pcg . Because the inspiral waveform encodes the precise geometry of the central object, it is highly sensitive to the underlying spacetime structure Amaro-Seoane:2007osp ; Gair:2012nm ; Berti:2015itd ; Cardenas-Avendano:2024mqp . Consequently, modifications to the geometry, such as that introduced by the Lorentz violation, can leave characteristic imprints on both the orbital dynamics and the resulting gravitational radiation. Therefore, geodesic analysis is not merely a theoretical exercise, but a necessity for constructing accurate waveform templates for realistic astrophysical scenarios and various theories of gravity Liu:2024qci ; Liu:2024lda ; Du:2025 . Notably, recent studies have examined time-like geodesics in this charged bumblebee black hole spacetime Xu:2025jvk ; Li:2026uwx , specifically analyzing the circular geodesics and innermost stable circular orbit (ISCO). Despite these advancements, a critical class of motion remains largely unexplored in this spacetime: periodic orbits Levin:2008mq . In the relativistic regime, generic bound orbits around black holes are not closed; instead, they typically precess. A periodic orbit occurs when the radial and angular oscillation frequencies form a rational ratio, causing the particle to retrace its path after a finite number of cycles. These orbits can be characterized by integers (w,z,v) representing whirl, zoom, and vertex numbers, creating a “periodic table” of orbital structures. Other types of bound orbits can often be viewed as perturbations of these fundamental periodic orbits. While such periodic orbits have been extensively investigated in various black hole spacetimes Misra:2010pu ; Haroon:2025rzx ; Zhang:2025wni ; Yang:2024lmj ; Gong:2025mne ; Chen:2025aqh ; Babar:2017gsg ; Liu:2018vea ; Wei:2019zdf ; Deng:2020yfm ; Zhou:2020zys ; Yao:2023ziq ; Tu:2023xab ; Junior:2024tmi ; QiQi:2024dwc ; Bravo-Gaete:2026com , their properties in the context of bumblebee gravity, particularly for the charged bumblebee black hole, remain unexplored. In this paper, we bridge this gap by conducting a detailed analysis of periodic orbits and their associated gravitational waveforms in this spacetime. The remainder of this paper is organized as follows. In Sec. II , we briefly review

Read the complete text